Imitation And Gender Insubordination In Shakespeare's Romeo And Juliet

Decent Essays
In this world there are certain expectations that are precedent in society, such as the way men and women act. “Romeo and Juliet by William Shakespeare was a great play that will always be noted as one of the best tragedies of all time.The novel contains examples of gender performativity shown through Romeo and Juliet that sparks an interesting discussion. “Imitation and Gender Insubordination” by Judith Butler brings up a lot of debatable topics on gender and society.Judith Butler 's idea of performative gender and her theory of the roles of men and women in society are that they they should not be stereotyped. Her theory connects and in fact complements the idea of gender performance shown in the novel Romeo And Juliet and how characters …show more content…
Butler states that all though one may show signs and characteristics of a certain gender does not determine their outwardly desires. In this text we can conclude that Romeo in some aspects can be perceived as a soft and emotional man, although this is true these actions does not make him homosexual. He shows emotional and physical attraction towards Juliet and expresses his feelings in a extremely chivalrous manner, which in this time period women would see these actions as feminine traits. Romeos gender identification is not only established through us reading about his love for Juliet but his interactions with other characters within the story. But, according to Judith Butler because of his exhibit of what is considered as feminine traits these traits are presenting themselves from a symptom of his inner core identity and his trueself of reflecting a homosexual identity. However, Butler says that gender identity does not express all inner truth, but it is the product of repetition of actions which makes gender a performance. According to this section of her theory we may assume or ponder upon the idea that Romeo had been exposed and interacted with mostly females as he was growing up which caused him to develop his soft and emotional traits and effected his gender performativity. But at the end of the day he is still a male and desires to be with a female. Moving on …show more content…
Juliet switches to becoming a normal submissive woman which allows Friar Lawrence to persuade her easily. His plan was for her to take a fake potion that would make her seem dead in order to avoid the conflict of the marriage dispute between her parents.She changes into a what seems to be a newly found feminine role that the reader isn’t fond of by letting someone give her actions to follow. In the final scene of the play,Romeo reverts back to his natural gender identity because he has seen that them acting as new people has caused many problems in their relationship leading up to her “death”. Romeo becomes very sad and heartbroken at seeing his loved one lying on the floor and takes his life with poison, which is a more feminine form of suicide. Then after that, Juliet wakes up and sees her husband’s dead body and stabs herself with a dagger in a violent manner that reflects a more masculine form of suicide which brings the great Shakespearean play to an end.Regarding gender in terms of performativity, Judith Butler rejects anything that promotes the use of gender categories that affect the identity of people.Gender for her is always a performance which is entirely a social matter in which others perceive and will forever make judgements

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    the feud has been started by the ancestors of the two families. The people fighting in this feud are the young people, the people who have no reason to fight are told to fight and hate the other family. An example of this is Tybalt, a Capulet, who is a prominent brawler against the Montagues, states that he hates the very word of peace after the Montagues offered a ceasefire. The reason and motive for this is unknown, however, which indicates that he has just been continuing his family’s battle just because he is told to.…

    • 183 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The main characters defy the laid down norms on the expected behavior. For instance, when Juliet’s father tries to marry her off to Paris she defies something not common with the women here. In her interaction with Romeo, she is not shy. In fact she dominates much of the conversation, leading the relationship on “if that thy bent be honorable, / Thy purpose marriage, send me word tomorrow”…

    • 906 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Until recently, the world was extremely sexist and in Romeo and Juliet, Juliet was the subject of sexism. Fortunately, in today’s world, the story would never have occurred in the same way. One example of sexism in the play is when Juliet states that she doesn’t want to marry Paris. Capulet exclaims she is “unworthy” of such a man like Paris. Not only, is Capulet not respecting Juliet preference, but he is putting Paris’s desires above Juliet’s because he’s a man.…

    • 561 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mercutio at fault? Romeo and Juliet Essay Due to Friar Laurence’s decisions he is most at fault for the deaths of the lovers Romeo and Juliet. Friar Laurence married Romeo to Juliet and became overly involved in their love life that tragically ended one night in the cemetery of the Capulet family. Romeo begged Friar the night Romeo and Juliet met by chance, the Friar married the two just days following their first encounter in secret, not obeying the family rules. Friar had known that the two were part of two different enemy households, the Montagues and Capulets.…

    • 852 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    William Shakespeare did not become arguably the most famous playwright in the history of the world for coloring inside the lines. In each one of his complex plays, he pushes against the boundaries of social norms. Shakespeare incorporates bold discussions of fleeting love, gender uncertainty, mistaken identity, and ironic comedy into his creative plots during the 1600’s when public discussion on such progressive ideas were rare. In his comedy Twelfth Night, Shakespeare uses dialogue between his three main characters, Viola, Orsino, and Olivia, to express his critique on the strict nature of gender roles during his time. Through his manipulation of his characters’ identities, his placement of women in leadership positions, and his questioning of traditional gender roles, Shakespeare reveals his theme that strict definitions of gender reinforce false stereotypes of both men and women.…

    • 1503 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Jean Baudrillard, a notable French sociologist, once said, “There is no aphrodisiac like innocence.” This holds true in the epic story of Romeo and Juliet. Juliet, the young daughter of the Capulets, falls in love with Romeo, the young son of the Montagues. Both of these young lovers are practically children, innocent in the beginning of the story; furthermore, both lose their innocence during their first true love. In Shakespeare’s epic tragedy Romeo and Juliet, Juliet makes a serious of rash decisions that show her losing her innocent, transforming from the rich, young daughter of the Capulets, to the suicidal lover of her family’s mortal enemy.…

    • 1209 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Romeo and Juliet “Romeo, Romeo, Romeo! Here’s drink. I drink to thee”(Act 4 Scene 3) This quote is talking about Juliet drinking poison. Romeo and Juliet should not be taught in the ninth grade curriculum.…

    • 555 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    What is an appropriate reaction when someone gets angry? Is it to lose your temper and make the situation worse? In Romeo and Juliet, the way Tybalt reacted was not appropriate for the situations that took place in the play. He blew things way out of proportion and let the situations get the best of him. Tybalt is responsible for his own death because he came looking for trouble, he killed Mercutio, and he didn’t listen to demands from other, more powerful people. First of all,Tybalt caused his own death because he was looking to start a fight with Romeo.…

    • 545 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Romeo and Juliet Essay: Killed By Love By: Sidney K. Have you ever been in love? The tale, Romeo and Juliet, is a tragic love story that takes place in Verona Italy, in which the main protagonists attempts to be together are cruelly destroyed by numerous components. William Shakespeare embellishes four of these many components more than any of the others; Friar Laurence, society, the Lord and Lady of both Montague and Capulet, and the lovers themselves. These factors quickly try to destroy Romeo and Juliet’s love and lead to deep sorrow, for not only the lovers, but for their family and friends.…

    • 1476 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet explores the tragic love of two teens from warring families. Amongst neglectful parents and horrific coincidences, readers have questioned the causes that lead up to the young couple’s deaths for years, whether they result from chance or choice. In Act 4, Scene I of the play, Juliet confronts the Friar for help in avoiding her soon approaching marriage to Paris. Though this speech could characterize Juliet as immature and brash, Shakespeare’s use of powerful words, careful balance between mono- and polysyllabic lines, and even scornful language characterize Juliet more so as a determined and honorable young woman set on upholding her marriage to Romeo.…

    • 972 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Literature is commonly viewed as a dramatic reflection of societal views and beliefs. Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet illustrates a quarrel between two fighting families, both of which are ruled by men, with two starcrossed lovers forbidden to wed due to their family’s fighting. Traditional societal views, such as the belief that men dominated society and women should submit to their husbands, influenced gender roles in Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet. During the Elizabethan Era, men were expected to be strong, dominant and were responsible for running society. Since society favorite men in all areas of life, men were given many opportunities.…

    • 571 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Intro: There are many themes in Romeo and Juliet. The theme I found the most important is that “love is tragic.” Love isn’t always tragic but in Romeo and Juliet it is. Paragraph 1: Some evidence I found to support my theme, was when Mercutio was explaining Queen Mab and what she does to people who love.…

    • 505 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However, in order to help Juliet through her "grief" over Tybalt's death, Capulet decides to marry her off to Paris (III, iv). Of course this is a problem as she is secretly married to Romeo at this time. In III, v, Lady Capulet states, "I'll send one in Mantua, where that same banished runagate doth live, that he shall soon keep Tybalt company…" (ll94-96). This statement prophesizes Romeo's death later in the final scene of the play. Then, Lady Capulet wishes her daughter to be married to her grave (ll. 145), which is ironic, as Juliet will take a potion causing her to appear dead in IV, ii. That same evening, the lovers consummate their marriage, and in the morning, Juliet makes yet another prophesy, "O God, I have an ill-divining soul!…

    • 1189 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Romeo is a very complicated character, he is handsome, intelligent, impulsive and very sensitive. He is charming and well liked, amongst most characters in the play. Romeo’s emotions run very strong, throughout the play. Though he is very impulsive and immature. He is still a passionate lover, though sometimes unusual, when he is first introduced in the story, he is obsessed with Rosaline, in act I scene I, saying she is the perfect women.…

    • 658 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Not many of Shakespeare’s plays contain a female character in the lead role position. Therefore, when female characters have a prominent role in plays it is something to pay attention to. For instance, in Measure for Measure, Isabella’s character serves to break down the patriarchy by using their own constructs to emphasize how outrageous their ideas are. Isabella does this by falling into one of the three categories that the patriarchy says women belong to. In this society, women are either maid, widow, or wife and problems occur when women do not fall into one of the three defined categories.…

    • 939 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays