Harvey Milk: Why Do People Deserve To Die?

Improved Essays
How many shots does it take to justify whether someone deserves to die? It took five for Harvey Milk, but it still was unjust. Even after the violence and turmoil of the civil rights movement it has been shown once again that Americans cannot live free without consequence. In this case a person tried to erase a social stigma by using his social platform to promote equal rights. Milk’s assassination was unjust because an openly gay man in a position of authority and had more power then a “normal person”. Some may say that his murder was just because not everyone wanted the change he was trying to achieve. In the days and months leading up to his assassination Harvey Milk’s stance on Gay rights and his notoriety as being one of Americas …show more content…
Milk won the election to the San Francisco board of city supervisors in 1977. His election made him the both the first openly gay supervisor in the city and the highest ranking openly gay government official in United States.(NYC Moscone Milk Verdict Protest) He used his position to implement more change. Milk demanded that Government respond to the needs of the individuals.(Harvey Milk Biography) As mentioned he changed the make-up of the police department by allowing more gay and lesbian people to be hired. He ultimately hoped to produce change through politics. That he did. The only problem with his power is that all of the people weren't ready for the ‘in your face’ style that Milk portrayed and it angered many. It fueled the fire that led Dan White to take his life. The jealousy he had for Harvey’s position and power led him to do the unthinkable. Did Harvey effect Dan’s life to a point where he felt justified in taking his? Or was it just a hate for a man who was successful where had failed. A man who was not scared to speak out on topics that made the normal person uneasy. Is depression a reason to execute another person? According to Dan Whites defense team it is. Dan’s defense team argued that depression along with an increased intake of sugar led him to act out of control. This was later known as the ‘Twinkie Defense’ and has since been

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In the 1970s, if you were someone who was interested in the same sex as yourself, you could understand the day by day difficulties of being accepted by society because this was not considered proper. The general views of Americans were very different from the views of Harvey Milk at this time. The actions that Harvey Milk took towards gay rights stood out. In the Mid-1970s, Harvey Milk worked to promote gay rights and for everyone to be equal. Milk was successful in making a change by being the first openly gay man elected into public office and influenced many gays and gay supporters.…

    • 1404 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This bill was distributed amongst government officalls which stated that the act of being gay was considered to be a mental illness, a dessees which needed to be dealt with. The bill also stated if any person engaged in this perverted action is considered emotionally unstable. Even though men and women like Harry Hay did not approve of this bill they still fought for their right to express their love interests. Harry was strong and steadfast on his goal of gay rights acceptance in congress and American society slowed down when Dwite Eisenhower signed an executive order number 10450 which placed homosexuals at the same security treat as drunks…

    • 1269 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This scene was one of the points in “Age of Aids” that made me frustrated. When millions are fighting and dying from the disease, it was swept underneath the rug and to the public they did something to deserve it. However, when Rock Hudson died, it was getting national coverage and a big issue. On the upside this was a positive, because it gave the AIDS epidemic a popular face.Although it did bring a negative context as well, since Rock Hudson was a homosexual, which only heightened the stigma associated with AIDS. Once it was public knowledge that Rock Hudson was a gay man, it made people believe that the disease was only spread between homosexuals even more strongly.…

    • 1353 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Homophobia violence is a common display around the world. They constantly discriminate people for being who they are. Recently homosexuals are beginning to have the human rights the deserve in society. After the summer of 2015 hate crime has been on a rise because of the marriage equality law (Comrade Fang, 1993,2). Seattle, Washington is one of the cities that have a large population in the LBGT community, but just days after the great victory of the gay marriage enforcement law was approved violence was remaining at the tip of homophobes thoughts (Comrade Fang, 1993,2).…

    • 995 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Harvey Milk advocated for the equality of everyone in society and used powerful quotes such as "All men are created equal. Now matter how hard they try, they can never erase those words. That is what America is about.” Milk’s fight for the equality of gays and lesbians was primarily why he was such a predominant figure in history. For the time period it was unheard of to have an openly gay politician however, “As San Francisco 's first openly gay supervisor, Milk became a symbol of the gay community 's will to be included in the functioning of city government. His presence at City Hall forced residents of San Francisco to acknowledge the role gay men and lesbians played in the life of the city.” Milk had made leaps and bounds in the gay and political communities.…

    • 1789 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In 1895 T.R was appointed the Police Commissioner of New York. The job marked the end of T.R’s future career in New York city, yet it also “sow[ed] the seeds of future political victory”. For T.R sought to break the powerful and corrupt alliance between Tammany Hall and New York’s police(an idea that he had formed in his early twenties after visiting the dwellings of the poor), but as he was doing so he had made himself a lot of enemies and by the summer of 1895 he was regarded as one of the most unpopular man in the city for enforcing the Sunday alcohol act. With the best of intentions for the citizens and the hopes that corruption would reduce to a minimum level, he had enforced an unpopular law. As a result, he was attacked by both members of the Republican and Democratic party.…

    • 1242 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Gay Marriage Arguments

    • 2179 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Lately, there has been a big discussion regarding the concept of gay marriage. The Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender (LGBT) community has been fighting against the government, looking forward for public acceptance and governmental laws that would let people of the same sex get married. There are millions of same sex couples in the world who feel left behind because of the lack of equal rights. For example, people from all over the world move to the USA because cultures are rapidly associating with each other. These people are finding themselves trapped, thinking that they 're going to find more freedom and legal rights in the USA more than anywhere in the world.…

    • 2179 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    According to HIV public records, there were about 16,301 deaths before Reagan even mentioned AIDS, showing the homophobic behaviors of our government. Homophobia is an irrational fear of the LGBT+ community and an umbrella term for biphobia, transphobia, acephobia. Together, we can drive this irrational hate out of the world and unite to eliminate this hostility, leaving a better tomorrow. If you are scared that a gay person will turn you gay, you are homophobic. If you hate based on a person someone chooses to love, you are homophobic.…

    • 1248 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Today, the word Watergate carries more meaning than that of the hotel in Washington DC. The word also represents the political scandal that brought down Richard Nixon's presidency and caused him to resign. However, he did not resign on his own, he resigned following impeachment charges brought against him. This left many wondering whether Nixon could actually be impeached by Congress for his crimes. Impeachable offenses are outlined in the United States Constitution article 4 section 2.…

    • 1544 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Taking the world progressively by storm, the gay rights movement caused many to get arrested, one being Harvey. After getting arrested he knew he needed to go back to New York, but his friends new his heart belonged in San Francisco. It was not long before Milk came to sense and booked his flight back to California for good. He opened up a camera shop in the heart of the gay community called Castro Street. The camera shop spurred many ideas out of Milk, one being becoming San Francisco supervisor due to how small businesses, like his shop, were being treated.…

    • 1581 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays