Argument Against Immigration

Improved Essays
People constantly immigrate to the United States with the ambition of gaining an ameliorated lifestyle. They arrive with the willingness to work, adapt to the American culture, and increase the amount of jobs. This postulates that permitting immigrants into the United States has its advantages, however Gene Callahan in his article “Immigration, Yes—and No: A Trimmer’s Case Against Open Borders and Closed Minds,” argues contra advocates for “open borders.” He avows that the United States faces a threat of having “too many immigrants,” ergo the U.S must avert this from occurring. Callahan’s antagonistic views revolve around the idea that certain issues should precede in the immigration policy. These issues include the “economic effects of immigration, …show more content…
Through a series of conclusions reinforced by historical events, Callahan emphasizes that the U.S. is heading towards the same direction as the empires did, years ago. He adverts that “The Western Roman Empire” had come “to an end in AD 476… due to invading barbarians” thus concluding that no regiment in the U.S, could lead to a country subjugated by immigrants. Callahan hinges on brief stories that meager in detail rather than accentuating on other factors other than immigration. He denotes these poorly detailed historic events, implying the preeminence of seeking control over today’s “invading barbarians.” In addition, Callahan flounders in implementing statistics and evidence when emphasizing that “immigration tends to lower the employment opportunities and wages” or “immigration increases supply of workers.” Subsequently, he constructs scenarios appealing to us through his use of common sense by noting that it would be facile to abetment a neighbor than “to help a homeless person in Latvia.” Though his argument dwells on constructed reasoning and common sense rather than actual evidence and statistics, his use of ethos and pathos clearly show that the purpose of his argument is to make a proposal to avoid an excessive amount of …show more content…
Callahan’s method of listing several empires, whose downfall were engendered by lost control over “immigration,” creates a sense of fear over the reader; alerting us that this could be impending for the United States. Furthermore, his claim that while “immigrants increase the lower the wage… will be,” establishes a feeling of insecurity at thought of the imminent problems immigrants cause. His ability to specify on points raises awareness, and evokes us to feel menaced, unsure about advocating for immigrants. He adds on “As their numbers increase… they will assimilate and…swamp the native culture with their own,” his use of persuasion and ethos triggers us to be agitated. Although allowing immigrants has its advantages, its disadvantages have a greater impact upon the American

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In the essay “Dawn’s Early Light” by Richard Rodriguez, the author demonstrates how the addition of immigrants has changed how Americans view themselves. Since the 20th century, the Mexicans were illegally employed in order to suit the American needs: crop harvesting and cheap laboring. Even if the Mexicans are “disrespectful to American laws,” their presence also indicates the hypocrisy of Americans as well – by illegally employing them. The addition of Mexican immigrants also caused the assimilation of Spanish culture across the United States; that is Spanish being the unofficially, second language of the United States. The Americans are also not in control of the movement at the borders since it is an “aspect of tragedy, of circumstances,”…

    • 184 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    He states that the impact of immigration has caused government officials to impose policies and that “assessing these policy prescriptions requires us to examine in some detail the state of illegal immigration” (377). Krikorian seems to observe that during recession most immigrants suffered unemployment. Yet, without doubt statistics prove that 21% of them were willing to work hard labor while only 5% of US citizens took these jobs (379). Considering the facts, Krikorian then examines the cause of the colonization…

    • 1076 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Immigration in The United States during the progressive era resulted in an essential transformative period during American history. The United States was a beacon of hope for immigrants looking for prosperity and a fresh start. However, during the years 1880 through 1925, important transformations within the American economy occurred there were important such as the successful and lucrative industrialization and tensions arose regarding the government’s negative feelings and toward the large flow of immigrants and new cultures. Once the frontier was closed and became irrelevant as the United States settled, there was an illusion of hope for people immigrating to the US.…

    • 1115 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The immigrants that entered the United States from the 1870’s through the 1920’s proved that they were different from any immigrants that came before them. This generation of immigrants was the most diverse group of people to enter this country during this period. Not only were they from different ethical backgrounds, they practiced different religions, their rules of life were different from ours, and among many other things. While the immigrants had, a hard time living in the US, they still defeated the odds and achieved economic success in multiple institutions. Unfortunately, because these groups of people changed the dynamics of the United States, Americans took that as a threat to the social, economic, religious, political, and overall…

    • 1059 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When discussing the topic of immigration every person has a different opinion. Many people believe Immigration should be illegal, however some believe it should be legal. These differences in opinions has caused Immigration to become a major issue all over the world. Immigration should be legal for many reasons. These reasons include: Immigrants create more businesses, It helps build the melting pot origin that America is based upon, and introduces the freedom of America to immigrants who may not have been as fortunate to experience from their former homes.…

    • 729 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He reflects on how controversial the topic of immigration has always been and how during recent times there has been a lot of discussion on the laws regarding the restriction of immigrants. The article discusses how even though it is perceived-so, immigrants are not a threat to the economy, as well as to employment opportunities for the native-born. The writer argues that immigrants complement natives by filling labor market as well as by providing jobs to them. He states that the public anxiety directed toward immigrants is immoral and the pros of immigration system by far outweigh the…

    • 1225 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    increased dramatically through immigration during the last few years and the country cannot keep up economically and socially. According to Roy Beck, “Based on opinion polls, it appears that most Americans consider themselves net losers and believe that the United States has become ‘a nation of too many immigrants’” (446). Beck states that “there are four national goals that Americans expect to achieve and illegal immigration is partly the cause for many Americans not attaining these goals” (450). They are: “(1) a middle-class society; (2) equal opportunity for the descendants of slavery; (3) harmonious and safe communities; and (4) a protected and restored natural environment…” (450).…

    • 317 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I’m sure we have all heard the phrase, “America is a country made up of immigrants”. While this may be true in terms of the history of the United States, but today it’s not that simple and it remains a highly debated topic that most can agree needs reform. Moreover, it draws many differing opinions on what actions are best in pursuit of the same goal. Immigration also brings many changes that raise fundamental questions for Americans. Who are we?…

    • 725 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sanchez George J. Sanchez is Professor of American Studies & Ethnicity, and History at the University of Southern California. The main idea is that we must weave together the insights of previous generations to begin to tell a whole story of immigration to the United States that includes everyone while taking account what pushed them to leave their nations and the factors that affected their integration into society. The reading was assigned to give us a broader view of immigration history, and to bring to light the conversation of assimilation into American society. Race and Immigration History was published in 1999. The text discusses the interconnected aspects of immigration and how the factors have dramatically changed with every new wave of immigrants.…

    • 1571 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Journey to Becoming an American In a time when the immigration train ran at full speed, America found itself introducing millions of foreigners to the world of freedom and opportunity. In multitudes, natives from countries such as Italy, Germany and Poland traveled to Ellis Island in search for something greater than what their modest indigenous land could offer. Unfortunately, when America began to accept immigration, it also found itself amid conflict, cultural discrimination and war. Many of these newly accepted immigrants came to achieve the “American Dream”, yet found themselves becoming a part of the war effort.…

    • 808 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Immigration has always been a part of American culture; in fact, it is the basis of how our country was formed. Immigration, both legal and illegal, has become a key focal point in today’s society. The arguments surrounding immigration and the legal -or illegal- standing of the immigrants, are various and vast in their quantities. Many concerns with immigration involve the social implications, economic impacts, and the possible discrepancies with national unity. In particular, the economic impact that immigrants have in our economy is one of the most widely debated subjects across news outlets and social media sources.…

    • 1294 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Argumentative Essay On Immigration

    • 1134 Words
    • 5 Pages
    • 5 Works Cited

    Many U.S. citizens believe that immigration is actually a negative influence on society. Some people see immigration as harmful to the American economy because they believe that these immigrants are taking away jobs from natives. This idea can be easily dismissed, as it is proven that even with the population at a far higher percentage (12 percent) of foreign-born Americans than in recent decades, the economy has still experienced a higher overall gross domestic product (GDP), higher GDP per person, higher productivity per person, and higher employment rates among Americans. Even if immigration is not the cause for this economic boom, it certainly should not be to blame for false perceptions of economic downfall. As far as social contributions, many traditional American citizens carry too much pride to admit that foreigners could have a positive influence on the society of the United States.…

    • 1134 Words
    • 5 Pages
    • 5 Works Cited
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    However, there are many reasons why immigration has positive effects on a…

    • 1863 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Immigration Issues Essay

    • 1305 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The following discussion will focus on immigration issues in the United States, specifically,…

    • 1305 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    As Borjas (1994) points out, there are three policy questions surrounding immigration of which economists are uniquely qualified to answer. First, what role do immigrants play in their new country’s economy? Second, what sort of effects does the labor market success or failure of immigrants have on the job prospects for natives? Third, how can immigration policy best be structured to benefit the receiving country? All of these issues are present in The Simpsons episode “Much Apu about Nothing.”…

    • 1340 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays