From Show And Tell Mccloud Analysis

Improved Essays
Analytical Essay
Traditions have led to people having a restricted point of view on the use of images in various types of texts (Books, articles, etc.). In Scott McCloud’s graphic essay, From Show and Tell, he discusses how the use of images in a story does not lessen the effect the story has on the reader. He believes when text and image come together the greatest works are made. McCloud makes this claim due to his background of being a comic artist. His profession incorporates the usage of both text and image to progress the story. In order to support his claim, he gives us examples of how a story would be different depending on the uses of words and images. By using pictures and words McCloud can create metaphors that catches the eye of
…show more content…
Many believe that the use of images creates a childish appeal which takes away from a story. McCloud states, “It’s considered normal… for children to combine words and pictures, so long as they grow out of it” (From Show and Tell, 739). He is telling the reader that using pictures in writing is something only children are allowed to do so long as they grow out of it. People treat it as if it is a bad habit. McCloud’s message is an attempt to convince those who believe this to be true in order show them the true advantage of using pictures. The many other authors that write comics/graphic novels can agree with him since images play a huge role in their …show more content…
In science there is a lot of information that can be discussed among many. James Balm states, “Images help us become involved (biomedcentral.com).” This is true simply because pictures are a way to place a lot of information into a condensed view that is easier for people to understand and remember. This is because everyone has their own way of learning. There are 3 major types of learners, visual, auditory, and kinesthetic. Most people learn using a combination of the three styles listed, however there are those who are more adept in one style than in the others (learningrx.com). Since not everyone is able to fully understand when information is being told to them, the incorporation of pictures allows for a larger amount of people to then understand what it is the presenter is teaching. This goes back to McCloud’s idea of the use of images not being childish and it in fact is a helpful resource at our disposal. When reading a comic, the reader is able to see the connection between the words and pictures, thus resulting in them having a more vivid image in their minds in terms of setting and how the appearance of a character is. Children are giving picture book with few words since it is easier for them to understand, but that doesn’t mean adults cannot read books of a similar nature. It is only when words and pictures come together

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Foundation Before Density In Scott McCloud’s graphic essay, “Show & Tell”, McCloud uses an appreciable combination of words and images interchangeably to convey clear and comprehensible thoughts, He establishes better, more understood, literature by depicting images directly alongside pieces of text. Evidently, pictures are an associative mechanism that enables newcomer and experienced readers to make visual connections to text they normally would not conclude to by only analyzing and interpreting words (McCloud). Moreover, aside from images allowing readers to make connections, illustrations are particularly crucial components in literary works because they can convey coherent messages all on their own. In all, visual depictions in literature…

    • 1206 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Comic Book Superheroes Unmasked can be used as an effective source for an introductory paper on the top of superhero comic books. There are a number of credible sources used within the documentary as guest speakers that are relevant, experienced or influential in comics. The information is presented in a consistent manner following the creation of comics and how the time period they were published in affected the comics. The information is also appropriate for a wide audience due to the documentary assuming that the audience has no background on superhero comic books which causes them to give the information to the audience in a manner all age groups can understand. The final way the documentary is a credible source is the information that is presented is backed up with examples.…

    • 1230 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    1. Introduction Most people deem that picture books are straightforwardly used to beguile children in their leisure time. Nevertheless, the previous statement is not utterly truthful: these books are not only advisable for the entertainment but education as well - particularly infant education- . This paper aims at showing the importance of picture books in the growth of people, particularly in the one of those who need special schooling. In order to attest it, the importance of the image in a picture book and of picture book itself will be explained; in addition, multimodal approach and how picture books work in this methodology will be demonstrated.…

    • 1942 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Lines In Graphic Comics

    • 2043 Words
    • 9 Pages

    In the comic, both author and illustrator wanted specific pages within the graphic novel to be noticed and centered on by readers. In order to capture emotions of these visual narratives, certain pages required more careful and diligent attention than others as it relied on lines to expressed sensations a character undergo due to Canadian colonial practices. Seen on the 26th page that depicts Joey Caver’s life, there is a sudden change in the variation of lines that differ from the previous pages. The lines before this page are very straightforward and clearcut. The lines are bold and are rarely broken.…

    • 2043 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    It would be more beneficial if they are “cozened into a knowledge of letters; be taught to read, without perceiving it to be anything but a sport, and play themselves into that which others are whipped for” (Locke 272). This shows children that education does not have to be tedious and boring and it can start to become something that they look forward to doing on their own. Plat and Locke both observe the use of the dice game and conclude that children respond better when they are educated through playful and enjoyable activities, rather than through the traditional methods of paper and pen or beating. In addition, scholarly writer Diana…

    • 1984 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The ability of an author to create an image and understanding of the characters within their stories is what can separate many average authors from the great ones. Both Ernest Hemingway and William Faulkner are notorious authors that are famous for their own styles of character development among many other admirable achievements. Just as we judge the character of the people we know in our own lives by the actions they make and the tings they say, authors use the actions and dialogue to create a personality for each of their characters. However, this does not mean that every single character within a story needs to have their entire back story laid out for the reader, but rather that some characters may need to have a bit of their personality…

    • 1029 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    They sat on the side of me so I had to make sure that everyone one could see the pictures and I did a good job making sure that they all got a chance to see the pictures. I think another thing I did that was good is letting the children chose the book they wanted to read I didn’t pick one for them, they got to choose which one they wanted I think that make it more fun for them and they also stay more engaged that way. Letting the children come and go as they please and not making them say and listen to a book they didn’t want to hear was something I think went best because there were other children and teachers reading books not just…

    • 1202 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Unfortunately I did not begin the large stack I seemed to always have, but instead began reading web comics. It seemed less stressful than opening a book, since my anxiety was pretty severe at that time. Reading webcomics made me excited and inspired again— finding small creators with such beautiful comics was invigorating. I loved to see the formatting and especially the art styles. Looking at such unique styles portraying more complex posing and backgrounds really made me want to work on my own art at the time.…

    • 2108 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Therefore, they will learn by “using PowerPoint presentations, the internet as well as other areas where the information is written” (VARK Learning Limited, 2016). Additionally, learning may take the form of rewriting notes and the continuous use glossary” (VARK Learning Limited, 2016). One of the advantage is many consider this to be an admirable quality. The Kinesthetic Learner Additionally, there is the kinesthetic modality which refers to learning through involvement. These individuals find learning easier by “literally doing something with their hands, other parts of the body, or just by moving around” (Institute for Learning Styles, n.d.).…

    • 796 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Introduction First and foremost, writing a good wiki entry requires good writing and editing skills. However, there are many technical skills involved in creating an attractive and readable wiki entry, as well. In addition to text, most wikis will allow you to insert multimedia such as pictures (see Figure 6.3.1 below for an example). You can also add links to your text--both links to other pages inside the wiki, and links to regular web sites. Knowing how to format your changes can also help make the difference between a wiki page that is hard to read, and one that looks professional.…

    • 1704 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays