Free Will And Determinism: A Comparative Analysis

Improved Essays
There is a huge issue on how to evaluate human behavior. People have narrowed it down to Free Will, which means people are responsible for their own actions” and Determinism meaning the environment and the occasion will affect one’s actions. The main issue is choosing one to explain human behavior. The dispute between these ideas can be seen in black or white, meaning some believe in the absolute definition of free will and determinism, while some believe in bits and parts from both concepts. The correct solution could lie in between both ideas indicating that society is influenced by both deterministic and free will at the same time.
My Position Free will and determinism work off each other, meaning they can both work to provide answers
…show more content…
Those benefits being free will promoting stronger motivation to improve and explore (Vohs 2008) and determinism being easily used to root out causes of a decision (Roubertoux 2011). So, using both mindsets allows for more progress and prevention.
My Opposition
My main oppositions would be the ones who believe in determinism or free will whole-heatedly and the faults in both determinism and free will and how they affect society. If someone brings on a hard-set view about free will or determinism, it could work against progress and may cause some social and moral strain due to not taking into account what benefits the opposing side can offer. The opposition’s motive against this position would to remove the one or the other, not both.
Another issue is determinism failing to explain twists such as someone who seemed very likely to make one choice, but ended up choosing the latter. These types of oddities would make determinism’s faulty nature unappealing while making free will more favorable when both should have equal consideration. Use of determinism also has a negative affect on motivation, causing people to put less effort into difficult tasks (Vohs

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Justice 's core values can shift quickly if the ideas of the leaders choose to take a different route than the current mainstream beliefs. A reason for the leaders to change the people 's ideas of justice is that it can be used to motivate others. Although justice in the modern day is seen as protecting the weak, justice is actually a manifestation of the morals of the people…

    • 1008 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Theories On Free Will

    • 770 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Although it may be a little complicated to understand at first, Smart wants us to get rid of the judgmental feelings that we have in regards of someone’s action an instead recommends that “a clear headed” person will use the words “praise” and “blame” when the action is either held to be good or bad. So if the person does something that we did not consider being a good action then it would fall into the “blame” aspect and thus if a person commits an action that does seem to be favorable then it would fall into the “praise” category. In Free Will, Praise and Blame, Smart argued that we have moral responsibility for the choices that we make in regard to praise and blame considering how this may affect those around us. Smart rejects the idea of libertarian free will on the claims that it is “logically incoherent”, making it clear that he does not believe that we have free will. He later goes on to mention also mentions his opinions about “chance ”…

    • 770 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I feel unpremeditated outcomes should have less bearing when appraising the morality of a decision, unless said outcome was a glaring omission. Similarly, as with moral absolutism, human individuality renders the practical application of consequentialism extremely difficult, as it requires individuals to consider the needs of others as having the same value as their own (Smart and Williams, 1973). Whilst being idealistic in theory, in practice individuals are much more likely to act egoistically, in that they value their own interests and desires first and other second (Moseley, n.d.). To summarise, whilst consequentialism is somewhat idealistic, it would require humanity to be all-knowing in their decision-making and completely altruistic, thus the practical application of the theory is…

    • 1036 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Utilitarian Vs Mill

    • 2422 Words
    • 10 Pages

    The reason why it is better is because the Kantian approach seems more practical for real world situations than the utilitarian does. It forces the person to think and be conscious of the intentions and the actions that one carries out. If one thinks of it as becoming a universal law that they cannot be exempt from, then they are less likely to commit an action that is considered morally wrong. The utilitarian encourages the individual to seek aggregate happiness for themselves and the group, and to ensure that it happens through any way possible. This opens the possibility to using harmful acts, such as murder, cheating and lying to ensure that group happiness is existent in a large amount.…

    • 2422 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Therefore, if progress means making things better by replacing old ways, then those social standards are able to change as well. This makes the idea of cultural relativism implausible according to Racheal because then cultural morals can then be changed. However, he still believes in the teleological theory where the answer to labeling an action as right or wrong is sometimes a nonmoral value.…

    • 1504 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Free In Morality

    • 1218 Words
    • 5 Pages

    By the end of this essay, I`m hoping to show that human beings are responsible for their actions and also moral actions by proving how free-will and determinism works in this concept. As an independent field from philosophy, morality is a system of rules. It is a system of norms or values established to regulate people`s actions and their relations with each other. But first, we must look at how hard determinism and…

    • 1218 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hard Work Research Paper

    • 1749 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Convincing yourself that everything will work out may alleviate stress, however, it takes away your freedom to act upon your circumstances. Likewise living life in a pessimistic way is unhealthy. A little pessimism can be good, but living life expecting the worst of everything cannot be a good way to live. I argue that instead, we should take control of our own destinies. Instead of living pessimistically or optimistically, we should make our own views.…

    • 1749 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    This would make it difficult to decide if an action’s consequence is bad or good because people’s view of bad and good are not congruent with each other. Mill’s argument would work if you do not focus on whether or not the actions are just as well as generalizing concepts so that all people think…

    • 1291 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    10. Why we categorize- it is a natural thing, and it’s easy for our brains but it can be very harmful and can make people miss out on a better quality of life if they avoid people because of how that person perceives the target. Again, neutral attitudes seem to help override the initial urge and/or actual stereotyping. Learning everything is a huge mental task, but being aware is the first…

    • 1578 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The notion of hard determinism reduces human beings to passive objects, while attributing active power to many other objects. This goes against the active power we regard ourselves as having. It also appears to undermine the qualitative power which is crucial to causal operations. The maintenance of internal causal elements within the world causal system are crucial to its operations. At the same time, the notion of free will as something acting without relation to causal factors is problematic.…

    • 1679 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays