Religion In Galileo's Daughter

Great Essays
In Galileo’s Daughter, Dava Sobel assembles an account of Galileo’s attempt to prove the heliocentric model of the universe in a world where mans’ logical reasoning is potent, yet second to his devotion to God, and by relation, the Catholic Church. Sobel writes about Galileo’s tendency to question the reasoning of those around him. Though it may not be apparent, Galileo was born into a world of great similarity to the modern day. In Galileo’s time, Science was seen as blasphemy and a tool to undermine the construct of God. Moreover, it didn’t help matters that at the time, the Church was the governing body throughout Italy. This made it particularly difficult for scientific advancement, as any theory that suggested conflict with religious teaching …show more content…
Theodore Schick’s book, Doing Philosophy, identifies the relationship between logical reasoning and the origin of religion. Throughout history, there have been particular instances when this problem of religious dispute has come to face particularly large amounts of consideration. In essence, it is during these times of great change in widespread understanding, such as during the Roman Inquisition; an age chronicled in Dava Sobel’s, Galileo’s Daughter, that this annoyance becomes a significant problem for humanity. Evidently, the institution of religion is so deeply integrated into human social behavior, that many have come to accept it as fact. Given that, it must be understood that religion is an outdated establishment created to explain what could not previously be understood. Markedly, in this establishment, we sacrifice the truth within our understanding in exchange for a wider scope of explanation. Consequently, this breeds an interpretation of reality that expresses a less than real understanding of the world. This becomes problematic when such beliefs become so widely held that one can misappropriate them to discount factual evidence. Under no circumstance are we justified to partake in the practice exhibited in Galileo’s Daughter, in which the Church denounces the validity of worldly observations, on the ground that it conflicts with the doctrine of its religious

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Galileo: Science, Scripture, and Truth Among the academics that fostered growth in developing European society and scholasticism, Galileo Galilei holds a hierarchy attributable to the highly dynamic time period that his life spanned, as well as an unmatchable intellect that fostered vital observations in the sixteenth century. Often defamed for his religiously controversial discoveries and scientific ideals, Galileo repeatedly rose to contest institutions, like the Catholic church and its adherents, in order to cornerstone the secularization of European science and philosophy. Evident in his “Letter to Castelli” and “Letter to the Grand Duchess Christina,” Galileo asserts that there is no use for Catholic scripture in the pursuit of science and reason, though he still gives ample merit to a better-suited purpose of purifying and saving souls. These letters demonstrate a deep opposition to putting faith-based and logically unsound Catholic opinion above calculated and certified scientific fact, which would obliterate any truth to the goal of understanding the physical world.…

    • 843 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Galileo Dbq

    • 858 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Sadia Usman Professor Acoppola Lit237 10/27/2014 In the seventeenth century, scientist and philosophers were lacking the instruments to make observations and further their experiments. The seventeenth century was also known as the scientific revolution. During the scientific revolution, philosophers mainly confided in people from the church and the ancient world. Before the scientific revolution, the Europeans were uneducated about science.…

    • 858 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Antonio is naturally disbelieving when Florence first confides in him about his disbelief in God. Florence rationalizes to him that no God would have forced an innocent child to endure the death of his mother and the woes of a drunken father (195), yet Antonio attempts to justify the nature of Florence’s struggles, claiming that “‘God puts obstacles in front of us so that we will have to overcome them’” (196). But Antonio quickly realizes his naivety, admitting that he “was still trying to hold on to God,” and that he “‘did not think [he] could live without God’” (196). As a young boy, it feels unnatural for him to reject the beliefs that are the very backbone of his mother’s identity; to believe in another God would be to betray his mother and to venture into unknown religious territory.…

    • 1043 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In a Catholic institution, theology acts as a department for finding truths within human comprehension; these truths are found based on God’s “self-revelation [and] ‘understanding’ what God has revealed” as opposed to just Scripture since not all of the ancient texts are universally accepted and had to go through intense examination if they are (Cavadini…

    • 760 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    David Schwitzer April 15, 2015 Professor McCartin Essay #3 Does Religion Need A Justification To Be Important? The quote by Christopher Hitchens, "Religion has run out of justifications. Thanks to the telescope and the microscope, it no longer offers an explanation for anything important,” would be seen as accurate by both Barbara Ehrenreich and Gershom Gorenberg. In Ehrenreich’s book, “Living With a Wild God”, she talks about being an atheist and how growing up in a non-religious home made her become a rationalist.…

    • 1021 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Scientific Revolution Dbq

    • 1361 Words
    • 6 Pages

    . . if I be, nor wholly deceived, will hold that my labors contribute even to the well being of the Church” (Doc 1). Copernicus knew how his works would spark an intense theological debate; therefore, dedicating his book to the pope because he wanted to show that his works were not works of blasphemy. The Church, at this period of time, would punish scientists whose works did not parallel to the Church’s beliefs. This was proven apparent in cases such as Copernicus and Galileo's theories about astronomy.…

    • 1361 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Which three enlightenment scientists contributed greatly to the sciences and the modern world? The enlightenment period was a very important time in history. During this time, everything was changing. Politics, science, and the old way of life were radically changing.…

    • 474 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    What Galileo was arguing was, if the faculties of the senses are G-d given, so is the need for reason, which in this case would be science, more specifically his scientific claims. By choosing not to question and reason all that was presented as the truth, one was choosing not to follow one of the actual Scriptural truths. Furthermore, this claim opposed what Aristotle proved to be the truth (the Church’s convention), and “therefore mistrusting their defense so long as they confine themselves to the field of philosophy, these men have resolved to fabricate a shield for their fallacies out of the mantle of pretended religion and the authority of the Bible.” Even though his teachings were not accepted by the general public, there were a few religious figures that backed up his statements.…

    • 1209 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Why Is Galileo Wrong

    • 541 Words
    • 3 Pages

    He uses an example of how any "idiot" can see a human body, but a philosopher or anatomist will be able to explain the function of each nerve, muscle and bone. Galileo asserts how the Church does not have authority in specific places, especially where mathematics and physics are involved. Galileo had his theory of the Earth orbiting the Sun, and not the other way around, supported by mathematics, astronomy, and physics. The Church had authority in many places, but Galileo made it clear how the Church cannot change fact because of the Word of God. The Church's promotion of education inspired individuals to become educated and eventually challenge the Church with…

    • 541 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Philosophy has been plagued with the subject of religion since the dawn of time. Each philosopher having their own opinions, many attempts have been made to prove and disprove their opinion and the opinions of others. The existence of God, a single, supreme being who created the heavens and the earth, is a controversial topic, but even among those who believe in the existence of God, finding a way to explain such existence has been nigh impossible. An 18th century philosopher, David Hume attempted to establish his opinion on the existence of God by critiquing the widely accepted ideals set forth by Descartes.…

    • 1206 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    David Bentley Hart, a renowned theologian and philosopher, has accepted the challenge presented by the New Atheist ideals. In Hart’s publication, Atheist Delusions: The Christian Revolution and Its Fashionable Enemies he explains to the reader the falsehood of Atheism and how the rejection of Christianity has negatively impacted humanity. There are four themes that Hart uses to convey this message: Faith and reason in today’s society, Christianity’s influence and misunderstanding throughout the Middle Ages, Christianity’s attempt to shape present culture, and why the rejection of the peaceful religion will cause a negative impact. Within this explanation, both theologians and atheist philosophers are able to explore a true account of how…

    • 1312 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Scientific Revolution Dbq

    • 780 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Science started to attract followers that believed its theories that opposed to those of the church, while religion was just faith. Many were working aside from the church’s beliefs and making way for science to explain the secrets of the unknown. During this time not only did scientific areas prosper, but also areas in economic and governmental views. Philosopher demanded exemption of speech and the press, and they criticized the strict censorship that most governments exercised. They started to believe censorship was harmful because it prevented people from learning about fresh ideas.…

    • 780 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I chose this text from the book Angels and Demons by the well-known author Dan Brown. The story mainly takes place in Rome and I believe it depicts a battle between two very influential components in society: science and religion. Dan Brown shows us a contrast between the beliefs of science and religion and the tension that’s created when they're combined. As the book progresses the main problem Brown is trying to address is the question a lot of characters in the book are trying to answer, can science and religion exist together?…

    • 487 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Galileo’s scientific method over time changed the underlying philosophy and overall aims of scientific research. Before Galileo’s notion of the scientific method we use today scientists use to have to understand the ‘why’ as well as the ‘how’ of their discoveries. Causing them to dwell in the world of philosophers instead of scientific observing. Galileo’s scientific method influenced and changed the direction of what was once a science of god and theology science into the path of pure observation. Galileo also quantified science stipulating that a scientist should explain phenomena mathematically and use experimentation to prove it with the use of hypotico-deductive methodology.…

    • 133 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Why Did the Catholic Church Put Galileo on Trial for Heresy? And What Was the Significance of the Trial? Galileo was summoned to trial twice for heresy. First, for the heliocentric model and then for the geocentric model.…

    • 1023 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays