Homosexuality In Annie Proulx's 'Brokeback Mountain'

Improved Essays
Homosexuality has been an overly heated debate since the beginning, and it still is in some parts of the world. Society believes that a man and a woman are predestined for each other. that a correct union can only be between a man and a woman. These societal norms leave those who do not fall into the category confused and lonely. Consequently, they hide their true self and take on a double role. Similarly, Annie Proulx suggests the challenges men, who fail to abide by societal norms, face about their sexual identity in the story of “Brokeback Mountain”. Ennis and Jack both struggle with their homosexuality due to the homophobic society they live in. Although the story defies archetypal ideas of masculinity as it puts forth two men trapped in …show more content…
His fear of being perceived differently makes him take on this role and play it correctly. He puts forth a man who is both that is “inured to [the] stoic life” and a hard worker. He works on a ranch and lives life by not letting his emotions get in the way of cowboy life, all of which are characteristics associated to men in society. However, when both Ennis and jack are leaving Brokeback Mountain, “Ennis [feels] like someone [is] pulling his guts out…” This passage demonstrates how Ennis’s masculine traits are superficial due to the fact that they merely exist on the surface level. He is not truly inured to the stoic life since he has emotions. The words “pulling his guts out,” suggest the pain he is going through. If Ennis were a true cowboy, he would not let a farewell affect him as much as it did. Consequently, he is only embracing the superficial traits associated to a cowboy in order to show society that he is normal. Furthermore, he embraces the cowboy life because he fears that society will consider him wrong. Since cowboys are generally associated with characteristics that men are expected to have such as strength, by taking up the role of a cowboy, nobody can suspect Ennis’s homosexuality. Therefore, Ennis’s “rough-mannered” and “rough-spoken” characteristics are simply implemented into his life to revoke any assumptions linked to his sexuality. Finally, …show more content…
The relationship between them is not a normal relation since Ennis is not as invested in the relationship as Alma. The fact that “…[he] never brings any trouts home” (126) from his several fishing trips suggests that Alma does not hold a great importance in his life. He is married to her simply to show that he is the epitome of a man. Since a man and a woman are predestined for each other, by marrying Alma, his homosexuality remains a secret between Jack and him. As a result, his relationship with Alma represents a superficial relationship because there is no connection or affection between them. He is just playing the role of a husband, which society expects him to play. Additionally, the fact that he does not love her proves that this marriage is just for show. Alma does not fall into the category of things that is near Ennis’s heart. Only “His horse, his daughters” (122) truly have a place in his heart. This suggests that he is taking on the role of a husband to conceal his true identity. Finally, Ennis’s character manifests superficial masculine traits in his relationship due to his true identity, which is

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Being the man to a cheating wife not only shows that a man cannot control his household but that he is not providing his woman with her necessities. “If wives do fall. Say that they [husbands] slack their duties” (4.3.86) because “wives have sense [desires] like them” (4.3.93). If she had everything she needed, there would be no need for another…

    • 1269 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The issue was how people would perceive him negatively in a society that stood against transgender or even homosexuality. He didn’t do this for the cameras or for fame that sprinted his way, but for the satisfaction of receiving love from his partner. Chaz is a kind and loving man who hardly cared what people would say about him. It took a lot for him to also open out in public to the media about his transitioning. Jennifer his girlfriend stood there by his side since a little kid.…

    • 1035 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    When confronting Rose, he tries to explain why he had gone ahead with seeing Alberta and this leads to his next and most prominent flaw – self-centeredness. He cannot get over many things that did not go right in his life which is why he has to be the center of the conversation. In essence, this is why he had the encounter with Alberta, not because he did not love Rose, but because he was bored and tired of his life, trying to find an escape from the pressures of his life, which all people want. Although he is not the perfect character, he did the best that he thought he could be. In the end, one can only truly judge Troy based on his childhood and how those experiences have helped influence his actions toward his family and…

    • 1339 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This shift in the determining factors of sexual morality shows that not only it is completely arbitrary, as sexual acts are only assigned meaning through social and cultural contexts, but also that individuals became labeled as deviant and were thought of as fundamentally different from “normal” people who engaged in traditional displays of intimacy. In American culture, generally it is only married, heterosexual couples that are safe from having their sexual activities labeled as “immoral” (Fischer, p. 38). Standards of sexual morality are determined and passed down by those in groups that hold societal power. Applying a sticky label of immorality, such as “slut” or “fag”, allows groups and individuals to assert dominance over…

    • 1266 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Not even the all-important task of finding his father surpassed the importance of fulfilling his sexual needs. Many recognize a lustful relationship to be shallow and brief, having no respect for both the individual and their partner. It is condemned by society, but Saber continues to chase this particular relationship. He does not take cultural normality into consideration, but rather embraces his independence to pick what he…

    • 1503 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Jealous of his wife's affection toward Robert and unaware of the emotional connection they share, the narrator is not eager to welcome the man into his home. "I wasn't enthusiastic about his visit. He was no one I knew. And his being blind bothered me. My idea of blindness came from the movies.…

    • 1083 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Throughout A History of Rasselas, the dangers of removing oneself from the world becomes a prevailing theme. One first sees this in Rasselas himself, as Rasselas resents being captive in the happy valley because he does not have access to the outside world. Next, consider Rasselas’ conversation with the hermit. The hermit laments to Rasselas, “I have been long comparing the evils with the advantages of society, and resolve to return into the world to-morrow. The life of a solitary man will be certainly miserable, but not certainly devout.” This startles Rasselas as he assumed that the hermit would be living purposefully - after all, he made the choice of solitude himself, he is very learned, and he has everything a man could want.…

    • 1906 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Grant also feels very useless, and he does not understand why he was put into a position where he would have to interact with Jefferson. Since Grant has an attitude of self-absorption and anger it’s making it a lot harder for him to face his fears and actually overcome them. He just needs to have hope, and stop thinking that making change is impossible to do. Before long, Jefferson starts to grow on Grant. “Do you believe I’m your friend, Jefferson?” I asked him.…

    • 1126 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Have you personally ever had to choose between being a friend or doing your duty? Many people believe that Billy was a decent and dandy guy to have as a friend. These people believe that the captain should not have followed the law nor let his friendship cloud his judgment. Since Billy did kill someone, he had to be punished by the captain because it was his duty. Therefore,the captain should have followed the law and not been a friend to Billy for three reasons: The captain had an obligation to his crew, no one can receive special treatment, and the law demanded it from him as a captain.…

    • 606 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    (Chapter 8) He fantasizes about romantic love with Lenina, yet, he doesn 't have the courage to fight the world 's value. Even though Marx shows his strong desire to fight his boss in his inner thoughts, he also fears the consequences of the rebel action. On the contrary, John speaks out for his desire of romantic love to Lenina. However, because Lenina is like the others who are highly constructed by the world 's values, it is impossible for her to accept John 's idea of love. On the other hand, Mustapha Mond is another character who share common traits as John.…

    • 939 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays