Hegemonic Masculinity In Domestic Violence

Superior Essays
Domestic violence plays an enormous problem in society, specifically when there is no set explanation to why it occurs. By analyzing the role of hegemonic masculinity, patriarchy, and traditional gender roles as it pertains to domestic violence, this essay intends to expound on how the three interlace to perpetuate the domestic violence cycle. Hegemonic masculinity rose out of the post-World War II era as the idea of the “real man”, and the idea that the real man is not peaceful, nurturing, or indecisive, nor a sissy, crybaby, or loser” (Messner & Greemberg, 2015, p. 10). Rather, the “real man” is a man who is seen as someone who has the speed and strength of an athlete, as having a large income, authority, charm, loyalty for family, manual …show more content…
There are many examples than can demonstrate the use of these terms into everyday society to serve as explanations to domestic violence, historic concepts of traditional gender roles play a large part in the violence by men towards women. In an historic standpoint, men have ways they are supposed to act such as asserting their dominance. In a study conducted by Peralta and Tuttle, interviews where conducted with men who were convicted of intimate partner violence; in these interviews the men described their situations and some reasoning why they lashed out on their partner (2013). During the interviews a man named Jerry stated that to feel like a “man” you need to have money and a job because it’s a mans natural instinct to provide and when you’re not doing that it hurts your pride (Peralta & Tuttle, 2013, p. 264). This response demonstrates how a man believes he should present himself and how that can put stress on him and can cause him to become violent with his intimate partner, because it is the only way he can feel like a man. With other interviewees the problem focused on the ideology of traditional roles that women believe a man should have, or society, puts stress on the man when he or his partner feel …show more content…
265) This caused him to turn to violence against her, because she was the on perpetuating the incident by not letting him feel like a man. According to these factors Peralta and Tuttle concluded that it is clear that “control/domiance was intertwined with traditional constructions of masculinity, namely the inability to achieve hegemonic masculinity which results in violence” (2010, p. 271). These traditional roles also are similar as todays hegemonic masculinity and serves as many of the same gender “rules” such as a man should be tough and now week. Due to these concepts of masculinity Peralta and Tuttle state that men have the choice to adopt or approximate hegemonic masculinity or they can distance themselves from harmful forms of masculinity and expressions, however different factors can be expanded on what role a male choses (2010, p. 270). Looking at our society it is known that we live in an offspring of a patriarchy society, where men have the power in controlling different aspects in society due to the history of masculinity traditionally and hegemonic viewing them as leaders and aggressive. However with this becomes a powerful role in society considering that according to Umberson, Anderson,

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    There have been countless cases of women suffering through domestic violence by their husbands or boyfriends because these men believe they need to physically dominate their partner in order to feel like a man. Early ideas about masculinity generally revolved around the stigma of being superior to one’s girlfriend, wife, or significant lover. It was once believed that physically dominating one’s woman was a sign of masculinity and power, and even today, some people still believe this. In “Two Ways a Woman Could Get Hurt: Advertising and Violence,” Kilbourne includes numerous ads that degrade women by displaying a man who physically dominates the woman in a violent way. These advertisements send men the message that being violent towards a woman is sexy and alluring.…

    • 980 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Questions can vary from: Why is domestic violence still a big problem in the United States and all over the world? Why do so many men abuse, physically, emotionally, verbally, and other ways, the women and girls, and the men and boys, that they claim to love? What 's going on with men? The act of overcoming gender violence is to stop…

    • 1369 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Berkel’s assertion accurately pinpoints the key reason as to why men act and think in a hostile manner towards their significant other. The influence they have experience throughout their growth and maturity reflects the way they act and execute their behavior towards women. Thereby, it depicts a strong correlation between the roles of obtaining power; the way men mentally define the social role of women; how this link shapes a man’s understanding of his role in society. In this case, men are taught to be powerful and bread earners of the family. They treat women inferiorly in order to justify the need for “men in the workplace…[and] legitimized male power within the family” (Anderson qtd.…

    • 761 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Thus. making many men still have the mentality that they can dominate a woman’s life or be in charge of the women by telling her what she can and cannot do. Those guys with that type of mentality are why we still have to deal with domestic violence. Although men in today’s world hurt their partners, we do not know the exact reason for them doing so. Some psychologists say that men who batter women are seeking a sense of power and control over their partners lives, or because they are tremendously dependent on the woman and are threatened by any moves on her part toward independence (http://www.pbs.org/kued/nosafeplace/studyg/domestic.html).…

    • 1082 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Feminism And Masculinity

    • 1040 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Although, advertising and social media have portrayed the picture to young and old males that they need to be primal, violent, controlling, un emotional and that they need to disrespect women and to treat them as objects for sexual gratification we are in a prime position to change these ideologies. Furthermore, have we created this ungodly idea of what men should be we have allowed T.V. to portray women as manipulative, sex toys for judgement and objectification. One of the ways that we have tried to assert our dominance as males is by reducing women to nothing more than their sexuality, and when women try to adopt a more masculine they get ridiculed for abandoning their womanhood. Hilary Clinton is running for president and everything that I see, and on social media (Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, Myspace), is about her sexuality and they go to preposterous reaches to try and discredit her because of how she adopts a masculine appearance.…

    • 1040 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Through hierarchical standing and expectation for men to be dominant and superior, institutional pressures placed on men by media and schools to follow unobtainable masculine standards, and male privilege which constantly favors men and male gender performance, our society breads and conceals men’s sexual violence against women. These hierarchies, institutions, and privileges not only perpetuate the cycle of men’s violence against women, but also continue to mask men’s overwhelming contribution to the issue of sexual violence against women. Hierarchies of difference play a pivotal role in how our society and media reacts to sexual violence. Jackson Katz, in his documentary Tough Guise 2, focuses on how the dominant group in these hierarchies…

    • 1457 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gender Bias In Advertising

    • 1157 Words
    • 5 Pages

    E.J. Graff in their article “The M/F Boxes,” discusses this unfortunate and harmful factor. “Boys and men still patrol each other’s masculinity with a Glengarry Glen Ross level of ridicule and violence that can seem, to women, nearly surreal” (698). It is obvious that men are more strictly…

    • 1157 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Analysis As a man in society, I am obligated to fulfill gender stereotypes that are demeaning to both men and women, and also can be the root of serious problems. Attempting to fit into these hurtful generalizations can be frustrating, and can lead to anger along with other issues, both mentally and physically. Men have always been viewed as the tougher gender, and with that comes no ability to express emotion. They are the rock for the family, and cannot simply be bothered by menial issues like emotion. Additionally, female stereotypes that force conformation of body image can also be extremely detrimental.…

    • 1078 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Society is to blame for men’s fear of losing their masculinity in the eyes of others(Call to Men). Jackson Katz, an expert in violence against women, explains that “there are pressures on men, there are constraints within peer cultures on men,…

    • 1100 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    It is an idealized configuration of manhood which puts women down as an external subordination, it includes stereotypical traits likes tough, rich, powerful and brutal (Donaldson, 1993). Throughout society, men are supposed to demonstrate the concept of hegemonic masculinity in order to perform their gender role. This is heavily influenced by the norms, values, and beliefs. However, the expectation of hegemonic masculinity in modern society has caused huge stigmatization to those men who do not match these socially constructed standards (Grozelle, 2014). This convention of expectation caused many anxieties to men which lowering their capability.…

    • 1839 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays