The secular motivations provided ammunition for all. Peter Frankopan argued that …show more content…
However, Peter’s intentions were questioned by Guibert of Nogent; a Benedictine historian in the early 12th century. In his testament he stated that Peter was seen 'going through the cities and towns under a pretence of preaching’ , which suggests that he masked underlying motives through religious reasoning. Guibert was in fact an 'eyewitness to the preaching of the Crusade' which increases the contextual reliability of his claim. However, before 1096 in Jerusalem Jesus Christ appeared to him in the Church of the Sepulchre, and instructed Peter to preach a Crusade. This contests Guiberts suspicion that Peters motives were not religious intrinsically religious as his motivation was chiefly inspired by his apparition of