I Rigoberta Menchu Book Review

Improved Essays
I, Rigoberta Menchu An Indian Woman in Guatemala
I recently finished reading I, Rigoberta Menchu for another class I am taking. It was written by Rigoberta Menchu and was published in 1983. I felt like this was a good book to review in light of reading about Women’s Rights and Poverty in the modules. Take a person out of their element and force them into an environment that is far from their norm, and typically you’d expect them to fail.
“I was incapable of disobedience. And those employers exploited my obedience. They took advantage of my innocence.”(Menchu, 108) I have 5 sisters, and could not imagine them going through any of what we have covered in this class or even the things that Rigoberta experienced. When first moving here from American
…show more content…
Menchu experienced the debt and pay problem, which was basically a sneaky and despicable way to keep the workers who are already in debt in debt. This cycle of buying that you need on the finca like work shoes, food, or medicine for baby and putting that on a “tab” that you can pay off later. Not knowing that it comes of out of your paycheck, and whatever else you still owe puts you in debt. She also went into the city because she knew that it was there where she would find more than life on the finca. She had to put herself out there though, and step out of her own boundaries and security walls.
Menchu went into the city, despite her Father’s disliking to it and she flourished. Not to say that she was met with open arms and a parade, not at all; but she experienced something that she would have never learned on the finca, the fact that not everyone was the same. While there she met ladinos or non mestizo people, who were not out to hurt or disrespect Indians. She was able to open up herself and her eyes to the fact that struggle is everywhere even in impossible settings. Menchu learned spanish as well, which was a huge bonus in her

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    She had done a lot of research, and came up with a sentence that she thought was her own. In reality, it was something she had read earlier and forgotten about. She was almost kicked out, but saved by a professor who knew that she would never break character like that. This happened to my English teacher's college friend; she was accused of plagiarism when, in reality, it was all…

    • 1704 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Additionally, this addiction is due to their inability to save money as there are barriers surrounding their illegal line of work (Day 1999:146-147). Thus, these women live their lives in the here and now, as they are merely fixated on spending their earnings instead of saving and making future plans (Day 1999:146-147). These women believe that the faster they spend money the less likely it is to impact important relationship (Day 1999:148) The immediate spending of their earnings also make it difficult for them to set up “a more respectable future” (Day 1999:148). Women work as prostitutes in order to make enough money so they can move on with their lives but, “in the process of moving on, the future loses its attraction” (Day 1999:148). This illustrates how the London prostitutes have a temporal orientation towards the…

    • 2243 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ehrenreich Bad Jobs

    • 707 Words
    • 3 Pages

    ‘Bad jobs’ include jobs in the service sector such as being a cashier or waiter and or waitress. These jobs are physically demanding and can be deteriorating to the health of an individual. Living on minimum wage is nearly impossible and an individual has to be very cognizant with their spending habits, so they don’t run out of money. Many immigrants come to the United States looking for work since we have minimum wage laws that other countries lack. Many immigrants come work in the United States since the pay is better where they are from and return to their country when they have sufficient funds.…

    • 707 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    So if a person does not have enough knowledge to get this or that job he or she always has another opportunity - to prostitute himself or herself. Prostitution as a primitive way of making money; it is a problem that prevents the society from its perfection and development. Prostitution is obviously a negative phenomenon, demoralizing the society but is has actually become a “job” for many men and women and this fact cannot remain…

    • 1267 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    On the other hand, my mother was very closed and private. This idea of raising pure girls, marriage, and pregnant after marriage was an achievement. “I found this confusing because my parents never had a sex talk with me and it hurt to think they had such little trust in me. Years later, my mom would brag to her friends how her girls ‘didn’t have to get married because they were pregnant.’ She consider this a personal achievement,” (Pg. 72,…

    • 970 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He brought his wife like your own private goods to the United States, but he has never considered from the perspective of his wife. If she left her culture to a completely strange country, how will this affect Mrs. Sen’s mentality and lifestyle. She would be richer in America than she was in India materially. As her Indian family thought, “live in a palace, like a queen” (Lahiri 125) In fact, her life was restricted only in her house, and she did not even talk her innermost thought and feeling with friends because she have none. There are only two things that make her hopeful about life.…

    • 882 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    But, what about the rest of the people who have to wait for the bus, ride a taxi or even have to walk long distance to get back & forth. We live in a country we stereotype many different groups. Sometimes we could be right, some lazy people should go out and find a job and go through the application process. We all want to live the American dream, but how if the cost of the living is way too expensive for the work that is given to you? Such as waitressing, housekeeping or working as a sales associate at Wal-mart.…

    • 931 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    They were basically just handing out money so people could buy these expensive houses with high mortgages and then ending up being foreclosed on . Then the banks wouldn’t get their money back which put them in a crisis . Mortgage applications were not looked over carefully and anyone really could get accepted to have their own home . When all of this was going on banks kept mortgages on books and you would have to pay them and if you did not pay them they lost money . Now they sell yours loans and to investors and divide them .…

    • 1483 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Eviction tends to turn into a vicious cycle where the evictee cannot escape. They use more than half of their income to pay rent, get evicted for any number of reasons, and then are forced to move with no money for new rent. With no money for new rent, they cannot pay and are again evicted- never able to escape the cycle. Some may ask why tenants do not just save their money, but as Demond learned, “Saving and stability become wishes, and some days children go hungry because the rent eats first” (page unavailable). He continues to explain how the United States government has the money to fix much of this problem, but decides to spend the money elsewhere.…

    • 743 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    They also find that the layoffs are not worth the struggle. Caroline Matthews writes about the layoffs in a direct outlook on how it effects the companies in the long run. In her article “The Real Cost of Layoffs”, she points out that Bill Blizz, founder of Blizz Associates, found that layoffs in the end, wind up costing the company more in the long run. The company has to pay unemployment and it is just money being misused. They could use the money to get the company out of the jam they were in that they had to have layoffs.…

    • 1523 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays