How Did George Kill Lennie Justified In Of Mice And Men

Improved Essays
Is putting someone out of their misery the right thing to do, or it it wrong to kill someone? This is what George Milton is faced with in John Steinbeck’s Novella, Of Mice and Men. George was forced to kill Lennie at the end and some readers thought that George’s action were unacceptable. However they did not realize that George had to kill him to protect him from others that would do harm to him. Therefore George’s decision to kill Lennie is justified because he was doing it to protect him from the other men that would want him to suffer, he needed to do it himself or he would feel guilty about not killing him, and that Lennie would mess up again and that because of Lennie’s actions, the dream would never come true.

The first reason that George”s actions were justified is that he knew that Lennie was going to mess up again because he does not know about his strength. When George and Slim looked at the dead body of Curley’s wife Slim said “Maybe like that time in Weed that you was tellin’ about”(Steinbeck,97). Slim’s comment shows that both him and George knew that Lennie would do something like the time in Weed again even if he did not mean to. Given at the end of the book that Lennie has killed a lot of mice a puppy and a woman, George knows
…show more content…
Some readers think that George made a bold and harsh decision to kill Lennie himself and get rid of him for good. However, George made that decision because he wanted protect Lennie from the other men. “But Candy said excitedly, ‘we oughtta let ‘im get away. You know that Curley. Curley gon’ta wanta get “im lynched. Curley’ll get ‘im killed.’”(Steinbeck,95). When Candy says that, George realizes that he needs to be the one to kill Lennie because if he does not kill him, then the other men will make him suffer for what he

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    George made the right decision by shooting Lennie Because. George did not want Lennie to suffer for what curly had in store for him so think of Lennie death as a mercy kill fast and less suffering also if George wouldn't have shot Lennie he could get tortured in many different ways. But most people say that George and Lennie should have run away instead of killing Lennie. My first reason that George should have taken Lennie life is that first of all. If Lennie had tried to escape with George both of the men would be considered wanted so it would be hard to have any type of job or place to live because their reputation would be murderers, But George thought that running away would be a bad idea so he did not want Lennie to deal with all this so he took his life.…

    • 552 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It took a lot of sacrifices and strength to kill someone you deeply care about which George has to go through. A bad friend would kill someone just for their selfish reasons but in this case Gorge did it to help Lennie: for Lennie 's sake and the rest of the people. Overall, Friendship is formed in different ways that people may perceive that friendship as bad or good. However, in the novella “ Of Mice and Men” it shows us how George was a good friend to Lennie. He finds ways to get Lennie out of trouble, warns him to not do certain things so he would not get in trouble, and sticks by his side.…

    • 1296 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    So it would only be logical for Romeo to die. Instead of death Princes punishment for Romeo was banishment from Verona. I believe that princes punishment is appropriate because he killed Tybalt like the law would, he was trying to avoid fighting, and he listened to the rules that the Prince made. If Romeo would have face the punishment of death the story would look a lot different. If Romeo died then Juliet would not end up getting set with Paris because her parents think she is sad over Tybalt’s death instead of Romeo’s…

    • 724 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    For example, the first time Lennie messed up with a girl, he wanted to touch her dress but she thought he would rape her. To have George and Lennie beaten, all the men in that town sought for them. Then the second time is when Lennie was killed for accidentally killing Curly’s wife. George knew that Lennie would make more mistakes in every workplace. It could have been worse if George hadn’t shot Lennie.…

    • 840 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    If that thou be’st a devil, I cannot kill thee” (5.2.299-300). Othello goes on to stab Iago the reader does not know if he dies or not. Othello believes that Iago is the devil for the havoc he has wreaked on him. Othello does not want Iago to die because he knows Iago will be tortured and left for dead by the new Governor Cassio. Iago was so close to succeeding but a fatal flaw was when Emilia decided to break her silence.…

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    At times, though it may seem that Hamlet has gone truly mad, he is still aware of his actions. When he is talking to the Queen after the performance of The Mousetrap, he stabs and kills Polonius. Though he meant to do this, he wasn’t aware that it was Polonius behind the curtain - he thought it was the King listening in on their conversation, instead. As much as he disliked Polonius, he wasn’t aiming to kill an innocent man. So this action, one that could be seen as insane, was a misjudged, yet justified action, for he thought he was actually avenging the death of his father.…

    • 1323 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The guys would have done the same thing that George did, Slim told Curley after seeing Lennie dead, “A guy got to sometimes.” (SteinBeck 107). Slim is saying that sometimes you have to do what you think might be right. In conclusion, George did make the right decision to kill Lennie, so he can stop suffering and finally rest. If he would have let Lennie live, Lennie would have gone to jail, be hanged or be beaten to death. In George and Lennie’s world, people would not hire or get near Lennie because he is mentally challenged.…

    • 604 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the short story The Bargain by Guthrie, Jr. moral responsibility is the topic of discussion on who is responsible for Slade's death. Morally responsible means to be deserving of blame for an act that was committed. Many believe that Slade is solely responsible for his own death, however, Mr. Baumer is morally responsible for the death of Slade because Mr. Baumer knew exactly what he was doing and he knew that Slade would drink out of the barrel if he thought it was liquor. Some may say that Mr. Baumer is not to blame; however, he has reasons to hate and want to commit murder against Slade. In the beginning of the story, Guthrie introduces the characters and how they act right away.…

    • 827 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The decision that George did for Lennie was merciful, he was killing Lennie just to save him from the painful death that Curley was planning for him. In addition, if George has not killed Lennie, his best friend might end up in a terrible place. “An’ s’pose they lock him up an’ strap him down and put him in a cage. That ain’t no good, George” (Steinbeck, 97). Slim explains that if Curley captures him and did not kill Lennie, he might end up being…

    • 1001 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    His goal was not to receive any personal gain from Caesar’s death; he would rather be at fault for murder than have his people live under tyranny. Brutus was also the last of the conspirators to stab Caesar. Even though he felt guilt for killing his friend, he would not let the means of reaching of his goals override his desire to help…

    • 1130 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays