Student Teachers Relationship Analysis

Better Essays
Freire starts the base for his essay around the student-teacher relationship, and the dysfunction within. He is very right in saying that the process of teaching is akin to the banking system. This often leads to a poor relationship between the pupil and the almighty instructor. However, is this relationship and the teaching method a package deal? The current approach to teaching is the banking concept, which can lead to an oppressive environment, which is caused by the poor student-teacher relationship. I agree that a different teaching method could be more effective, but I do not agree that the current one can never be improved upon or does not ever work. I would like to demonstrate this through a pair of teachers that I had the somewhat …show more content…
While pondering all the teachers that were labeled the best or worst at Brookville, I began to notice some common traits. A teacher’s likeability has a lot to do with the way their teaching is perceived by the students. Often the teacher’s that students define as good at their job are also easily likeable people. Therefore the teacher’s personality affects the level of classroom equality and atmosphere. An unlikeable teacher is usually a no nonsense person who favors the “I’m in charge of everything” mentality. Another important aspect is level of thinking that a student is allowed in the classroom which also influences the opinion of a teacher, but the student has to have the chance to think. There is a significant difference between having to think for yourself in a class, and being so overwhelmed that you can’t think. Freire says that when using the problem-posing method “The students… are now critical co-investigators in dialogue with the teacher (pg. 9).” yet this is not only true of the problem-posing method. Just because a teacher presents the students with knowledge does not mean that there can be no discussing in the class as well. Consequently the personality and approach of the teacher is what makes the banking method become an oppressive learning …show more content…
Pete, on the other hand, was easily one of the greatest teachers that I have ever had the pleasure of learning from. Instead of fitting the image of the essay, Mr. Pete is more similar to the statement, “From the outset, her efforts must coincide with those of the students to engage in critical thinking… (pg. 5)” He shared a lot of the same feelings as students when it came to the way education works. He interacts with the students largely through jokes and comedy, which is interesting since he’s a biology teacher. His favorite motto is “you have to make your own fun,” and he lives by this in his classroom. He is able to joke around and bring himself down to the same level as the students by not acting like he’s better than they are. On one occasion, he even went so far as to dress in a homemade Iggy Izaela costume for the entertainment of the students, and himself. These are attributes of him that he incorporates into his teaching to be more effective. He also does not let standardized tests dictate what he teaches. He focuses on what he thinks we need to learn since we are at the point in our lives where we make the most mistakes. When there is some kind of scandal or gossip going around the school, Mr. Pete takes this as an opportunity to teach a life lesson to the students. Sometimes it’s about common sense, others might be about how to treat people, or how the real world works. When a Brookville student hears the words “Mr. Pete’s spiels” they know that they are in

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Paulo Freire discussed the teacher-student contradiction in the text of “Pedagogy of the Oppressed.” This contradiction is when students are regulated by teachers. The teachers have the power over the students, which places them in a situation that limits their freedom as a whole. The Banking Concept of Education is the reason for the lack of freedom for students. This concept contradicts students as objects, and not individuals. Assuming that the students know nothing, Freire stated that the students are the empty banks and the instructor is the banker who banks in knowledge into the students.…

    • 953 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    It’s not fair to judge a teacher on the basis and bad reputation of another. If you have doubts, then it is wise to have a sit-down conversation with the teacher and express your concerns. Generally, after the discussion, you will have a better outlook on the type of person who will be assisting your child in his/her educational needs. Thank you goes a long way Sometimes teaching can be a thankless occupation, not because they aren’t gaining fulfillment from instilling their knowledge onto their students and watching them succeed, it’s because they are rarely thanked for their efforts. Just like anywhere, it’s nice to get that pat on the back once in a while to affirm that they are doing a good job.…

    • 1004 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    On the flip side this could expose a lot of the terrible teachers and show schools what type of people they should and should not hire. Just because you have a degree in education does not necessarily mean you are cut out to be a good teacher. Another reason teachers should get evaluated is because even though they teach well, they can not control their students in the class. Some students may have behavior problems but their education is important. I feel as though that it is up to the teacher to find a teaching style that grasps some of the ill mannered children’s attention so they will not be as prone to act up.…

    • 724 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Resulting in the fact that students shouldn't rate their teachers. These teachers work hard to educate their students. It isn't the teacher’s fault that the student is unprepared for class, and lacks the motivation to study. "The bad news is that students often conflate good instruction with pleasant ambience and low expectations. As a result they also reward instructors who grade easily, require less work, are glib and chatty, wear nice clothes, and are physically attractive… Plus students will penalize demanding professors or professors who have given them a bad grade, regardless of the quality of instruction that a professor…

    • 864 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Teachers are more than simply blind punishers. They look at the action and the cause of the misbehavior as opposed to labeling the student. The least useful portion of Dreikurs’ theory is that students may not be truthful when explaining why they misbehaved and it may be difficult for the teacher to identify the true reason. Lee and Marlene Canter: Discipline through assertive tactics Lee and Marlene Canter believe that educators should try to catch students doing good deeds, set standardized rules and punishments, and have the expectations for all students. The Canters believe that there is a place for punishment in the classroom, but only if it is set in stone and standardized.…

    • 1345 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Some explained that it is not that students are unaware of their academic expectations, but without academic motivation, their students find it difficult to be successful and consequently, lose interest in their education. The participants felt that in order for their students to achieve in their classrooms, they have to present the lessons in a manner that the students can relate. They feel it is of the upmost importance that they come up with creative and interesting presentations of the material being taught. In interviewing P2, it was evident that she was interested in reaching her students to get the maximum results in her class. Sshe was a very innovative teacher and really cared about her students’…

    • 1577 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Teaching is partly acting, and acting ability helps greatly. Above all, teachers need to be able to control a class, because without good discipline nothing worthwhile can be achieved. So, that means good teachers are those whom pupils will respect - and slightly fear if necessary. They are completely in control of what’s going on around them. Pupils know the teacher will notice if they are misbehaving or if their work is incomplete or copied from another child and will take action - punish the child, perhaps, or require the work to be redone.…

    • 915 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Schools need to listen to their students and start to value students opinions. The most important thing teachers should be doing is to make sure to ask the students for their insights and observations about the teachers that administration might miss. A lot of students feel they don’t an opportunity to express their feeling and emotions. It is true that every single student in the classroom can not be satisfied but they should be. The students should understand the teacher 's way of teaching and have a good relationship with the teacher.…

    • 1413 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    According to ringing the bell for K-12 teacher tenure reform “tenure keeps bad teachers in front of classrooms sustaining a child’s education”. However, it is not always the teacher’s fault weather a student is failing or not it doesn’t matter if a teacher is good or bad, it is always the student’s decision to learn something from the class. In addition, the Rhee-forming P.C schools insist about how, “teacher tenure should be abolished because it makes it hard to remove a teacher with poor performance or who is guilty for wrong doing”. This may be true; however it is hard, but not impossible to fire them. Teachers who have been accused for low performance of wrongdoing do get fire!…

    • 1333 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Some may cheat because they really don’t understand what the real meaning of academic dishonesty or may not get what’s going on in the classroom for the lessons. Others students may cheat because they feel like they always have to succeed or they look at cheating as tricking their teachers. Some cheaters are acknowledge and some go unacknowledged. You have some teachers in this educational world who grades student work and knows that it has been plagiarized and does nothing about it at all. One of the reason why they don’t do anything is because all of that takes time.…

    • 1212 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays