Slave Taxation Argumentative Analysis

Great Essays
People of the United States, the time has come to unify this great nation under the a single name. This will not be easy; I am sure we are all aware of the difficulties we will encounter along the way. Questions such as How will states be re-admitted? and How will war debts be repaid? are no doubt on your minds and must be answered to progress. Fortunately, I have planned on how to solve these crises and hope to restore prosperity to these lands by the end of the century. One pressing concern is what to do with the states that participated in the Confederacy. I propose we act with mercy, and do not impose harsh reparations. Even though many state leaders supported the war, they should not be feared, as more revellions seem unlikely. Currently, …show more content…
After the war, many slaves have been freed to repay their work in the war. Slaves may see these free men and attempt to run away or become less productive. The easiest solution to this is to free all slaves and pay for their labor. However, much needs to change to lower the South’s reliance on slave labor and let this transition happen smoothly. To alleviate the use of slavery, I propose a slave tax. Henceforth, all goods created by using slave labor will be taxed 5%, and will increase to 200% over the next four years, with the goal of making hiring free men more profitable than using slaves. Anything made by freed men are not to be taxed. At random times, an inspector will check to see if slave labor is being used. Funds collected from this tax will pay for the inspections, infrastructure repairs for damages caused by the war, and war debts for both sides. While this tax may seem unfair to many Southern states, it helps them by letting slave owners choose when to switch to paying free men for labor instead of forcing them to switch before they are prepared to. An abrupt van on slavery may be detrimental and slow production in the South, hurting the entire nation’s …show more content…
However, this is the exact reason why the reparations should not be too harsh. Hard-to-meet conditions will breed animosity within the South and encourage more rebellions. By giving lenient terms, it gives the South a chance to rebuild and calm down. Although lenient terms may make it take longer to pay off debts, prosperity in the South is a much more important long-term benefit. Giving the ex-Confederate states a chance to keep their current governors and representatives will let the people feel well-represented and unlikely to

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Bitterly Divided Summary

    • 1260 Words
    • 6 Pages

    It came as quite a shock to me to find out that much of the South was not supportive of the Civil War in the first place, including my own hometown of Harris County, Georgia, where it was even stated that they were “Union loving people” (10). In reality, the main people who…

    • 1260 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Confederacy was more than a cluster of succeeded states who wanted to still be able to keep slavery. Anne Sarah Rubin’s work “A shattered Nation: The Rise & Fall of the Confederacy” dives into the sentiment value of the Confederacy to the citizens. In this work she uses journals, diaries, and speeches to construct a consensus of the Confederate people from eighteen sixty-one until eighteen sixty-eight Important to note that Confederacy did not exist with the provocation of war and it never lasted by it. The basis of the Confederacy foundation and principles were driven by wartime fears.…

    • 1722 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    shaped the Federal strategy that was ultimately used to defeat the Confederacy. It was a rational and enlightened policy. However, the events that happen in war are not easily controlled and conciliation faced two major challenges from the beginning. The first challenge stemmed from the mere existence of a competing policy hatched in Missouri. The second, more serious challenge came from the soldiers in the ranks.…

    • 676 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There is plentiful discourse as to why the Northern Union won the Civil War in 1865 against the Southern Confederacy. Although the military leadership from Abraham Lincoln and Ulysses S. Grant in the North and Jefferson Davis and Robert E. Lee in the South both impacted the outcome, Jefferson Davis’s poor political leadership both as president and commander in chief led to the Northern victory, particularly his defective judgements regarding military affairs and his moderate leadership as president that yielded tenuous relations with the Confederate people. According to David M. Potter, Jefferson Davis was not fit to command the Confederate Army. He was “his own secretary of war and his own general in chief” in which he included departmentalization…

    • 741 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Natural Law vs. Positive Law In spite of the personal opposition to the issue of slavery, President Abraham Lincoln took office in 1861 citing his constitutional duty of keeping the nation together rather than abolishing slavery. Lincoln intended to reunite the Union. Nonetheless, there were critical issues during the war, which compelled him to contend with slavery under his leadership.…

    • 513 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    After the Civil War, Congress issued a plan to restore the South. During this time period, also known as Reconstruction, many people questioned how the South should be dealt with. Should the Southern states that seceded be readmitted into the Union, or should they be treated as conquered territories? Since the South had lost their main source of profit, the labor slaves, after the Civil War, there was also the question of how to repair the Southern economy. Not everyone shared the same views on these questions, and these ideas would compete against each other during Reconstruction.…

    • 333 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Reconstruction Dbq

    • 2023 Words
    • 9 Pages

    The fall of the Confederacy…

    • 2023 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Commissioner of South Carolina, John Smith Preston, believes that “the South cannot exist without slavery…” (Page 72) which is why South Carolina was the first to succeed from the Union. Southerners did not want to put and end to slavery, therefore creating this uprising that influenced many factors such as states rights, the economy, and the state as a whole. With the many states succeeding in effort to dissolve the Union, politics played a big role between the North and the South. Dew realized that time and time again, in all the commissioners’ speeches and letters, slavery was always the main topic brought up along with other brief topics discussed in this book.…

    • 882 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    1. The Civil War was very different from past conflicts. To start, African Americans played a huge role in the Civil War. For the North, African Americans were enlisted in the army and fought alongside other Americans, and for the South, African Americans slaves were “camp servants,” for their masters. The slaves would cook meals, raise tents, and carry supplies for their masters.…

    • 1483 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    To My Honorable Congressman, The purpose of reconstruction has not been fully fulfilled leading me to conclude that we cannot end it just yet. I am writing to you today to inform you on my opinion about authorizing the removal of federal troops from reconstructed Southern states. So far Reconstruction has been successful, as it restored the Confederate states back into the Union to make the United States whole again, but there is still work to be done with integrating freedmen into society. I believe that if we further work on ending segregation, we can be reunited in society as well instead of just being reunited as states in a country.…

    • 660 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    By reducing the rights of slaves and giving an overwhelming majority of power to the southern states in the House of Representatives through the three-fifths clause, it has become clear that the early American viewpoint was that we needed to keep slavery for as long as we can. As slave labor being the number one source of plantation workers in the south, by removing them entirely, the income once obtained by these landowners would be decreased siverly, and the north knew it. By removing slavery from the early American lifestyle, the economic boost we were going through would drastically decrease from where they…

    • 1585 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the southern states that sided with the Confederacy, the Civil War was viewed as a “Lost Cause.” Despite losing the war, the South applauded the “chivalric Southern soldiers” who fought against the “rapacious Northern industrial machine”(Wills, 2015) in defence of their state rights. The Union may have ratified the 13th, 14th, and 15th Amendments to abolish slavery, but it could not erase the intolerance that still existed in the country. Thus, the amendments held little power over the southern ideals.…

    • 521 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Black Loyalists

    • 1931 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Even when most Blacks were skilled at what they did such as carpentry and blacksmithing after the war, “blacks earned as much as half of what a white tradesman could expect…” With the exception of fishing, no matter what the Blacks did, they would always be of lesser value than anybody. Now that the Blacks received their lower pay and worked countless hours a week, many of them could not provide for their families with such little pay. This then relates back to selling themselves as indentured servants and working again for someone. Now in reality some black did in fact receive their freedom. For example, on December 14th, 1775, “the said [Cato Hamanday] has hereby his Excellency Sir Guy Carleton 's Permission to go to Nova Scotia, or wherever else he may think proper.”…

    • 1931 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    First, Abraham Lincoln’s election as president was a huge blow to the southern community, as it made them nervous he would eventually abolish slavery. They considered this a threat to their luxury of enjoying the profit of slavery. Although Lincoln was clear about his opposition of slavery he also admitted he had not intention of messing with the South’s slave system. For example, Lincoln said, “I have no purpose, directly or indirectly, to interfere with the institution of slavery in the States where it exists (Hine, 2014).” Be that as it may, the South was not convinced.…

    • 860 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Between 1861 and 1877, the United States experienced Reconstruction after one of the most brutal Civil War to date. The North and South division over slavery provoked the South to seceding and becoming the Confederate States of America. There was many positive and negative aspects to the Civil War. Some positive outcomes from the Civil War was the newfound freedom of slaves and the improvement in women’s reform. Some negative outcomes from the Civil War was the South’s loss of land and crop from the devastated land left behind and the South’s hold on to racism.…

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays