Golden Rice Controversy

Great Essays
Eva Resnick-Day and her question about the fossil fuel industry was enough to make Hillary Clinton lose her calm at her campaign in New York (Phillip). It was not the first time Eva had done this, and it was not the first time her group was known for this. Eva belongs to a group known as Greenpeace, an environmental awareness group with deep ties in past and current issues. In the past, it had focused on whaling and nuclear efforts, but with stricter regulations in place and in order to stay relevant, Greenpeace has moved onto current issues, such as Golden Rice in India. However, the reasoning and effects of this issue has caused widespread controversy. Greenpeace’s protest on Golden Rice is causing it to lose support as it strays from their original goal of environmental protest into popular pseudoscience.
Greenpeace found its beginnings in the Cold war as the “Don’t Make a Wave Committee,” a group of people who worked together in the basement of a church to
…show more content…
With other crop varieties, such as rapeseed, maize, cotton, and soybean, popular ideals circulate faster than scientific journals and cause the setback and even destruction of some varieties (Rousu). In Greenpeace’s crosshairs, Golden Rice is no exception. In a twenty minute video on the site YouTube, Greenpeace’s official channel hosts a short, twenty minute long documentary named “All that glitters is not Gold – The Truth about GE ‘Golden’ Rice”. In the video are claims, such as that the lack of beta-Carotene is not from the lack of the vitamin in the available foods, but that the people of the area are not eating properly (“All that glitters is not Gold”). While the documentary may sway people to join Greenpeace’s members and donate to their cause, it does not directly harm the population in Southeast Asia where Golden Rice is a staple crop. What does harm them, though, is the Greenpeace funded destruction of their

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Genetically modified foods have always been looked upon negatively. Though it may reap in benefits, the potential risks weigh heavily in the minds of the many against them. By allowing this product to go forth, many risk are welcomed, including the commingling of the product with crops for regular consumption and therefore, risking mass human health. In this case, Ventria planned to increase their acreage of planted genetically modified rice from 50 acres to 120 acres.…

    • 441 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    At this period in the organic movement when the OFPA passed, former grassroots organizers now had to deal with politicians and lobbyists, which caused frustration. Additionally, activists began to fear large-scale organic players were abusing the rules of the NOP while others continued to support the system for the growth it created. In chapter six Obach talks about social justice, which he describes as the main reason for discontent within the movement. The chapter mainly discusses social justice in relation to workers, consumers, and local farmers. The author summarizes that changing American values is and will continue to be a challenge for organic…

    • 772 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Paarlberg brings in celebrity author Vandana Shiva to explain just what is going on. He states, “A 2002 meeting in Rome of five hundred prominent international NGOs, including Friends of the Earth and Greenpeace, even blamed The Green Revolution for the rise in world hunger” (Paarlberg 613). This appeals to logic as it references an expert opinion. Paarlberg may not be credible on his own to make this statement, but by bringing in an expert opinion of eco-activists he appeals to logic. Because of this, he makes an even better point to the argument so that the audience can believe his…

    • 815 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The book “Harvest for Hope”, written by Jane Goodall, outlines and inspires the audience to eat mindfully and healthily. The author explains how a great portion of our nutrient intake is unknowingly mixed with toxins, and made in miserable conditions. Dr. Goodall explains this successfully by analyzing the typical practices of industrial agriculture, which then leads her on to examine the repercussions of these techniques, pressing the point that we are fatally detached from nature and it’s ethics. This novel informs the public not only how to leave a small environmental footprint, but also how one can do so positively. Jane Goodall associates many of humanity’s problems to the way the nutrition is composed.…

    • 312 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This suggests that some of the actions that environmental activists take are questionable and morally wrong. Take for example Grant Hadwin, a timber prospector who chopped down the Picea sitchensis Aurea tree as an act of protest against the “predatory forestry industry” (259). This act only made a very select group of people feel sympathetic and instead “shocked and disgusted” large groups of people (259). By committing this extremist action Hadwin disregarded environmental virtue ethics and performed an act that did not follow the moral principles of virtue ethics. If Hadwin had studied the teachings of the exemplar environmental virtue ethicists, this act would not have taken place as he would have realized that his act was damaging instead of helping.…

    • 529 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A major topic of concern today can be found in the world’s struggle with hunger and the malnourishment of millions of people. In attempt to address this matter, many countries have turned to genetically modified foods, causing many people to debate on whether or not they could be the answer to world hunger. Unfortunately, the countries not participating in the genetically modified foods movement are the main ones in need of food and nourishment. One author, Robert Paarlberg, attempts to describe the great need and positivity of allowing these modern growing methods in his article, “Attention Whole Foods Shoppers.” Through the use of convincing facts, rhetorical devices, proposals, and addressing opposing views, Paarlberg effectively argues…

    • 1079 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    A quick glance at the local or national paper will show you that there are many environmental issues today. Some of the issues you will hear about are related to population issues and how to control the population of humans on Earth. Some stories will be about the loss of ecosystems in some part of the world. Maybe you'll see something that has to do with the current administration treats environmental issues. You are going to probably be reading a lot of articles that talk about climate change.…

    • 1974 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Landfills. Solid waste, including food scraps, produces greenhouse gas emissions from anaerobic decomposition…” (Lappe). She also satisfies the appeal to logos when she refers to the several sources she uses to support her claims. An example of this appeal is when she mentions “Said Greenpeace, the IAASTD report recommends a ‘significant departure from the destructive chemical-dependent, one-size-fits-all model of industrial agriculture’”…

    • 1682 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When it comes to Global warming, being a vegetarian should be turned to as a first resort rather than going more toward the Prius, a car that has been made to cut vehicle emissions in half in an attempt to fight against global warming. Kathy Freston’s article “Vegetarian is the new Prius” caught my eye immediately when choosing an essay for the very fact that, I want Toyota Prius, and also because I’ve tried going vegetarian. Although I see nothing wrong with being a vegetarian, the lifestyle just didn’t work for me. I do to a certain extent agree with her argument because ever since I took ecology in high school, the environment has been very important to me, and I do what I can to help preserve it. Freston wrote that President Herbert Hoover promised a chicken in every pot and a car in every garage”.…

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As stated in Sevastian Winters online article, “The Pros and Cons of the United States„Going Green‟: Is Environmental Consciousness Really All Good…

    • 962 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Confronting politicians over issues of environmental losses has proven somewhat effective in modern times, however, needs to be further pursued. If actions were taken to actively educate the politicians of the world about the current condition of the plant, greater interest might be put into the topic. Additionally, the opposition of environmentalists may be convinced to join the movement once scientifically backed information is made available and widely understood within their parties. For the women’s suffrage movement having the government approve changes to the voting system was required, for environmental movement, the role of the state may not be essential for major change. Convincing the public that their support is crucial for the movement to succeed may be all that is…

    • 783 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Reinhard Renneberg’s article, “Golden rice can end world hunger,” he explains his ideas on the highly controversial topic of GMO Golden Rice. He begins the article by introducing the problem: 250 million children are suffering from provitamin A deficiency, which is important for resistance against infectious diseases. Renneberg’s solution is to use Golden Rice that is genetically modified containing maize DNA, which has provitamin A. He believes this to be a strong solution because rice is a key food in the diets of two billion people worldwide. He later mentions the opposition of his argument when he states, “ their objection wasn’t to the addition of provitamin A, but to the use of gene transfer.”…

    • 799 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    DBQ: The Green Revolution

    • 1816 Words
    • 8 Pages

    The worldwide introduction of new, scientifically bred crop varieties and intensive use of new technologies, is known as the Green Revolution. The Green Revolution is the start of a new beginning in the world. Some people think that the Green Revolution was the best thing for us, but some other people think otherwise. Throughout history, many improvements have been made, but the Green Revolution was not one of them. The Green Revolution was only a temporary fix, to a huge problem.…

    • 1816 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Brilliant Essays

    Laura Reddig Professor Michelle MacFarlane AG 198 7 October, 2015 Midterm 1. Alternative crops are crucial to changing the unhealthy dieting habits of modern culture as the reliance on calorie rich crops rise. The world is shifting its agricultural focus to crops like wheat, corn, and soybeans while crops like sweet potato, cassava and yam are declining in numbers (Parker, 2014). With such a limited number of crops being relied on to provide most dietary nutrition, those crops have to be specifically bred and genetically modified to keep up with the nutritional demand. Alternative crops add diversity in the world’s food supply so a few select crops are not the only ones relied on for a majority of the food demand.…

    • 1045 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Brilliant Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For exercise two I will be comparing and contracting Green Peace verses Population connection. Both the Organizations have several differences, but they have some similarities as well. There are two main differences between the two organizations such as, Mission statement, and the environmental issues they focus on. The first contract between Green Peace and Population connection is their mission statement and what type of organization they are.…

    • 1464 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays