Gun-Free School Zones Act Case Study

Superior Essays
On March 10, 1992, Alfonso Lopez Jr. brought a .38-caliber handgun and five bullets to Edison High School in San Antonio, TX. He was arrested under Texas law but the next day, state charges were dropped after he was charged by a federal grand jury for violating the Gun- Free School Zones Act of 1990. He was convicted and sentenced to 6 months in prison and 2 years of supervision. Lopez’s lawyer, John R. Carter, a federal public defender, argued that the Gun-Free School Zones Act (GFSZA) is unconstitutional as it did not meet the requirement of the Commerce Clause. The Commerce Clause allows congress to make laws if interstate commerce is affected. In a 5-4 decision, the Supreme Court agreed with Carter and Lopez went free. United States v. Lopez is important because it was the first successful challenge to the Commerce Clause in 50 years and it serves as a precedent to other cases.

As a part of the Crime Control Act of 1990, the GFSZA amends federal criminal code to impose criminal penalties for the possession or firing of a gun in a school zone. Sponsored by Senator Joseph Biden (D-DE), it passed the house by a 313-1 margin and became law on 11/29/90. Violation of the GFSZA is punishable by a minimum of
…show more content…
They believed that school violence interferes with public education and has a negative impact on the economy. They argued that to meet the Commerce Clause, the impact on interstate commerce does not need to be direct, only substantial. Education has a substantial impact on commerce. They also cited the cost of insurance associated with violent crime as the expense is passed to everyone. Both sides make strong arguments but by the closest vote possible, the conviction was overturned and Lopez was set free. Congress later revised the Act to include language regarding commerce. The revised act has not been successfully challenged but some have

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    One of the most ineffective gun laws in place today is the gun free zones act, limiting where one can bring a gun. Gun free zones are an easy target for mass killers. Gun control advocates often fail to see that guns deter criminals. For instance, John R. Lott an American economist, political commentator, and gun rights advocate puts this law it into perspective in his article “Bans don’t deter killers”: “If a killer were stalking your family, would you feel safer putting a sign out front announcing, ‘This Home is a Gun-Free Zone’? That is what schools do" (par. 5).…

    • 1018 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Essay On Guns In Schools

    • 932 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Gun control has been an issue that is discussed in schools, political debates and is always a basis for anyone running for the presidential office. Should teachers and faculty be allowed to carry firearms in schools to protect the students? There are always two sides to the issue. Digging deeper on both sides of the issue and to find good clear reasoning is important in order to decide what is right, not just to agree with a political parties opinion. I plan on setting my own views aside on this as well sense…

    • 932 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As a matter of public policy, an employer shall not be required to be reinstate an unlawfully terminated employee when the employee is an illegal alien. If an employer was to have to reinstate an illegal alien, they would be violation of the Immigration Reform and Control Act. In 1986, the Immigration Reform and Control Act (IRCA) passed in order to prohibit employers from knowingly hiring, recruiting, or referring for a fee any alien who is unauthorized to work (“Immigration Reform”, n.d.). The IRCA, signed under President Ronald Reagan, also allowed those employees to be given a pathway to citizenship (Rojas, 2013).…

    • 692 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There has always been some level of student’s misconduct in school; however school recently changed the methods and polices to deal with delinquent behavior. Schools implemented zero tolerance policies which are punitive and based on deterrence theory. Therefore, many juveniles receive harsh punishments such as expulsion, suspension, and entrance to the juvenile justice system; creating the school-to-prison pipeline. The school-to-prison pipeline has damaging effects on an individual as the student is pushed out of schools; many students then find it difficult to gain an education and become stigmatized within society, thus pushing them to further delinquency. This pipeline tends to contribute to the racial and learning capability disparity…

    • 825 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    At most Louisiana schools and colleges bringing firearms on campus grounds is unlawful. The council is attempting to make weapons on campus grounds lawful. The chance that this law is passed then students and the workforce would have the capacity to convey covered firearms on school grounds all through Louisiana. The debate about having weapons on grounds is, would it be a good idea for it to be legitimate or unlawful? All students and staff have a privilege to be protected on campus grounds.…

    • 486 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Since this policy was enacted, census shows that there has been an annual decline in gun related incidents in schools. As well as San Diego, other states including: Pennsylvania, Oklahoma, Missouri, and Washington have had success with the “zero tolerance” approach in their communities. Although some may disagree, I firmly believe that the state of Georgia as prescribed by the tenth amendment in the United States constitution, maintains its right to amend this bill. Succeeding in this action will guarantee that Georgia has taken all precautions necessary to make sure that the safety of our staff and students are…

    • 499 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Enacted by Congress in 1938, the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) established a 25 cent minimum wage, a 44 hour long work week, which was later revised in 1940 to only 40 hours per week, and prohibited child labor (Fair Labor Standards, n.d.). However, in 1940, Fred Darby of Darby Lumber failed to comply to the regulations of the FLSA and was arrested when shipping lumber out of state because he was working his employees overtime and paying them under the minimum wage requirement. After a hearing in the District Court, it was found that Darby’s violation of the FLSA was unconstitutional because the Commerce Clause only applied to interstate commerce, not local as Darby described his shipment was (United States, n.d.). However, that decision…

    • 302 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    1. False: This statement is false because, in recent years, a number of precautions have been taken to reduce gun violence in schools. Certain federal and state laws have made schools gun free zones, and, as a result, fewer students are carrying guns, and it is more difficult to get a gun into a school zone. Also, many schools have surveillance cameras placed on school grounds, which may deter those planning to commit a school shooting. Another action taken to reduce the danger of a school shooting is requiring students to use see through backs packs to reduce the chance of a firearm entering school grounds.…

    • 763 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Second Amendment, is a very controversial area under discussion in the media. Both advocates for and against gun ownership have been lobbying Congress to gain legislation in their favor for decades. Congress is at a standstill over gun issues and has voted down all proposals on gun control in the legislature. Although regulation is useless against criminals some harm can be avoided through tougher unified gun control, the American people have a Second Amendment right to bear arms, nevertheless regulators must decide who should be allowed ownership of what guns and if any training should be required among other issues, regulation must be clearly defined in order to protect society from needless harm. Proponents of gun control have debated that the Second Amendment only applies to members of militias and does not apply to individual…

    • 1674 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Hernandez V. Texas case began when Pete Hernandez shot and killed Joe Espinoza. Pete was a crippled Mexican agricultural worker, who was being made fun of by Joe at a bar when the incident happened. On October 8, 1951 attorney Gustavo Garcia, entered a plea of not guilty for Hernandez and argued that Hernandez wasn’t being offered an equal trial, due to there being no Mexican Americans in the jury. The court argued that by law Mexican Americans are white, and the jury was made up of white Americans therefore it was a fair and equal trial. Resulting in attorney Garcia taking the case to the supreme court.…

    • 109 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The latest mass shootings have happened in where? Gun free zones. The ones like the shooting in Aurora, Colorado, the Oregon junior college and the Ft Hood massacre have all happened in gun free zones. The issue isn't the gun it’s the person behind the gun pulling a trigger.…

    • 189 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gun Free Zones Analysis

    • 867 Words
    • 4 Pages

    92% of mass shootings since 2009 occurred in gun-free zones (Hawkins, 2014). The basic rights of the Second Amendment allow us to purchase weapons and use them as we please as long as we follow the rules and laws. Gun rights were very serious rights when America was first founded and are still very serious and important. After a few shootings, the federal government decided to mark some areas as gun free zones because they were trying to stop mass shootings. Instead of further protecting the people, the gun free zones actually created more chaos by making the community defenceless.…

    • 867 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The United States v. Lopez case, presided over by Chief Justice William Rehnquist, dealt with the abilities of Congress to regulate and inhibit activities that may present a potential obstacle to the economic growth of an area. The initial problem emanated from a Texas high school student’s decision to bring a concealed firearm into his school. He was indicted under the Gun-Free School Zones Act of 1990 which falls under the Commerce Clause. The defendant appealed and after judicial review the law was found to be unconstitutional because the action committed was a criminal one that had no effect upon economic development or commerce. In this example, the Legislative Branch did overstep its boundaries because interstate restrictions on certain…

    • 176 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This case comes to great importance and had a great impact on the executive branch because the Supreme Court limited Congressional power under the Commerce Clause. The Bush v. Gore case involved a high school student that carried a weapon. The gun possession in a public school did not affect interstate commerce and the Commerce Clause was not able to be used as justification for Congress' legislation.…

    • 67 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The court room on this day was obstreperous. The judge constantly slammed his gavel, in a valiant effort to stop the unwarranted crossfire. The chaos was certainly hard to control, but it only contributed to the circumspect attitude of those determining the laws. Not wanting to take a risk and put a new law into place, it took hours of debating to finally sway the legislators towards creating new laws. Once suspicious, the legislators argued that gun restriction violated the Constitution, but the politicians provided plenty of statistical evidence that persuaded the…

    • 680 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays