Francine Prose Analysis

Improved Essays
Francine Prose is a living author and critic who was born in the 1940’s and has produced multiple works which have been rewarded with grants and honors. Prose wants the reader ask themselves how aware English teachers are about their curriculum regarding literature. It is Prose’s belief that instead of choosing real challenging books, English teachers around the country are choosing books with simpler themes and characters, and preventing deep thought about their meanings, which is stunting the love of books for high school students. Prose believes that books are no longer read deliberately enough (98), she believes books are no longer being written or read by the word, but skimmed over. Teachers sometimes choose masterpieces to assign their children, but simply do not follow it up …show more content…
The characters are simply too black and white, and students have a harder time identifying with characters that do not seem human. Prose wants the reader to be informed of these injustices against literature, and to realize, whatever age they are, that reading is worth another chance; there really are some masterpieces out there, and they don’t have to be high school favorites. The reader could be any age, however, Prose is focusing on a specific group in her essay, English fanatics. She mentions so many books that English fanatics would know, and she is focused on changing English fanatics’ (and teachers’) minds about their curriculum. Prose is frustrated that this ignorance has gone so far. She wants the reader to take matters into their own hands and not just rely on classic novels which are time and time again taught in high schools. Prose is credible because of her reasoning and extensive use of examples, from Of Mice and Men to “Gryphon” (97). She explains every example with a reiteration of her previous thoughts, which further convinces the reader to think like

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Character Identification Protagonist: Francis, a poor young girl in Brooklyn. Neely, her younger brother. Katie her mother, Her dad johnny.…

    • 980 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Her point of view is that the environment the students are put is very irrelevant since they loose interest in the books they are assigned in their high school English classes. this supports the idea that students are not being challenged since the school boards of education are not doing anything to change the readings and as she claims will lead towards a “ downward shift.” In her article she says “ One can see why this memoir might appeal to the lazy or uninspired teacher,” although it might not be necessarily true that all teachers do not teach the material in depth, it seems to be a major part of her argument on how a majority of the teachers do not challenge their students or in other words put them in a competitive environment. As a result Prose concludes that in terms of the educational system “ mediocre high school favorites will continue to rise, unburdened by gravity, to the top of the list.” Similar to Prose’s point of view, author of “ Superman and me” Alexie, claims that students are being limited to their full potential because of the school's…

    • 834 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    To be convinced by this claim the reader needs to know the origin of the short story form and its essence. Then the reader will analyze the nature of “The Truth” in a literary work.…

    • 686 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Thomas C. Foster’s How to Read Literature Like a Professor provides a lively introduction to the subject matter of literature and insight into the mind of an English professor. Being an English professor at the University of Michigan-Flint, Foster has gained valuable experience in reading literature; experience that he shares with the reader in his book. Put simply, this book is a general guideline for what to look for when reading literature. An essential characteristic of Foster’s writing is the use of specific novels as evidence for his argument. In each chapter, Foster makes a different claim.…

    • 1309 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Wanex 5-2 The Downsides of Hate Reading Pamela Paul’s article “Why You Should Read Books You Hate” is an intriguing read that focuses on the importance of reading books that are unappealing to the specific reader. She thoroughly explains that pursuing novels with subjects that do not interest the reader makes them a more skeptical and scrupulous critic. In addition, she details the pleasure that reading brings to all as well as the magnitude of the time commitment that it requires in comparison to other activities that expose people to new content.…

    • 505 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Secondly, O’Connor and Aquinas deny that one can come to know an object by knowing the idea of it, which is a Platonic epistemological belie (67, Gilson 212). She states that fiction writers who are just starting to write “loathe to create” worlds because “[the writers] are possessed not by a story but by the bare bones of some abstract notion” (68). By revealing this problem, O’Connor is addressing fiction writers and telling them it is necessary to not focus on “unfleshed ideas and emotions” because these “bare bones” of language are not the way a reader comes to know and understand a fictitious world (67, 68). O’Connor exemplifies this belief by explaining how people commonly ask what the theme of the story is (73). As a result of inquiring about the theme of a story, O’Connor says people “go off happy and feel it is no longer necessary to read [a story]” (73).…

    • 780 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Laura Turner 10/9/17 AP Lang period 2A Questions for discussion 3. Prose is implying that “the new-model English class graduate” is less likely to question or think about current issues and that they are used to not reading closely and not focusing on the book as a whole. 4. Prose directly blames society for the state of the education system, she also indirectly blames everyone for not doing anything about it. No, I do not feel blame has any effect on the cogency of her article.…

    • 815 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    America, the land known for its freedom and its classical novels. As years have come and gone, bestsellers and classics are being taken away from students in the school systems, the students have no say in the matter. Parents or the school board bring up the matter to the schools, then there are many meetings deciding whether the book should be banned or should stay. Challenging and banning books is a very popular matter now, with many eager to support, and some trying to get rid of the cause. Many parents and students question as to why books can be banned in the first place and what causes them to be taken out of so many schools.…

    • 1974 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The direct use of negative emotional words presents Prose’s stand in a really straightforward way. The readers are able to tell Prose’s stand in the very beginning of the passage, and such a strong expression will invoke the audience’s curiosity, making them want to know why Prose holds such a negative feeling about the required reading in American high schools. Also, the use of words with negative connotations allows Prose to build her central argument and lead her body paragraphs. Since this essay is a critique of the quality of high school reading requirement, talking about its negativity enables Prose to emphasize the necessities to change the standard of choosing the high school reading requirement, helping her naturally lead the following supporting paragraphs in the later part of the passage. Prose does not risk putting off readers who do not share her views because the use of strong emotional words can invoke people’s curiosity no matter they agree with her or not.…

    • 886 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The literary canon is a list of books chosen by scholars that displays the books that have been influential to western culture. The books chosen have been placed under this list because they contain important information that has impacted America. The controversial part of these “canonized” books is that they have been selected by “important” scholars. The system of canonizing a book lacks the diversity that the western hemisphere has, therefore, not all the western cultures are being represented. Representation is key to accuracy within history, in order to capture the essential history of the American literature.…

    • 1696 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    From the very beginning of Francine Prose’s “I Know Why the Caged Bird Can’t Read”, the topic of her argument appears to be one concerned with the failing education system, contributed, in part, by the failure of teachers to effectively teach literature, focusing on the moral values that can be taken from a particular work rather than focusing on the actual literary content, and the lack of literary works that encourage a love of literature and are complex in nature. However, Prose’s arranging of her argument allowed for an ill-conceived notion of what she was really trying to get at. Prose makes an universal assumption that the lack of complexity in assigned literary works is what makes for the decreased enthusiasm for reading and students…

    • 1298 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In “Disliking Books” (an excerpt from the 1993 book, Beyond the Culture Wars: How Teaching the Conflicts Can Revitalize American Education) Gerald Graff tells his story about growing up as a middle-class Jew in Chicago (22). He grew up disliking and fearing literature, history, and other advanced books. His explanation for his disdain towards reading was his fear of being bullied by the other boys in the working-class. Reading at the time was only acceptable for girls.…

    • 1046 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mexico Vs Us Essay

    • 1295 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Although school is considered to be a universal education to children through a certain system, different countries take on their own way of education their young ones. These differences are due to many different reasons such as culture, government, and location but even when they are similar, the school system differs. For example, Mexico and the United States share a border and both have a republic government, but their way of educating contrasts one another. The most prominent cause of the differences in the school system in these two countries is the amount of money available. Mexico lacks the funds that Americans take for granted daily, and Mexico is a poor country that does not have the money to spend on schools like the United States can.…

    • 1295 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    “How Teachers Make Children Hate Reading” is a personal memoir of John Holt’s recollections of being an English teacher. Holt remembers the times when he was the teacher that made children dissect books until their minds no longer held the real meaning of them. Their minds were drilled into finding the ‘correct’ answer and moving on as fast as possible. After multiple arguments with his sister telling him his approach to teaching reading was wrong and hurting the children's love for reading, he slowly started to listen. In his memoir, Holt shows growth of being a dynamic character and his ways of teaching change alongside him.…

    • 1772 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    My Reading Experience

    • 1190 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Just like learning to walk or ride a bike, learning to read is one of life’s milestones. However, unlike walking and biking, reading skills are not suddenly obtained and then static throughout life. After learning to read initially, an individual’s reading skills, interests, and purposes further develop and change throughout their life. Furthermore, the means by which an individual improves their reading capabilities change over time as well. In the same way, I initially improved my reading ability and changed my interests through the help of my parents, then later my teachers, and finally, in spite of a dark period of little improvement, through my own effort.…

    • 1190 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays