Friends Of The Curragh Case Study

Amazing Essays
Executive Summary

The aim of this report is to give an overview of the law relating to protective costs orders in Ireland while comparing it with the UK and Australia and making suggestions for reform. I consulted several sources in relation to protective costs orders in Ireland, the UK and Australia and found suitable material.
In Ireland to date only one PCO has ever been granted . However, PCO’s have also been rejected in this jurisdiction. PCO’s are only granted in cases that are considered to be of exceptional public importance.
The law reform problem is that the standard required to get a PCO in Ireland is simply too high. It is suggested that the standard be lowered to one of general public importance.
It is recommended that the criteria
…show more content…
The Applicant in this case was acting on behalf of the interests of the members of the community. They applied to judicially review two decisions made by An Bord Pleanala in relation to the realignment of a section of roadway and the granting of plans to build a hotel at the Curragh Racecourse. The case involved applying well known principles to new facts. The Court came to the conclusion that though the Applicants may have had a private interest it accepted that some of its members may have had no interest in the outcome of the case. There was no evidence that those who represented the applicant were doing so on a pro bono basis. The Court found it difficult to conceive how it would be fair or just to make a PCO in this case as “ such orders are most exceptional. This case exhibits no circumstances which would merit such an …show more content…
In the 2012 Report on access to justice , made to the United Nations General Assembly, the UN expert on extreme poverty Magdalena Sépulveda pointed out the following:
‘The limited ability of people living in poverty to access legal and adjudicatory processes and mechanisms is not only a violation of human rights in itself (ICCPR Art 14), but is also the consequence of numerous other rights violations. The lack of remedies for the negative impacts of social policy in the areas of health, housing, education and social security, or for administrative decisions relating to welfare benefits or asylum proceedings, often results in inability to seek redress in cases of violations of key human rights, such as the right to equality and non- discrimination and the right to social security’
The denial of the right of access to justice denies people a basic and fundamental right to which they are entitled

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    In the Spanish American War promises that were made were broken leading to a brutal war and a not so democratic solution. After the First World War Woodrow wanted to spread democracy but his fourteen point plan was not supported by the rest of America therefore not successfully spreading democracy overseas. In the case of when America first went overseas to begin associations with other nations, the motives that America had would be considered pure but turned into a situation that could be abused. When we refer back to Washington’s statement that America only ever went overseas to promote and protect democracy is not fully accurate but it can be believed that on the surface and right off the bat that America did only go overseas to promote and protect…

    • 1017 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    As the final appeal for the project (Geever, 2001), this proposal failed to move the funder further. Conclusion Technically speaking, the proposal did not mention how the leadership skill could be built by attaining those attributes, i.e. there is no definition of ‘Leadership’. In short, the proposal was detailed and informative that could give a clear picture to the reader. However, the planner failed to organise the useful materials to present to the potential funders.…

    • 1856 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Essentially, Bentham believes that none of these (natural) rights exists in a state of nature because in such a state, nobody has any rights as people have the right to everything. Thus, no one has certain guaranteed rights that are secure. In his critique, Bentham argues that…

    • 1858 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    But, this still does not adequately substitute legal advice from an experience and qualified legal professional. This implies a lack of legal resources to pursue justice, therefore u fails provision to justice for all, and further excludes the underprivileged. Furthermore, due to legal aid cuts, the underprivileged are vulnerable to third party litigation funding. Even though they do provide alternative funding, which assist with the costs of litigation. Third party litigation funding, initially prioritise potential financial earnings of a case.…

    • 921 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Other America The Other America, by Michael Harrington provides the reader with an extremely vivid look inside poverty in America and the issues surrounding it. One of those issues is with the assistance provided, otherwise known as welfare. The assistance provided to those in poverty is not designed to benefit them, but was built by those with little understanding of poverty. Individuals apart of the Other America face barriers to accessing assistance. The type of assistance may not offer them what they need.…

    • 761 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The result of this could often be results that are not accurate and potentially tampered with. To claim to be an international governing body but have no way of independently conducting and under going research and fact finding missions is unacceptable and takes power away from its ability to be taken as a functioning body. The Human Rights Commission’s reports are used by the Committee however these reports are described as “ inadequate”…

    • 1018 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    American Judges Duty

    • 775 Words
    • 4 Pages

    However in modern society, it is impossible to find a person who has not heard of certain prevalent cases. The media modern media is not regulated and allowed to share their opinion, not the basic facts of the story. This allows opinion to be inserted, and this leads to misinformation. This makes it virtually impossible for any person with access to a television, radio, the internet or any social circle to have these personal opinions presented as fact. And while not all people are smart enough to see the difference between fact and opinion, I am certain that these issues have caused problems in more than one person’s criminal case.…

    • 775 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Similarities between Frost/Nixon and Michael Clayton To begin, the movies Frost/Nixon and Michael Clayton did not have much similarities, but they both had ethical issues. In the movie Frost Nixon, Frost’s intention was to get an interview with President Nixon to drive up his popularity and help him with gaining a possible show on a US TV network. Frost was unethical in this case because he did not explain to his colleagues what is intentions were and could have wasted their time and effort in trying to get Nixon to confess to his unethical decision making while in office. The movie Michael Clayton was had a similar approach as it relates to ethics. During the movie, Marty, the senior partner for the law firm, withheld his intentions of merging the firm with another and in the process of doing so, took on the case of defending U-North, which he knew lied to their customers.…

    • 742 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Success Hotel Case

    • 824 Words
    • 4 Pages

    But in this case, it is the hotel’s duty to ensure safety for the customer. Following this line of authority, it can be argued in this situation that Elena being the customer of this hotel, can sue the hotel for their negligence and not having much care for the customer’s in the hotel. However as a counter argument, Elena was not supposed to act as so, she should have called for help instead of climbing out of the cubicle and attempt to help herself. But the hotel has not much Overall, the situation in this scenario, she can sue the…

    • 824 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    At this point, a pretrial motion to dismiss without prejudice is fair due to the misconduct of police and the violation of the client 's Fourth Amendment Rights. "In other areas of constitutional law and criminal procedure, the Court now routinely engages in textual interpretation informed by history, yet the debate over the exclusionary rule still seems to lack any foothold in conventional constitutional interpretation" (Re, pg. 5). There should be no interpretation whether or not the client 's rights were violated due to the facts in the case that the police blatantly without regard to the U.S. Constitution and showed true police…

    • 1291 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays