Sybill Trelawney's Analysis

Decent Essays
Sybill Trelawney’s first prophecy to Albus Dumbledore states, “The one with the power to vanquish the Dark Lord approaches...Born to those who have thrice defied him, born as the 7th month dies…The dark Lord will mark him as his equal, but he will have power the Dark Lord knows not, and either must die at the hand of the other for neither can one live while the other survives.” Voldemort assumes that the boy in question is Harry Potter and travels to Godric’s Hallow to kill Harry. Ultimately, his actions label Harry as the “Boy Who Lived”. Despite her hundreds of failed predictions, Trelawney’s first prophecy became real. Dumbledore advises Harry that prophecies, regardless of their accuracy, do not dictate what we do. A philosophical Harry …show more content…
Hard determinism states determinism is incompatible with freedom. If given the opportunity to rewind time and make a different choice, humans could not choose differently, because choice does not exist. Utilizing physics, Sider states determinists could study the patterns of past behavior of the particles and forces upon them, and could, theoretically, calculate the future. Such calculation does not exist yet, but conceptually it could. Sider’s argument is an over-simplification. Both living and non-living things are governed by physics; however, living organisms (like humans) are governed by biology. Biologists’ main concern is past events. Now that is not to say biology cannot be used to make predictions, but like fallible prophecies, they have the potential to be wrong and are in no way deterministic. Physics has more predictive power than biology. In fact, classical mechanical physics is completely deterministic. If given the exact variables and positions of particles at any given time, the addition of linear vector forces than be used to calculate the future and past positions and velocities of particles. Newton’s laws of motion published in 1686 are indubitable even to this day. On the other hand, quantum mechanics, a branch of physics developed in the 20th century, is more probabilistic and therefore lessens physics’ predictive power. Quantum mechanics states than …show more content…
Soft- determinism states that every action has a cause, but does not rule out the possibility of free will (Sider). According to Sider, a misunderstanding of the word “freedom” makes some believe free will and determinism cannot coexist. He highlights the fallacies of determinism and libertarianism, and suggests we humans need a clearer explanation of freedom. Perhaps the most alarming problem of determinism is the absence of accountability. If determinism is true, people cannot be blamed or punished for unfree actions. Without punishment, the lines of good and bad can be hard to distinguish. Although a vast majority of criminals are subject to uncontrollable factors such race, socioeconomic background etc.(as is everybody else), some determinists believe that criminals still deserve punishment from a legal system. Punishment could serve as the cause for stopping future crimes. Despite this logical defense, the absence of accountability is still disturbing. On the other hand, libertarianism too has unsettling flaws. Libertarians make the extreme claim that science is limited to non-humans, because we have souls and they are a non-physical source of change in the world. I believe that the soul and body are not distinct entities since there is no sufficient evidence and no observations to prove or

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    To resolve the conflict between free will and determinism, reject the belief that produce the conflict. Hard determinism reject free will in the face of determinism. Free will have got to go. Because science has disproved the presence of freedom and it conflicts with science. Hard determinism arguing that life without free will is not bad, but, Accepting hard determinism is about inconceivable.…

    • 1162 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    According to Popper, any theory can be proven false through empirical evidence or experimental data but cannot be proven true. In this view, any theory is always in the state of being not yet disproved. However, Kuhn thinks that in normal science the theory is not questioned until “the crisis stage” in the Kuhn Cycle. Kuhn claims that scientists does not try to refute their theories instead they try to prove them and seek evidence for their theories whereas Popper claims that scientists try to…

    • 944 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    It is vital to remember that scientist are fallible human beings just like us, they are not some unbiased enlightened people in white coats. Science, the ability to know from observation, is limited. Therefore, if individuals believe that scientific claims are conclusive, they will construct pillars of fake laws and a foundation of fabrication which will crumble future generations. In a place and time where many individuals take the word of scientists as law, we must be careful to remember this fact. We cannot assume that because a teacher or scientist or uses the statement “science…

    • 714 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Free will is the known as the capability to decide between different potential courses of action and is a highly questioned topic in the philosophical world. Free will, also closely accompanied to the views of moral responsibility, has some philosophers reason that only actions which are free willed are justified to accept the blame of the action while other philosophers oppose this view. Baron d’Holbach views free will under the idea of Determinism, which entails that only one sequence of actions is possible, which concludes that there is no such thing as free will or choice in the truly deterministic world. In contrast, Compatibilist theorists, like Stace, assert that free will exists and can be well-matched with Determinism. The first theory…

    • 1345 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Some people may go ahead and steal to stay alive while others may choose to act differently and do the complete opposite. Your actions solely depend on you and what type of person you are. Stace also claims that it is delusion to think that determinism is incompatible with free will meanwhile it is merely impossible for them to be compatible as determinism claims that freedom is just an illusion while free will is the complete opposite and is the notion that people are free to act and behave as they please. How can free will and determinism be compatible when people have no control of the causes that occur around them which according to Stace is the reason that they act in a certain manner? If people are not able to genuinely control their actions due to predetermined causes that make them act a certain way, then do they really have free will?…

    • 1040 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Those who believe in this idea are called “hard” determinists, which they deem no one is responsible for their actions. However, the alternative to hard determinism is Libertarianism. Libertarianism is the act of believing humans are free from determinism and its forms. Libertarians believe that determinism and free will cannot be as one. Moreover, they believe freedom requires indeterminism.…

    • 1628 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Modern theories concerning black holes cannot be falsified because we cannot observe a black hole from a close distance. Popper would claim that some of these theories are pseudo-science because it cannot be falsified. If the ability to test a theory does not exist it does not mean that the idea is not scientific but if there is no way to test it then it cannot be a real scientific theory. Sismondo also says that some theories assume that certain conditions are true in order to test out their theory. In these instances, Popper’s theory of falsification would fail because the assumed conditions are not being tested but they are necessary in order to test a theory.…

    • 1594 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    is unacceptable for scientific reasons, the second (ii. or iii.) for epistemological reasons. Let’s start with the former. The problem here is that we don’t have, Street says, an account for how the evolution pushed us towards the independent moral truths because the best scientific attempts to explain how the evolutionary past influenced our moral judgments do not make any reference to the moral truths.…

    • 1082 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Determinism is the concept that our actions and our decisions have causal influences. This is limited within the scope of Philosophy and Ethics and does not extend to the natural sciences such as Physics and Chemistry— though it could be applied in that context in subfields such as the Philosophy of Science. Determinism can be broken up into a spectrum of flavors (which will be discussed further later) but is primarily divided into the adjectives of hard and soft determinism. Indeterminism is the concept that the doctrine of determinism is not universally true. Philosophers who advocate for this view of (or rather lack thereof) causal morality are known as Libertarians, not to be confused or associated with the political ideology of the same name.…

    • 2724 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    There are scientists who believe that the first law of thermodynamics should not even have to be applied to the big bang.11 Another critique, would be the violation of entropy: the degree of disorder or randomness in a system.11 This would be in relation to the formation of the stars and the galaxies. However, due to pictures we now have of the universe in it’s infancy, we can see that it is indeed following entropy. Another criticism would be that it is violating the law that nothing can travel faster than the speed of light. Space itself can expand faster than the speed of light, and as space falls outside of the domain of the theory of…

    • 1075 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays

Related Topics