Hmong Noncompliance Case Study Morally Wrong

Improved Essays
Lia's doctors assumed she would die and allowed the family to take her home. She did not die, however, for another twenty-six years. Her family continued to love and care for her, and each year a tvix neeb held a ceremony to ease her suffering.
The Hmong's tenacity and unwillingness to surrender helped them to survive for thousands of years. However, it also made them wary of submitting to doctors' orders. A compounding factor in Hmong noncompliance was their taboo against many western medical procedures. For instance, they believed that the body has only a finite amount of blood and that frequently taking one's blood can be harmful or fatal. They thought surgery might lead to disfigurement not only in this lifetime but also in subsequent

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    But not all can understand Indigenous disadvantage is a result of the nations history of colonisation over 60,000 years ago (Behrendt, 2012). The most immediate consequence of the colonisation was a wave of epidemic diseases including small pox, measles, sexually transmitted diseases and influenza that spread and destroyed many Indigenous communities (Harris, 2013). This era is evident as to why many Indigenous people don’t trust and therefore don’t use mainstream health care services today, because they don’t feel safe from racism, being stereotyped, as well as the Western approach to healthcare, ‘it can feel alienating and intimidating’ (Narine, 2013). A sterile hospital environment conjures up many memories of racism and mistreatment (Reading and Wien, 2009). Some fear they will never leave a hospital alive, many believe ‘hospital is code word for the place you go die’ (Reading and Wien, 2009)…

    • 1162 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Hmong believed that epileptic people could see things that others cannot. They knew that it was a bad disease, but they also saw a potential in this disease. It got to the point of being so bad that they had made so many…

    • 1049 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Low income and/or minority patients are less likely to receive preventative care due to lack of adequate insurance (medical coverage) and language barrier issues. Abuse, violence and alcohol and/or drug use/abuse is less likely to be discussion topics by doctors when caring for minority groups. Refugees from Sudan are less likely to receive/administer accurate full doses of prescribed medications due to history of shortages and/or limited health care. Spiritual powers and religious practices and beliefs shape how many cultures supplement their medical care. Complementary alternative medicines are used in many countries in place of western medical care.…

    • 925 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Cultural Competence 101 The medical biographic novel” The spirit catches you and you fall down,” by Anne Fadiman is a magnificent time capsule of the experiences faced by the Hmong peoples during their migration to America. However amusing the novel was from a literary standpoint, the novel described many deeply discerning attributes of the American health care system and Social Work arena of that time period. Although this novel describes the journey of one peoples immigration to America this story really speaks to the experiences of many migrate populations to the United States.…

    • 1464 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Fadiman in her novel included an anecdote that reveals the secret to prevent the formation of a dichotomy of medical foreigncy, either be it the foreigncy of a doctor 's medical diagnosis or the foreigncy of a patient background. According to ethnographer Conquergood, who at the time was working at a refugee camp in Ban Vinai, “considered his relationship with the Hmong to be a form of barter and invigorating dialogue, with neither side dominating.” He stated that Western practitioners failed with foreign patients due to doctors believing they held all knowledge rather than viewing the relationship as mutual learning. I completely agree with Conquergood 's philosophy and the means of viewing the medical practice as a cultural compromise that requires an interactive exchange of information. Similar to the means that patients in Ban Vinai perhaps felt more confident and willing to conform to Western medicine with Conquergood’s presence, my own mother resonates with such an experience.…

    • 989 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Anne Fadiman’s book The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down, tells the story of the clashing of cultures between the Hmong culture and Western culture through the lens of medicine. Fadiman’s plot revolves around Lia, a Hmong girl born with severe epilepsy, and the tales of Hmong culture, allowing the reader to understand the actions of Lia and other Hmong, like her parents, as their culture heavily influences their beings. Thus I propose that this book remain a summer reading requirement as the book contains a unique correlation of culture and medicine, the themes are straightforward to analyze and provides a gradual preparation for the incoming year. The book itself consists of an interesting format, switching back and forth between plot…

    • 743 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Introduction The film The Split Horn The Life of a Hmong Shaman in America focuses on how health and illness is dealt with in the Hmong culture. It is about the life of a Hmong family who moved to Appleton Wisconsin from Laos and how they are adapting to this new place. The journey of a Shaman 's family is explored and it is expressed that they have their own set of traditions in their culture but when this family moved to America it was learned that it is difficult to carry out traditions. Illnesses are looked at from different viewpoints across different cultures and depending on an individual 's culture, explanations for health are looked at and treated differently. This family learns that it is difficult to adjust to the American lifestyle,…

    • 777 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Asian American Struggles

    • 2239 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Invisible and Struggling Asian Americans are generally known for their diligent work ethics, their high levels of education and the high paying job that follows from their education. This stereotype is even supported with statistical data, Asian Americans holding a higher median household income, $66,000, compared to the general population’s $49,800 (Pew Research Center). With a rise in Asian immigrants and the Asian American populace as a whole and how they are projected to be the largest minority group by 2055 (Cepeda), the U.S. economy seems to have a bright future ahead. However, the well-known fallacy of stereotypes is that they have their exceptions and also that statistics sometimes can be framed to skew the situation. Hunger and…

    • 2239 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Essay On Hmong Culture

    • 2194 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Things such as dabs (evil spirts) can harm one of the twelve souls needed, “to be intact in order for a person to be in good health (Lee and Pfeifer, 2009/10).” Other reasons for illness could be spiritual imbalance from: fear, sadness or loneliness (Australian Centre for International and Tropical Health at the University of Queensland, 2003). That’s not to say that the Hmong doesn’t consider certain injuries to the body as separate, like cuts or other external injuries and infectious diseases. Diseases like TB and Chickenpox are known to the Hmong, along with heredity, weather, stress and reckless behavior (Australian Centre for International and Tropical Health at…

    • 2194 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One great example given to us in our text this week is pertaining to diabetes among American Indians. One of the reasons for not seeking medical help is distrust for White authorities or for the medical system in general. According to Henderson, “One subject said that she would not take her (changed) diabetes medicine because she felt that the doctors were experimenting on her.” (p. 561). Thank you for your response!…

    • 831 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    This shows how the gap between the cultures is unbridgeable, however I do beehive that more could have been done in order to help Lia. There needed to be a middle ground in which both the parents and the doctors could agree on. 4. This book, from the very beginning provoked thoughts some ethnocentric towards the Hmong culture. I was clouded by my own culture in which I was raised , when I read this book for the culture is different, but each one has its own unique traits.…

    • 1354 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Caddo Nation Case Study

    • 1758 Words
    • 8 Pages

    According to Andrews and Boyle, Native Americans believe that heath is associated with the mind, spirit and connections with the creation and creator. Suppose a Caddo Indian was stricken with illness today, different ceremonies like seat lodging, traditional herbs, songs, dances, and prayers are used for healing (Andrews and Boyle 2012). In healthcare facilities clinicians should give patients time, space, and privacy to respect the family’s traditional healers; clinicians should also never interfere or interrupt the healer’s rivals so families will not distrust. (HCC 2013). Ultimately, the Caddo believe that the balance of harmony can be returned back to one’s life through rituals and…

    • 1758 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    They believe in giving birth to their children at home without any form of medicine or help. They believe that children go through medical issues because of the way a placenta has been buried. These beliefs may keep the Hmong people from going to hospitals. Not only may their customs create a health disparity but also many of the doctors are not aware of certain culture customs. Not speaking the English language or providing translators who speak the Hmong language, can have its disadvantages when communicating health issues or concerns.…

    • 1050 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Supplementing mainstream medical treatments with nontraditional medical treatments can demonstrate understanding and respect for the patient as well. As Dr. Alvord discovered, all of the aforementioned factors strengthen patient-provider relationships through cultural competence, in turn positively impacting patient outcomes and adherence to treatment. As a Navajo, Dr. Alvord’s background was similar to most of her patients, which allowed her to easily gain their trust and demonstrate cultural competence. Her environment gave her an advantage that providers working with patients from cultures different from their own may not have. Nevertheless, Dr. Alvord’s insights would be beneficial for any future, or currently licensed,…

    • 1956 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the play Yellow Face, David Henry Hwang tries to address the cultural problem of discrimination in the media against the Chinese. David Henry Hwang tries to show injustices of the united states when it comes to the Broadway show who tried to cast a white man as the main role in the Asian Broadway play. He hoped to end discrimination, and try to get the roles filled by real Asian-American’s than by men in so called yellow face. He tries to show how easy it is for anyone to pass themselves off as multiple races, and it is a very narrow problem when it comes to this specific ethnicity. The very thing that is making the issue so complex is the fact this is such a sensitive issue when it comes to the general public about discrimination.…

    • 793 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays