Five Common Arguments Against Animal Rights

Great Essays
Imagine someone sitting at home on their couch, watching TV when Sarah McLachlan pops up with a dog in her lap that looks healthy and happy. The commercial starts, the song “Angel” plays in the background, and words start to pour across the screen. “Every day in America thousands of animals suffer from cruelty and neglect… thousands were rescued last year, but for thousands of others help came too late…” through these words, the screen cuts to pictures of animals that have been rescued, animals that have been neglected and abused- by the people who were supposed to love them (Pattern 10a). Animals should be protected under the law, no matter what the circumstance is. Puppy mills need to be shut down, dog fighting needs to be stopped, and animal …show more content…
Some people think that giving animals more rights will disrupt society, because only beings that can comprehend the possible rights can benefit from the rights being given to them. The article Five Common Arguments against Animal Rights and Their Counter-Arguments, states that animals aren’t aware of their situations, and they don’t need rights, it then goes on to say how “strict… laws and regulations [view] animals as lower than humans” and that animals are “incapable of pain, thought, or understanding… the simple failure to be capable of expression, or a lack of cognition regarding complex pain or sadness” is portrayed as an adequate reason to not give animals more rights. Some people believe that “animals have no sense of morality,” or that “only creatures who comprehend rights can benefit from them,” or even that “animals are not sentient: they cannot speak, have no thoughts, feelings, desires, emotions or interests” (Ethical Activism). All of these statements are saying that animals should NOT have rights, because they either can’t comprehend language, because they can’t talk, because they are different, because they don’t understand, because they don’t have feelings or emotions (Pattern 4a). Morality is literally common sense, people have rights, and they know that it is wrong to hurt other people; people are different, does that …show more content…
Temple Grandin of Colorado University explains that “although animals are currently considered property the law grants them rights,” yet many people still abuse their animals, though they know they can be punished under the law for doing so. Don’t let the animals suffer (Pattern 19). Adopt (Pattern 20). Take care of animals. Help them live. Don’t let an animal be abused. Support animals as much as possible. “Animal rights are not about bigger cages or more humane training methods; it's about not using or exploiting animals for food, clothing, or entertainment.” Protect them, love them, cherish them. One day they might be gone forever. There won’t be anything that anyone can do to bring them back, leaving the world without animals (Lin, Important Facts about the Animal Welfare

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    Ought animals have rights, or ought they fall under the category of being morally considerable? I argue that there is no single framework in which to address the moral treatment of animals. A careful blend of these two ideas, moral rights and…

    • 1538 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article “What’s Wrong with Animal Rights”, author Abby Hearne states that the current animal rights movement is “built upon a misconceived premise that rights were created to prevent us from unnecessary suffering.” This mixed with the misunderstanding of animal happiness and what it really means. This paper is written for people who are supporters of the current animal rights movement. The author Abby Hearne’s main argument in this essay is that our definition of animal rights is fundamentally wrong.…

    • 810 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Should animals have the same rights as humans? This is an ongoing debate that could end in one of two ways: either animals are granted rights and the lives of animals change to benefit them while humans lives change in a way that could harm them, or animals are denied rights and life goes on just as it has for years and years. In his essay, Why Animals Deserve Legal Rights, Steven M. Wise, a specialist in animal-rights law, strives to persuade his audience to incline towards legal rights for all animals. However, one can ask the question: how can this justifiably be done?…

    • 1056 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    We as humans should also speak up for those who cannot. The Animal Legal Defense has sponsored a petition that states the following: “Deprived of legal protection, animals are defenseless against exploitation and abuse by humans. Through the animal Bill of Rights, the Animal Legal Defense Fund is working to show congress a groundswell of support for legislation that protects animals and recognizes that like all sentient beings, animals are entitled to basic legal rights in our society.” Society has always grown and changed to become more modernized; this Animal Bill of…

    • 514 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Animal Rights Did you know that some animals on earth are being more and more abused because of animal cruelty? Around 900-2000 animals are abused every year. In 2007 1880 animals were being abused. 64.5% (1212) Involved dogs.…

    • 444 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is an undeniable fact that we as humans share our world and lives with animals and must find a way to coexist. While in most societies humans have made some form of written rule such as a constitution which clearly states the natural rights of each person, a constitution for animals that clearly states what rights they have has not been ratified in the United States. In an attempt to fix this, the Animal Legal Defense Fund has proposed a bill of rights for animals. This bill sets up guidelines and rules on how we must treat animals to ensure a more peaceful future. Unfortunately, this bill is not perfect and has several flaws.…

    • 557 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Animal rights is a topic that has been all over the news lately and has raised many questions which makes it a controversial topic. Many argue that animals should not obtain rights as humans. However, animals must acquire a Bill of Rights since they are treated inhumanly and have similar traits as humans. Accordingly, the Animal Legal Defense Fund (ALDF) claims that animals have the right to earn rights just like any other living creature.…

    • 1058 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Persuasive Animal Essay For centuries man has always had the upper hand over animals but animal activists are now trying to sway the argument to prove that animals should be treated at the same standard as humans. Activists are working hard to show that all animals, from the smallest fish to the largest elephant, can feel pain, emotions, and human connections. After reading the articles I have concluded that an animal bill of rights should be added the the United States Government. I believe that this Bill of rights should provide standards and regulations to how animals are kept and cared for, It should also cover laws of what humans should and should not be allowed to to to animals, for example, slaughterhouses versus bull fighting, and finally the bill of rights should not state nor infer that animals should not be treated with the same standard or be “legally declared a person”(Yong 38).…

    • 702 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Animals are inhumanely treated all over the world and have been mistreated for thousands of years. They have been hunted, abused, and people believe that they are not smart and don’t have emotions. The Animal Bill of Rights is good start for animal rights, however, It will interfere with the way people live their lives too much. People will not be willing to pay more for animal products, give up hunting, cultural rituals having to do with animals, and much more because of The Animal Bill of Rights. Animals have feelings, they feel pain, are aware of themselves, and their surroundings.…

    • 692 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Animal cruelty is a big deal to people all across the world. The meaning of animal cruelty is inflicting pain and causing suffering to any type of animal. Animal cruelty is growing worldwide in today’s society, and the most common identified cruelty’s is scientific research, abandonment, and mistreatment. There are animals all throughout beaten and starved by their heartless owners. These people shouldn’t be allowed to even have a kid let alone a pet.…

    • 825 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Close your eyes and picture yourself as an innocent animal. While being that animal someone comes along an takes you in and feeds, shelter, and comforts you. Then suddenly the person that cared for you strips your fur, or brutally murders you for food, or holds you hostage for tests. These are just a few animal abuse in today's society that needs to be extinguished, therefore animals in our ecosystem deserve rights. Those rights should end the problems with animal abuse, abandonment, and animal experimentation.…

    • 697 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Attention Getter: Each year 10000 dogs die in illegal dog fighting according to Rescue Ink, more than 3 million dogs and cats are euthanised in shelters and more than 15 million animals are used to experiment on. All in all more than 150 billion animals are slaughtered every year. Every time these statistics are shown to someone the simple answer would be that even if they stopped these cruel acts how can their actions affect on the big numbers. (http://www.adaptt.org/killcounter.html) Reason to Listen: Although animal rights might seem a redundant topic, it should be taken more into…

    • 1327 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Rights are given to beings that have consciousness and sentience. Consciousness/sentience is classified by a being’s capability to “experience a life of its own, struggle with life, and flourish” (Donaldson and Kymlicka, Zoopolis, 22). This definition leads animals to have their own set of inviolable rights. Consciousness is often misconstrued as not being present in animals because their consciousness is not human consciousness. As most people seek “human consciousness” when giving rights to living beings instead of more abstract consciousness (Donaldson and Kymlicka, Zoopolis, 30).…

    • 1194 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Thesis Statement Animals deserve rights, and these rights should annihilate the problems with animal abuse, abandonment, and animal experimentation. Purpose Statement The purpose of this research paper is to discuss animal rights and what animals right activist ideology fight for which includes animal abuse, abandonment, experimentation, and laws that prevent inhuman actions towards animals.…

    • 1328 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Opponents’ views range from not wanting animals used for food at all, to those who desire a more humane way of raising and killing the animals. A quick search on the internet would flood ones monitor with images of animals that look malnourished and deformed and stories of animals forced into filthy and crowded spaces only to eventually be led to a cruel form of death. In the United States, supporters are pursuing animal law to ensure that these animals have adequate living spaces, proper nutrition, and are not tortured to death. Yet still, these conditions can be found…

    • 1264 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays