Grutter Vs Billinger

Improved Essays
3. What can school administrators hope to gain from knowledge of the sources of law that impact schools?
School administrators make certain decisions everyday and many of them have remarkable legal significance. Because of these decisions, school leaders have the responsibility of knowing and understanding state, federal, and case law that governs general education, special education, and community education. It is imperative that school leaders have appropriate legal knowledge base that includes past court rulings as well as present rulings; and must be able to develop, adjust, and implement policy to meet local, state, and federal requirements and constitutional provisions, standards, and regulatory applications that impact schools.

4. Which
…show more content…
Grutter, a white woman, who had a 3.81 undergraduate grade point average, and 161 score on the LSAT, sued the university over the school’s affirmative action policy, which considered race as a factor in admissions. Michigan, and many other universities in the country use affirmative action (or positive discrimination) to increase the number of minority students admitted in the university. Grutter claimed that University of Michigan’s affirmative action policy, which admitted less-qualified minority applicants, is in violation of federal civil rights laws and the Fourteenth Amendment, which guarantees citizens “equal protection” under the law. In Grutter v Bollinger (2003), the Supreme Court upheld the use of affirmative action in higher education. The Court affirmed that diversity could be a legally legitimate rationale for affirmative action, and emphasized that University of Michigan’s policy was acceptable because the school conducted a thorough review of each applicant’s qualifications and did not use a racial quota system (Parker, …show more content…
Bollinger has the greatest impact on my role as a professional educator. Affirmative action, which has its origins in a 1961 executive order issued by then president John F. Kennedy, continues to be a contentious issue. Since 1996, several states, including California, Washington, and Michigan has prohibited affirmative action in public education, in state government hiring, and the awarding of state contracts while the face of America has been changing. Traditionally excluded racial and ethnic minorities make up a large portion of the present and next generation. Without a variety of affirmative action programs that identify and nurture talent among groups, our nation will fail to effectively compete in the global market and maintain the world’s strong research capability (Garces, 2012). Despite the Supreme Court’s upholding the constitutionality of affirmative action practices in Grutter v. Bollinger, the use of the state ballot to enact policies that ban the practice is a growing phenomena affecting higher education policy. While the process is considered to be an exercise of democracy, it undermined the efforts of institutions of higher education to further the educational and democratic goals in our society, which in the words of the U.S. Supreme Court involves “cultivating a set of leaders with legitimacy in the eyes of the citizenry” (Garces, 2012, p.

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In conclusion I find that the Abigail N. Fisher has presented a good amount evidence proving that the University of Texas, Austin’s policy is unconstitutional based on their policy of accepting students not apart of the top 10 percent of their class and that the supreme court should rule in her favor. Abigail N. Fisher seems to have had the potential to be able to succeed at the University. Even though she was not considered apart of the top ten percent of her senior class she was in the twelve percent range and was still a highly competitive applicant. Not being accepted due to the University's goals of creativing diversity is not constitutional. Everyone should be given a fair chance to be admitted into the college especially if they are…

    • 135 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As result of the Supreme Court case, Fisher v. University of Texas questions involving the application of affirmative action during college decisions produces a response by professor emeritus of law and sociology, Richard O. Lempert. As to put an end to the debate over whether affirmative action backfires on those admitted into selective institutions Lempert published an article named, “The Supreme Court Has Upheld Affirmative Action. So Let’s Dump Mismatch Theory.” Consequently, Lempert refers to research done by Mary J. Fischer, Douglas S. Massey, and other experts who through their research are able to express how affirmative action does not lead to the mismatching of individuals and institutions of higher education. Mismatching is the…

    • 376 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Argument of Strong Affirmative Action Between Hettinger and Pojman After the era of the Civil Rights Movement swept how people think, Americans and business have tried to find ways in order to help promote diversity and equality into establishments such as the workforce and higher education. One of the ways that America has decided to do this is by promoting affirmative Action. Affirmative action a policy favoring those who tend to suffer from discrimination, also know as positive discrimination. We encounter two authors that both seem to have different opinions on the view of affirmative action. Edwin C. Hettinger is on the side calling affirmative action “reverse racism” itself suggests that it is discrimination: discrimination towards…

    • 1047 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    John Silber Way

    • 507 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Former president of Boston University, John Silber, who was also ran for the position of governor for the state of Massachusetts, was an intellectual man. Even after his death, September 27, 2012, he left behind his legacy and had “Sherborn Street” renamed by the city of Boston, the “John R. Silber Way” in honor of him. John Silber’s essay, “Students Should Not Be above the Law” addresses in the beginning of the essay, in which medieval Europe had a “two parallel court systems: the church’s and the king’s”. However, they still posed a major difference, which the church courts did not settle the situation in capital punishment. English clergymen were somewhat the exemption of the jurisdiction in civil courts.…

    • 507 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Griswold Case Study

    • 1813 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Griswold V. Connecticut: Griswold, with the Planned Parenthood League, gave information to married couples in regards to birth control in attempt to prevent potential pregnancies. She and another physician involved claimed that the 14th amendment was violated in regards to the accessory statue. The law says that any person that uses any drug preventing conception is subject to fines, greater than forty dollars, or even imprisoned for 60 days. Any person who also assists in this can be prosecuted. This Connecticut law overall prohibited the counseling as well as other medical treatment to any couple that was looking to prevent contraception or the risk of contraception occurring.…

    • 1813 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Imagine a university professor accuses a student of cheating on a final exam. Before the student can defend herself, the university decides to expel the student. Understandably, the student decides she wants to challenge the expulsion as a violation of her due process rights. Can the student challenge the action?…

    • 1298 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Antebellum Transformation

    • 911 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The transformation of the antebellum south to a culturally diverse community occurred before I was born in 1995. I can’t imagine a society that needs to be told a statement like Martin Luther King Jr. said in 1963, “I have a dream that one day on the red hills of Georgia, sons of former slaves and the sons of former slave owners will be able to sit down together at the table of brotherhood.” The Civil Rights era should have been seen as a new beginning as a society with an opportunity for hope and prosperity, but in reality, we are creatures of habit and turbulent times often arise when a paradigm shift occurs. This shift was evident as the Federal Government usurped more power from the States, black people moved into the middle…

    • 911 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Fisher III Case Analysis

    • 1561 Words
    • 7 Pages

    While this strategy has worked thus far, at least since Grutter upheld Justice Powell’s plurality opinion as expressed in Bakke , John V. Wintermute, in his 2014 Comment published in the Seton Hall Law Review, seeks to comment on the uncertainty left following the Fisher III decision, and “to provide colleges and universities with another foundation upon which to pursue a race-conscious admissions policy.” In particular, he argues that many forms of unequal treatment experienced by a number of black college applicant’s in the course of education falls within “the Supreme Court’s articulation of racial discrimination as ‘race-based decision-making’” and that schools may be able to account for the discrimination faced by members of their applicant pool pursuant to the race-conscious remedy jurisprudence established by the Supreme…

    • 1561 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Affirmative Action Case Study

    • 1561 Words
    • 7 Pages
    • 4 Works Cited

    As it is now, it facilitates the entrance to college to minorities of the higher classes. In its current form, affirmative action is well intentioned, but it is rather ineffective, and it sets itself up for causing a stir among whites who feel that minority status is taking precedent over academic performance, and calling this practice reverse discrimination. The case against the University of Michigan is a prime example of this. But William Symonds has a solution that would not only allow for more racial integration, but with race not playing a big role, if any roll at all in being a factor in deciding college admissions. Basing affirmative action off of financial need, with the money provided for the less fortunate to attend four-year universities would not only draw from the pool of minorities that make up a large portion of the lower classes, it would also give everyone a truly equal opportunity to attend college.…

    • 1561 Words
    • 7 Pages
    • 4 Works Cited
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The issue of equality based on race has given people a plagued view of America since its existence, and this issue of race does not stop when it comes to college admission. In 2003, a case known as Grutter v. Bollinger came in front of the Supreme Court and challenged the constitutional protection or lack of on an affirmative action plan adopted by an university. Grutter deals with the role the state plays in including a minority group into a larger part of the schools student body for educational benefits; this is the basis of affirmative action. The problem some people say of this is that under-favored minority groups are occasionally felt like they are pushed aside for these other group members. The challenge to affirmative action brought…

    • 1375 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Affirmative action is used in a good amount of employment and university systems. In Chandler Smith’s case affirmative action was used to decide who qualified for the five spots left to those who fit the school’s definition of diversity. Chandler being rejected when applying to the spot caused a two sided argument rise on if Chandler deserved to have been accepted or not. One side claims that she did not fit the description they were looking for for diversity and the school is allowed to do such a thing. The other argues Chandler should have been allowed to go because of her economic background and it is a violation to the restrictions surrounding affirmative action.…

    • 999 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Regents of the University of California at Davis (Davis) v. Allan P. Bakke, 438 U.S. 265 (1948) is an influential case that determined whether or not Affirmative action is constitutional in admissions decisions. Davis had two separate admissions programs, one for general admissions and one for special admissions. The special admissions program was created for students who wish to be considered “disadvantaged” (meaning minority students). Davis accepted 100 students every year for their medical program; 16 of those slots were reserved for students accepted through the special admissions program. Evaluating how the Supreme Court ruled in Bakke could help determine if Affirmative action is the best way to achieve diversity at your…

    • 1635 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Courts have examined claims that detentions of students by school officials constitute an unlawful seizure. A seizure occurs when individuals feel they are not free to leave, such as when students are detained by school administrators for questioning. The Tenth Circuit, however, noted: “To qualify as a seizure in the school context, the limitation on the student’s freedom of movement must significantly exceed that inherent in every-day, compulsory attendance.” As in the cases involving searches, courts examine school officials’ actions to determine if a seizure or detainment of a student is reasonable—that is, justified at its inception and not excessively intrusive in light of the student’s age and sex and the specific infraction.…

    • 526 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Affirmative action is defined as, “admission policies that provide equal access to education for those groups that have been historically excluded or underrepresented, such as women and minorities” (“Affirmative Action Overview” n.p.). Affirmative action is a controversial topic when it comes to college acceptance and admissions. The Grutter v. Bollinger Supreme Court case concerning racial diversity in public colleges across America had greatly impacted many policies on affirmative action in regards to student admissions. The case involved Barbara Grutter and her dispute with the University of Michigan because she was denied acceptance to the university despite having qualified LSAT scores and GPA, and she argued that it was due to her not…

    • 1640 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hopwood Vs Texas

    • 1144 Words
    • 5 Pages

    A U.S. Supreme Court ruling in 1996 may have led to one of the most controversial higher education policies of all time. The ruling made it legal for the flagship University of Texas at Austin school to drop affirmative action in their admissions process (Hopwood v. Texas). In 1997 a response by affirmative action advocates proposed and passed what is considered a race-neutral admissions procedure that they believed would actually increase minority admissions to flagship schools in Texas. The now infamous Texas Top Ten Percent law requires that any high school graduate in the top ten percent of their graduating class from any school will get automatic admission to state public universities (Rangel).…

    • 1144 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays