How Does George Make Bad Decisions

Improved Essays
There is a major difference between killing someone by accident, versus killing someone on purpose. In the novel, Of Mice and Men, written by George Steinbeck, two young men, one of which, Lennie, was mentally handicapped found themselves in trouble after Lennie accidentally killed the ranch owner’s daughter-in-law. Lennie killed someone by mistake---George pulled the trigger with intention. George’s brash decision to take Lennie’s life should be regarded as a bad decision because he was feeling and not thinking, he had alternative options, and because Lennie had never consented in this.
It is easy to infer that George was listening, mostly, to his heart in this situation that he was to his mind. George had not even had time to think properly on a decision that would carry so many moral ramifications. Time Magazine’s David Hume says about the function of the brain during life and death situations, “We like to think our views on right and wrong are rational, he said, but ultimately they are grounded in emotion.” This proves that George could not logically and rationally think about making the decision that he did. These factors, however, are just provide a small portion of the overwhelming evidence that George made a poor decision to murder Lennie.
…show more content…
George and Lennie could have hidden in their secret place until the heat died down, or even just runaway. In the book, it said that Lennie and George were the only ones that knew about that spot and therefore, they could have hidden there. Also based on the time period, they could have slipped away pretty easily given the low security innovations. George had plenty of options that would protect the life of Lennie, but instead decided that he would be the overrule of Lennie's life and take mere human existence into his own

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    George was the one who watched over lennie so he felt that it was his decision on whether he should kill him or not. It’s easy to tell that George is Lennie’s care taker because George and Lennie travel together and George makes sure they stick together and that they are both safe. Another reason that you could tell the George takes care of lennie is because George promised Lennie Aunt Clara that he would watch over lennie. And lastly Lennie listens to everything that George tells him to do “Jus tell Lennie what to do…

    • 723 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many people have wondered should George have shot Lennie? While I am upset that he shot Lennie, after thinking for awhile I think that he made the right decision. One reason that I think this is because if they tried to run away together they would have eventually been caught. Partly due to the fact that they are dealing with a murder more people will be looking for them and they didn’t get a very big head start. If they did escape though they would be looking over their shoulder and lived a unhappy fearful life.…

    • 553 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I, personally, don’t think George was justified in killing Lennie, but some of the evidence from the text proves otherwise. Most people saw Lennie as a child and not a grown man, which is understandable, and that may be one reason why George wanted to get rid of him. Many times he was called a child or people would say he acted like one. For example, when Lennie brought the puppy in the bunkhouse and George made him take it back, Slim said, “He’s jes’ like a kid, ain’t he.” Lennie was constantly in trouble which made it hard for George to keep a job for long.…

    • 190 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Just because Lennie didn’t know what he was doing, he still did something bad that led them to have to skip town. Another reason is Lennie would’ve been tortured anyway. Curley said he was going to hunt him down because he killed Curley’s wife. “He looked down at her, and carefully he removed his hand from over her mouth” (Steinbeck 23). He killed Curley’s wife and George knew that Curley wasn’t going to handle it very well and knew he was going to torture him or something.…

    • 205 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Should George have killed Lennie,? Absolutely not, it is not right to kill people almost ever, reason why well the obvious he had no idea what he was doing he is not the brightest person, George was supposed to take care of Lennie, Well he is getting the Death Penalty for killing a person that is not right So first things first he is not a intelligent person…

    • 342 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    After Lennie killed Curley's wife, the other guys had their mind set on killing Lennie for what he had done, but George decided he should do it himself so it wouldn't hurt him as bad as knowing that he let other people do barely know Lennie, do it. Even though George knew he was better off without Lennie in his life he's even told Lennie “I could be living so good without you getting me in trouble and outta a job” (Steinbeck). Honestly George knows he’d be better off in his life without Lennie,but he doesn't want to leave Lennie because he knows he would be alone and put in place for the mentally impaired people. Although, George wants to keep one job and possible get a wife and have some children, but he can't do that because of Lennie and his way of not being able to keep a job.…

    • 967 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    George and Lennie have been together for a long time, he even considers Lennie as his cousin, since Lennie didn’t have anywhere to go George took the full responsibility to take care of him since he cannot live on his own because of his disability. When George kills Lennie at the end, I consider that as an act of mercy because first of all the Mob was about the make Lennie suffer for what he did to Curley’s wife, second of all Lennie became a danger to the society and for himself third of all George couldn’t take care of Lennie anymore and Last George knew that he won't be able to make Lennie’s dream came true. First of all, since Lennie kill Curley wife’s accidently, George had to go hide in the forest because he knows that we will be in trouble, when George finds out that Curley wife is dead and that Lennie is the murder George didn’t know what to do, he knows Curley wouldn’t have any mercy for George if he finds out. George didn’t have any option to kill Lennie by his own hand to make him suffer less.…

    • 391 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    George knew he had to take Lennie's life himself or he would have a painful death, that was not something he wanted for Lennie. George taking Lennie's life was him stepping in and being the caretaker that he has to be for Lennie and protecting him from the other guys. Even though some people may say it’s wrong that George shot Lennie, he had to do it. George would have hated himself for letting them do it and Lennie suffering. One reason that George was justified for killing Lennie is because Lennie would have gotten himself into even more trouble and would have gotten himself killed somewhere else, and that is even if he made it out of the situation he was already in, which he would not have.…

    • 605 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In extreme cases should killing ever be justified? Yes, because if someone with A IQ under 70 kills someone then someone who cares about them helps out by killing them so they…

    • 499 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the book, “Of mice and men,” George is forced to make a tough decision at the end of the book; Run and potentially let Lennie suffer the consequences of his actions, or to simply put him out of his misery, and not suffer at all. George ended up making the decision to painlessly end the life of Lennie so he wouldn’t have to suffer from the potential consequences he would have to face if he were left alive. George made the wrong decision. Previously, the two were in a similar situation, and they were able to run from the problem. What makes it different now?…

    • 637 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    George kinda did the right thing, I mean there were other options but Lennie killed Curley’s wife, she scared him and Lennie really does not know his strength. Like what happened in Weed, that lady’s dress looked very soft and Lennie has a thing for soft things but she scared him and he did not know what to do so he held on to her dress, who could really blame him for that. Did George do the right thing?…

    • 691 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    I do not believe that people with mental retardation should be able to obide by the same rules as a normal person. People with mental retardation do not have the same ability to react as quick and accurate as a normal person does. A good example from the story is, Lennie could not remember much he was a very forgetful man. Lennie would not be able to survive on his own he needs someone like George to be with him to help him with things. Lennie did not think before he acted in the story.…

    • 253 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Best Friends Until the End Imagine having to kill your best friend. In Of Mice and Men, George made a hard decision which was if he should kill his best friend, Lennie. George killing Lennie was justified because had to think about Lennie’s life ahead if he didn 't make this choice. George making this choice was right because Lennie had unknowingly brought a threat among people, Lennie had died much quicker and painless, and Lennie was basically George’s responsibility.…

    • 1150 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Firstly, by killing Lennie, George was protecting others, Lennie had a murder chain going on he went from a mouse, to a puppy to go on to kill curley’s wife, the boss's son wife, with all of that in mind, Lennie did not mean to commit those murders he just wasn’t aware of his own…

    • 827 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Same goes for George when he killed Lennie; it would be super emotionaly to go through with it. But he did, he had to do it. We all know we aren’t all going to live forever; it’s just not going to happen, and death is one thing we have to face when its time. When it’s time to go it’s time to go. But George made sure before Lennie died, he wanted him to be relaxed and happy before it was Lennie’s time to…

    • 1240 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays