Gilbert Herdt's Sambia Sexual Culture

Superior Essays
In Western culture, we have a very specific understanding as to what it means to be male and masculine, or at least in terms of societies definition of masculinity. In our culture, gender and sex are understood as different, but co-existent and complimentary. Gender and sex together are used to create ones gender ideology; their personal understanding of gender. Just as the female/feminine has been socially constructed and implemented through norms attitudes and beliefs, so have the ideas or expectations of the male, masculinity. Within our culture and society, we have created norms and expectations of what it is to be male. Strong, powerful, stoic and brave- these are all traits of masculinity that are not only important in western culture, …show more content…
Literature Review
Two resources I found when researching were: Sambia Sexual Culture: Essays from the Field, and Clinical Ethnography and Sexual Culture, both of which were written by Gilbert Herdt. In Clinical Ethnography and Sexual Culture, Herdt discusses the “constructs of sexual culture, clinical ethnography, and sexual subjectivity”, and mores specifically the problems that arise for Western communities when trying to understand sexual cultures of non-Western peoples ( Herdt; Clinical Ethnography, p. 100). In his work Sambia Sexual Culture, Herdt looks more closely at the sexuality as a cultural construct of the Sambia people, specifically focusing on the male/masculine and their rites of passage. His work is a collection of nine essays, which focus on gender, sexuality, homosexuality, and ideologies of both Western and Sambian culture (Herdt; Sambia Sexual Culture, p.2). Herdt’s writings focus specifically on the initiation and rite of passage into manhood. He states that the ways in which we view Sambian culture and rites of passage are created by the ways in which we define sexual culture, and that how the Sambia conceptualize their reality is
…show more content…
In the movie, Guardian of the Flutes, individuals recounting their experiences of performing felatio expressed their dislike for the act, and the shame that they felt (Herdt; film). But the movie failed to address their understanding of the act, other than their dislike of it. They were not asked if they felt the act was necessary or important, only how they felt about it. There are many things in our lives that we do not enjoy doing, but do because we feel it is necessary or important. In a westernized society, our views of these acts would be that they are exploitative, but that is because of our understanding of sexuality. Sexual acts of the men are not supposed to be an enjoyable experience, but are to be done to ensure the survival of their society through reproduction. This is not to say that they do not enjoy them when they are occurring- but the act itself isn’t done out of desire for pleasure. Sambia men are fearful of being in close quarters with their wives as they are polluted and will deplete their strength, which is needed for battle(Herdt; Sambia Sexuality…p.9). The sexual culture of the Sambia does not include ideas of romance, kissing, or sexual deviance as a form of eroticism (Herdt; Sambia Sexuality…p.4). Sex is viewed as a natural urge that needs to be satisfied, but that

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    D. Salinger, Holden Caulfield epitomizes asexuality between his refusal to participate in sexual behavior and his lack of desire for it. He doesn’t look for it as a trait in a relationship, nor does he want to partake in it when faced by sexual situations. Asexuality is still extremely relevant today, as the amount of people who identify as asexual is constantly growing while more and more people find out about it. Awareness that this is a real and valid orientation must be spread in order to prevent the prejudice asexuals face from all sides in a society driven by sex. As Holden finds out, sex is not a requirement in order to become a valid part of the society; this is an important thing for anyone and everyone to understand.…

    • 1020 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Erotic Art Essay

    • 1010 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Personally, the lectures have taught me that sexuality varies within many factors. Factors range from the historical periods of evolution to sexual diversity such as individuals sexual identity and orientation. Also, the diversity in sexual desires, fantasies, and behaviors was discussed and has aided in my core understanding of sexual disorders. The book by Daniel Bergner, "The Other Side of Desire" put into perspective cases of individuals that may be presented in the future. Thus, the course has encouraged me to step out of my comfort zone and analyze psychological issues.…

    • 1010 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sexual Script Analysis

    • 997 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Gender identity what is in your head, whereas gender expression is the way you express your gender. The gender roles influences how the script plays out. Our sexual scripts have been defined by our gender. A females might be raise to be caring, sexually submissive, and gentle or strong and aggressive; whereas a male might be raise to be strong, competitive and aggressive or gentle and caring. The way this female choses to display her gender it will have a significant impact on her sexual script, same goes for males.…

    • 997 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many argue that while it is successful, there are circumstances in which Nagel’s theory does not account for. Given that there are instances in which Nagel would consider perversions while others would not. For example, take into consideration homosexuality. According to Nagel’s theory while it is considered unnatural to many, homosexuality is not a perversion. Although it is not a typical sexual act -meaning that it does not result in reproduction- it is still not foreign as it existed even back in the time of ancient Greeks.…

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the past few classes, one of the big things we learned was what sex really is. We learned that the traditional view of sex is actual penetration of a penis to a vagina between a married couple so they can procreate. If we look at sex from a more modern view, there is more of a variety that is considered sex. This can include sexting, oral, masturbation, etc. We also learned what sex can be influenced by: psychology, culture, and biology.…

    • 762 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This “pleasure of analysis” that accompanies the procedures of Western society contains fragments of an erotic art. A new pleasure in the discovery of the truth is seen as a part scientia sexualis in modern society. Foucault states that the repressive hypothesis is inadequate to explain the reinforcements, proliferation of discourses tailored to power, solidification of the sexual mosaic, and the construction of technologies of mandatory confession and knowledge. Essentially what is being dealt with is a undertaking of a “subtle network of discourses, special knowledges, pleasures, and powers” (72). The issue at hand is the process spreading sex all across things and bodies, one that arouses it and summon it to speak, but mainly, one that grounds…

    • 1919 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    1257). However it suffers from many shortcomings. Firstly his theories are vague and therefore are unable to be scientifically tested. There is no scientific evidence for the thinking behind his psychosexual phases, and while they have brought understanding to sexual development, it is impossible to know whether children experience something such as the oedipus complex. The psychological elements of his theory cannot be confirmed.…

    • 1680 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Effects Of Hookup Culture

    • 1248 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Ideally, they will be more costumed to the movement and would not accept the changes of committing to love because it is not what they are used to or desirably want. The hookup culture may come off as being something that is wrong, but why would people be a part of something when there is no right? Being in a relationship can lead into trouble and may cause problems that can be avoided down the road. In the hookup culture, you mainly know what you are getting into, so you shouldn’t expect anything different. But dealing with a relationship, it is not as simple as some people may seem to put it.…

    • 1248 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    The reason for such practice is due to corporations concern on the potential negative feedback of the general market place, and impacts on the image of the corporation (Peñaloza 34). However, Vargas research demonstrates how the general consumer can actually have an implicit preference for advertisements that have homoerotic images. Thus, the pressures that are pushing marketers to use false representations, is not exactly imposed by the general consumer; instead it derives from political and religious institutions that construct and promote hetero-normativity. Therefore, heterosexual subjects who demonstrated implicit preference for homoerotic traits, but no explicit indicators, suggest that they wouldn’t mind the legitimization of gay and lesbians in the marketplace. But societies imposition of what is considered the norm restrains them from free expression and thought.…

    • 1203 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I felt no love, nor feigned any’” (Hawthorne pg number). Since she no longer had a husband to love in Boston, she seeks to act on her repressed desires, to satisfy the primitive urges of her id, by engaging in a relationship with another man. Hawthorne insinuates that Hester did not have inherent control over her actions, so she herself should not have to undergo as extensive a punishment. Hawthorne believes that satisfying the id serves as a natural and a necessary human behavior, and should thus not be looked down upon. Instead, rather, he tries to illustrate to readers that the flaws of society need corrected before people punish others for acting on natural impulses.…

    • 977 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays