Traditional Gender Roles Analysis

Improved Essays
Traditional gender roles permeate every aspect of society, dictating how we sit, eat, bath, dress, smile, and walk. Thus, it is only reasonable to assume that gender, and the roles ascribed to each group within the binary, will also impact the political nature of an individual. Differences in socialization, education, experience, and demeanor have ultimately developed a dichotomy between male and female legislators. The dualistic terms in which we assign traits (e.g. classifying one action/emotion/trait as feminine and its counterpart as masculine) has placed women at a significant disadvantage when we consider the process of becoming an influential and powerful public figure. By applying these differing expectations to political structures …show more content…
In contrast, it has been found that men are more likely to develop patterns of behavior that emphasize competition and forcefulness, traits that are equally likely to be applied in the legislative process (Rosenthal 2000). The effect of gender on these legislative duties cannot be easily quantified, but research concerning the interaction of men and women would logically predict a disparity in effectiveness as a result of gender. Legislative effectiveness is often measured through a “hit rate” analysis, observing the passage of sponsored legislation for each representative. Research conducted with these “hit rate” analyses have yielded mixed results, with some indicating that women are more effective than male legislators (Volden and Wiseman 2010; Anzia and Berry 2011), and others indicating that gender is irrelevant when predicting legislative effectiveness (Jaydel and Taylor 2003). Furthermore, recent research concerning gender’s influence on legislative effectiveness seems to have identified interaction variables, such as party status (majority or minority), that indicate an “ebb and flow” of superior effectiveness among the genders. Of course, a significant portion of any representative’s work, at the state or national level, occurs without a formal proposal or …show more content…
Legislators often work within party and committee structures in order to exert their influence over a variety of issues (Volden and Wiseman 2010). That being the case, the academic community has not reached consensus on whether or not either gender is naturally more effective than the other. Consequently, we can determine that the democratic theory explaining the gender gap in representation is unfounded. Many assert that a gender gap in political presence predisposes female legislators to focus primarily on family issues. Dissimilar life experiences, expectations, and gender norms among men and women have led female legislators to concentrate their efforts on matters that are often controlled by females, primarily child rearing and family development (Volden and Wiseman 2010). The tendency for legislators to focus their political agenda on matters that effect a subordinate or underrepresented group to which they belong transcends is only logical. In fact this phenomenon transcends gender, as legislators of a racial minority have also been observed narrowing their legislative focus as a means of maximizing the legislative benefit for their respective group (Hamm, Harmel, and Thompson 1983). In this case the gender gap in political “presence” is reasonable, as policy

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    Congressional approval ratings have proven to be dependent upon the partisan lens in which the public views their legislative decisions. The public tends to have higher approval ratings when Congress approves legislation that aligns with their political views and lower approval ratings when congress approves legislation that does not. However, in “How Partisan Conflict in Congress Affects Public Opinion: Strategies, Outcomes, and Issue Differences” Flynn and Harbridge examine how approval ratings are affected when congressional decisions result in legislative gridlock. They find that when compared to partisan conflict resulting in partisan wins, loses, or and gridlock, the latter results in the least public approval.…

    • 1527 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Term Limits Case Study

    • 471 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The purpose of this paper is to answer the question of under what conditions legislators seek for higher office? Based on the results from the data collected, open seats is what influence state legislators to run for Congress. The results showed that term limited states are not really opening the door to minorities to run for office. Imposing term limits does not make a difference, as some scholars argued, that term limits were forcing legislators to run for Congress, the data in this paper does not support those arguments. Not to mention, the level of professionalism in states does not matter.…

    • 471 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In deciding the books “Filibustering: A Political History of Obstruction in the House and Senate” and “Filibuster: Obstruction and Lawmaking in the U.S.” for review, the central topic to consider for discussion quite literally hits us over the head via the book titles. But to be thorough (tedious) I shall mention it more blatantly: The topic for this review discussion is the concept of Filibustering. The opportunity and method to filibuster is what gives the US Senate an interesting twist to its proceedings. The right of senators to singly or in a group, speak for an unlimited time unless opponents can secure sixty votes, also known as a super-majority, to impose cloture is preserved in the chamber's traditions and practices.…

    • 578 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Term Paper “No man is ever good enough to govern another man without the others’ consent” –Abraham Lincoln. In current American politics, the United States congress has a low record of eleven percent acceptance rating. Despite such a low approval rating, the congress is still passing bills that become laws. In this essay, I will discuss how different political scientist argue as to why congress approval has been at an all time low. In depth, I will use Hibbing and Morse’s articles were the most persuasive of all other authors.…

    • 1488 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is the world’s worst kept secret - politicians want to get reelected. To accomplish this goal, they will have to convince their constituents that they deserve it. They may face the misfortune of being in a state where their party is not favored - perhaps they won the seat to begin with because their opponent was simply unacceptable, even though the state identifies with the ideology of their opponent’s party. In these kinds of situations, the candidate’s charasma and good will may go a long way in securing the candidate’s election. Perhaps, the issue in achieving reelection is that the President of the United States from the opposing party is not letting them pass pieces of legislation.…

    • 1653 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Term Limits In Congress

    • 568 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Knowing the Limits When America’s founding fathers composed the Constitution two centuries ago, they created the legislative branch to write and enforce laws to better the nation. Since then, congressmen and American citizens debate whether or not the Legislative Branch has upheld its original job of benefitting the people. This concern developed out of a growing public perception of government corruption. In an attempt to address this concern, the possibility of enforcing term limits on congress has come into debate. Ultimately, the long-term desire is to restore confidence in and the productiveness of the legislative branch of government.…

    • 568 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The promises and possibilities of reelection dictate the behavior of members of congress. Unlike the President of the United States, members of Congress are not restrained by a term limit, and, consequently, spend their careers focused wooing their constituency in a constant effort towards reelection. As a result, David Mayhew in Congress: The Electoral Connection has labeled congressional members as single-minded: the motivation for a member of congress being the ultimate prize of reelection. Yet, a hypothetical congressional term limit would undoubtedly alter the behavior of congressional members. By first comparing legislators’ behavior before and after the establishment of a congressional term limit, it becomes evident that such a change…

    • 1478 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Filibuster Analysis

    • 785 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Modern Issues and Applications Both majority and minority parties have utilized the filibuster and the vague rules surrounding it to pursue individual party agendas. For example, during the 113th Congress (2013-2015) changes to the “tracking” technique occurred when minority Republicans agreed to not filibuster legislation so long as the Democratic majority allowed them to suggest amendments. This restricted the Democrat Majority Leader’s ability to block the Republican minority from adding amendments, entitling the minority to two of the four pending amendments. The 113th Congress also considered changes to filibuster rules, such as lowering the number of votes necessary for cloture, however there wasn’t enough support at the time to obtain…

    • 785 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Voter’s Influence All past presidents were male but this year Hillary Clinton had her second chance to become the president of the Unites States, however the male candidate won yet again. Some are furious and even believe that she lost because she is a women. The lack of female politicians have raised questions if gender still influences voters decisions. In the United States the gender does affect a voter's behavior because of sexism, unconscious responses, and stereotypes, Today there are female senators, governors and justices, but never a chief in command. When it becomes voting time males and females choose certain candidates for a high authority figure, and they might not even know it.…

    • 922 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This meant that 30% of participation in the list of candidates for legislative elections were women. Over the years women have struggled to become equal to their male counterparts. This struggle also translates to women in the…

    • 1502 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    When states need to redraw districts after every census, it is often up to state legislatures to figure out the lines. Within limits, the state legislatures can draw the districts however they see fit. The basic requirements from the federal government are equal populations in each congressional district, and compliance with the 1982 Voting Rights Amendment. The Voting Right Amendment prohibited both discriminatory intents and effects when drawing district lines, and allowed for the creation of majority-minority districts as a method of remedying discriminatory effects. Most other considerations – such as a desire to make districts geographically compact – are based on state laws.…

    • 1524 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Decent Essays

    When election season starts coming around every four years, there are many different aspects to planning out how to proceed and how to win, when it comes to the candidates or the President of the United States. Most of the time they base their campaigns on winning over their party population whether that be Democratic or Republican. But what happens when this candidate gets elected? Are their best interests in the people or in their own endeavors? Political scientist Morris P. Fiorina makes three claims about the elected candidate and us citizens; that the President will act in greed and self-interest in order to get power, that they will want to be re-elected in the next term, and if we, as voters, get along with the party of the President,…

    • 462 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    "Once upon a time, it was a man’s world,” states David Brooks firmly. For centuries it has been understood that men rule over the more important dominant and power positions of the world. From great male pharaohs, to an increasingly systematic view of presidency, men have been able to manipulate genetic gender roles in order to instill the notion that it’s truly a world only able to stand with the leadership of men. However, contrary to the beliefs of the gender based roles of conduct in society, that represent males as supreme in intelligence and in physical dominance, we have evolved into an era where woman carry an equivalent and sometimes ever greater capacity to strive for success than ever before over men. To begin with, no longer…

    • 1168 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Introduction Richard F. Fenno, Jr. has undoubtedly made some of the biggest contributions to political science that society has ever seen. With that being said, Bernhard and Sulkin have also contributed to the field of political science in some sense with things such as innovation in analytics and equations, quantitative data, along with their knack of coming up with new legislative styles, and identifying the styles of lesser-known legislators. They did have some strengths but overall the more in depth the article was examined, the harder and it became to read and the less valid their study seemed to be, compared to the works read in class. Moreover, Bernhard and Sulkin showed more weaknesses than strengths, including: not being personable…

    • 1532 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Although there is not currently a term limit placed on all members of Congress, the democratic process would greatly benefit from the enactment of an established limit. Serving as a member of Congress should not be idealized as a career choice, rather one should serve with the desire to create a change in policy and dismiss himself when that change is seen through. The pros to instituting a term limit on Congressional members far outweigh the cons because the primary goal of both the House of Representatives and Senate should be to bring positive change to our nation. Without term limits we will continue to be stuck in a mediocre cycle of citizens who are unhappy with their government, but unwilling to do something about it. Some may believe that setting a term limit for Congress is “resorting to an indirect instrument” to voting for the incumbent (Kong-Pin Chen).…

    • 1000 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays