Healthy Lunches: Article Analysis

Improved Essays
Since obesity is on the rise, another form on bio-politics which regulates children’s lives is giving the example of what children should and should not have in their lunchboxes at school. In the article ‘Why it’s important for Kids to Eat Healthy Lunches’ (2015) written by Melissa Angela demonstrates why it is important for children to have a healthy lunchbox since ‘obesity in children is climbing… If lunch in school is promoting unhealthy habits and behaviours by having unhealthy choices, children are not learning to eat healthy. This can lead to making unhealthy choices in their future with regard to snacks and meals’ (Angela 2015). Thus, government put these guidelines into place providing children with a well-balanced diet, however children …show more content…
There have been many concerns in what food choices children are making, allowing the government and schools, more than ever, having to intervene into what choices children make for school dinners and what food is involved in their pack lunches so children do not become ‘poor, obese and lazy’ (Warin, 2011: 11). Thus, this is a Foucauldian understanding of ‘governmentality’ which the state exercises control over the schools and the children to regulate what they eat and how much to eat as he expresses that the ‘Government has as its purpose not the act of government itself, but the welfare of the population, the improvement of its condition, the increase of its wealth, longevity, health, and so on’ (Foucault, 1991: 100). Thus, it becomes evident from the concerns outlined here from Foucault, that obesity epidemic falls well within the dominance of the governing population. A key way to understand the governmental work through obesity in schools is to conceptualise the numerous ways that pedagogies are developed as ‘biopedagogies’. This concept was developed by Jan Wright (2009) as an addition of Foucault’s notion of bio-power and he states that ‘the notion of biopedagogies is drawn from Foucault’s (1984) concept of ‘biopower’, the governance and regulation of individuals and populations through practices associated with the …show more content…
Consequently, Wright suggests that biopedagogies position individuals under constant surveillance, especially obese people, pressuring them to monitor their bodies so they do not break the power of the norm. However, ‘these sites are not necessarily (and indeed mostly) in schools, but are everywhere around us, on the web, on television, radio and film, billboards and posters, and pamphlets in doctors’ waiting rooms’ (Wright, 2009: 12). Therefore, for obese individuals, especially children, the pressure to lose weight and be healthy is on the rise and is everywhere they look which they cannot escape. Foucault’s notion of ‘Governmentality’ is an approach that emphasises power and the governing of individuals conduct through the sovereign power to formulate the law, Foucault describes governmentality as ‘the ensemble formed by the institutions, procedures, analyses and reflections, the calculations and tactics that allow the exercise of this very specific albeit complex form of power’ (Foucault, 102-103). Thus, through this form of power that Foucault compels, the government are forced into taking control to improve health issues and creating an environment that encourages healthier eating and physical activity. The article ‘Role of Policy and Government in the Obesity Epidemic’ states that ‘the environment has a

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Within the last thirty years, the rise obesity has become a major topic of concern in the United States. While many argue that this increase in size is due to disruptions in the “energy balance model,” which states that the obesity is due to a combination of eating too many calories and not exercising enough (Smith & Cummins, 2009), Julie Guthman argues in her book Weighing In that this definition focuses too much on the individual’s actions without looking at the broader health consequences derived from the built environment, agricultural policies, and neoliberal capitalism. However, although Guthman does offer some excellent points, specifically with her political ecology perspective in the alternative food movement, she does little to…

    • 796 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Fat Talk Nation Analysis

    • 618 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The readings for this week consisted of the first half of the book Fat Talk Nation by Susan Greenhalgh. As per the title of the book, Fat Talk Nation is an insight into American’s perceptions of “Fat” and the attempts to combat the perceived “obesity” epidemic in the United States (Greenhalgh 2015). Greenhalgh uses the concept of biocitizenship to analyze how fat affects societal perceptions and the standing of an individual. Greenhalgh does a thorough job of addressing the origins of the “fight against obesity”, and details the use of media as a normalization tool in making thin in (Greenhalgh 2015). One of the earliest topics Greenhalgh addresses is how individuals of a higher class have “…the wealth to create perfect bodies” (Greenhalgh…

    • 618 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Can the Government Fix Everything? Government control has had a place among America’s debatable topics, and the new focus is obesity. In Radley Balko’s essay “What You Eat Is Your Business”, which was published May 23, 2004 on the Cato Institute website, he discusses that topic in regards to restrictions and laws placed on the food industry. Some people are all for the government placing more regulations on food and requiring more detailed labeling on packaged foods, but others say the government has no right to tell us what to eat. Balko is arguing the side that believes the government does not have the right to decide what we eat, which is not surprising because he is a “self-described libertarian”.…

    • 808 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Radely Balko

    • 1117 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In the essay title “What you eat is your business”, the author Radely Balko tries to make a strong argument against more government intrusion in what we place into our bodies. By advocating we should be responsible for ourselves and not rely on others to assist. Sadly, Mr. Balko detest of government oversight undertones and in some cases, overshadows his argument. There is a proper place for government involvement in our health but we can’t look at with a politically eye. As this has the tendency, as it did with the author, to move you to a negative view point of their involvement.…

    • 1117 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In his essay, “What You Eat is Your Business” Radley Balko asserts that it is not the government’s responsibility what you put into your body. He calls for no regulation on the fast food industry, declaring it a personal responsibility issue. Balko claims that the best method of reducing the obesity problem is removing it from the public sector, and making it a personal problem. However, I believe that he is oversimplifying an issue which he does not fully understand. I also believe that he is mistaking regulation of industry and informing consumers of what they are eating for socialized medicine.…

    • 905 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He adds that there is also a lack of education as to what should or should not be consumed, in particular among poor individuals. Even if there is reference to what should be consumed people do not know how to understand the labels. Both authors bring forth valid ideas for why obesity has drastically increased in the past few years. While also discussing if this growing issue should be seen as a public or private issue. Although, both writers present valid points neither succeed in presenting completely effective ideas.…

    • 993 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    An average American consumes one ton of food a year per the USDA. Multiply this by the number of US population, and witness the enormous number, more than 300 million tons of food being eaten in the US every year. Imagine what would happen if there was no one to monitor our food, or regulate it, and think how much work is needed to keep 300 million American safe from hundreds of millions of foods that comes from everywhere in America, and the world. Radley Balko, in his article, “What You Eat Is Your Business”, claims that the US government is to involve in US citizens’ eating habits. He shows how the excessive involvement of the government makes people lazy about their own health.…

    • 192 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Since when one’s health become everybody’s concern? Toward the end, he advocates that obesity should be removed from “the realm of public health” because what one chooses to eat should not be anybody’s concern and forcing to pay for the consequences of others is seemed quite unpractical. In order to gaining audience’s trust, Balko has used rhetorical appeals to show audience the validity in his…

    • 1194 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Obesity is a problem. Whether it is a problem that affects all of us, as suggested by David Zinczenko in “Don’t Blame the Eater” or each our own, as proposed by Radley Balko, action must nevertheless be taken. Balko makes good points in his article, but Zinczenkos credibility makes his essay stronger. Balko’s proposition is not realistic and I believe it does not put into consideration the best “of the people.” His idea of reform would only benefit very few people and does not take into account people with health problems.…

    • 1219 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Obesity In America's War

    • 996 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Obesity is a disease that plagues America’s old and young more than any other country in the world. Despite efforts to resolve this issue from the communities affected, and by local, state, and federal government this epidemic has yet to come to an end. The most common solutions offered to address the obesity epidemic are ones derived from an economic and dietary approach. Although seemingly worthy solution are commonly agreed upon, however pinpointing an incontestable culprit guilty for this monstrosity cannot be so easily done.…

    • 996 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Obesity In America Essay

    • 1238 Words
    • 5 Pages

    “Our society keeps us focused on others and outside events influencing us. However, the truth is that we are independent and need nothing outside ourselves to survive.”, says American author and internet news caster, Meria Heller, on health and spiritual well being in a modern, digital age. In the most recent of times, a new problem has been brought to the forefront of many lawmakers and average citizens: the impact of obesity on daily life and the role the government should play in helping to stop and prevent obesity. While some people feel it is the government’s job to micromanage the details of its citizen’s lifestyles, others take a more wholesome view that says it is the government’s job to provide easily accessible, raw, healthy foods…

    • 1238 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Argument Paper II The quality of school lunches has been a debated topic throughout this past decade. While some are advocating for healthier lunch options for students, others would prefer that lunch options stay fairly the same to offer a more diverse selection of foods. The opinion article “Healthy School Lunches Under Attack: Our View” written in 2015 by USA Today is a prime example of those in favor of healthier school lunches, and on the opposing side, “Provide Flexibility in the Lunchroom: Opposing View” written by the president of the School Nutrition Association Jean Ronnei in 2015, is an article discussing the possibility of school lunch mandates going too far. The articles provide interesting points on both sides of the argument, however, after reading both articles…

    • 831 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Title In “Does This Tax Make Me Look Fat” by Jeff Osborne, the author considers John Ridley, Eric Topol, and Governor Jan Brewers idea to place a tax directly on the overweight persons to reduce the national problem. After considering their solution to creating a smaller proportion of obese people in the U.S., Osborne gives his readers insight on how he feels about their perception of the problem (647-648). Although both of the gentlemen as well as the Governor pose a sound plan, Osborne argues, their proposal is highly unlikely to raise revenue and make humans healthier (648). Even though Osborne does not agree with the strategy of placing taxes on overweight humans, he does express the evolving concern for the obesity complication…

    • 1305 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Should Students Have The Right To Chose What They Eat For Lunch? The choice of lunch for students should not be one that is made by someone else, students should have the right to chose what they eat for lunch. A healthy lunch for a growing student is a principal component for the development and growth of a child. There are many components of growth that cannot be changed, but weight and health from choice of food can always be revised. Parents often want the best health for their kids, and sometimes physical activity is not as easy to facilitate, which is why eating healthy is exceedingly important.…

    • 1253 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Certain kids have different experiences with their school’s lunches, but it’s safe to assume that the majority of children do not enjoy them one bit. At a school in LA, one child says “The healthier it gets the more disgusting it is” which is just another reason why healthy school lunches are not a good idea. Some children at the school can barely describe what “it” is. Kids want to eat what tastes good, not what tastes like garbage, no matter how good it is for them. It’s not just the taste though; it’s the serving size as well.…

    • 1095 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays