Are you for or against genetic tests on children? In the articles,”Why we Should Think Twice About Giving Genetic Tests to Our Kids,” and “Genetic Testing for Kids: Is It a Good Idea?” They both give multiple reasons why it is a bad idea to test kids genetics. The first reason is that adults and children may worry. The second reason is that you may find unknown information. The third reason is that if you get diagnosed it may be incurable.
One of the main reasons it is a bad idea to genetically test children without their consent is that it could cause children to worry unnecessarily. According to www.impact-study.co.uk children who “ have a brother or sister who has been shown to carry that gene alteration, they may feel guilty at having …show more content…
The first example can be located at www.cancerresearchchuk,org. The website states, “Only fifty percent of people with cancer survive.” That is a very slim chance if you were to get you children genetically test and find something out like that would you want your kids to live their life knowing that. The next example is located in the article “ Genetic Testing for Kids: Is It a Good Idea?” The article states the claim, “As the AAP stated in a summary of the journal article, it advises against testing kids for adult-onset conditions “ when this information has not been shown to reduce mortality through interventions initiated in childhood.” This example shows a great amount of mortality meaning close to death and your kids would have to live with the fact that they will have a disease when they are older if they get a positive diagnoses. The final example for this reason can be found in the article “ Why We Should Think Twice About Giving Genetic Tests to Our Kids.” The article states, “ But should these children really spend their childhood knowing they have a ninety percent chance of contracting breast cancer when they’re older.” Why should a child have to go through their entire life knowing the fact they have a high risk of cancer when they are older. These are a few reasons for why genetic tests on children is a bad idea and that it can be
One of the main reasons it is a bad idea to genetically test children without their consent is that it could cause children to worry unnecessarily. According to www.impact-study.co.uk children who “ have a brother or sister who has been shown to carry that gene alteration, they may feel guilty at having …show more content…
The first example can be located at www.cancerresearchchuk,org. The website states, “Only fifty percent of people with cancer survive.” That is a very slim chance if you were to get you children genetically test and find something out like that would you want your kids to live their life knowing that. The next example is located in the article “ Genetic Testing for Kids: Is It a Good Idea?” The article states the claim, “As the AAP stated in a summary of the journal article, it advises against testing kids for adult-onset conditions “ when this information has not been shown to reduce mortality through interventions initiated in childhood.” This example shows a great amount of mortality meaning close to death and your kids would have to live with the fact that they will have a disease when they are older if they get a positive diagnoses. The final example for this reason can be found in the article “ Why We Should Think Twice About Giving Genetic Tests to Our Kids.” The article states, “ But should these children really spend their childhood knowing they have a ninety percent chance of contracting breast cancer when they’re older.” Why should a child have to go through their entire life knowing the fact they have a high risk of cancer when they are older. These are a few reasons for why genetic tests on children is a bad idea and that it can be