Fetal Consent Case Study

Superior Essays
Consentimiento
There have been several situations in history including what belongs to whom. There are more laws on possession than most people would be willing to count. Consent should be given as an official count of giving something significant over to another person, whether it be a car, house, or even organ donations. Not only is it illegal to take these things, it is incredibly immoral to do with or without a law. Before laws were implemented, doctors could take from their patients as they pleased. While there are many issues surrounding the use of human cells and tissues in scientific research, the main issue surrounds that of morality and subsequently, ownership and consent.

It is unethical to perform scientific testing on a fetal
…show more content…
For example, Henrietta Lacks was a woman in the 1950s. She was diagnosed with cervical cancer and her doctor removed part of her cells without her knowing. When her family had found out what was going on, they were furious. They had no idea what was going on, and they were flat out confused on the idea of the whole situation. Because of their confusion and uncertainty, Henrietta’s family “refused to talk to anyone.” (Skloot, 2011) Their family isolated themselves for years after Lacks passed away. If her doctor had asked for permission just one time, their lives’ would have played out so much differently. Instead, they had to live without closure. The only thing the Lacks family really wanted was an answer to their questions. They lost a family member and this man was hiding crucial facts about her from them. That family deserved the right to know what was going on with their loved one. Deborah, Henrietta’s sister, had one command when she spoke with Skloot, and that was to, “Find out what happened to [her] mother and [her] sister.” (Skloot, 2011) If Dr. Gey had only sat down and talked to Henrietta about the procedure they performed, he would not have had to avoid any legal issues or need to cover up and lie about the identity of Henrietta. If he had said something, the Lacks family would have made some sort of revenue …show more content…
A doctor should be connected to their patients. If a patient knows they can trust their doctor, they will be more likely to give a doctor permission to perform practices on them. “We’re teaching the humanities to our residents, and it’s making them better doctors,” said Dr. Richard Panush. (Chen, 2008) Doctors like Dr. Panush are pushing to have doctors work more in psychology. Doing so will allow them to learn their patients more, and therefore connect better with them. On the other hand, doctors like Dr. George Gey performed work behind his patients’ backs. His relationship with his patients was not very great whatsoever. This caused so many problems with his credibility, his respect from others, and he received negative publicity for this. These two contrasting ideas prove that the relationship of a doctor and his patient is crucial in the outcome of scientific testing on human tissue. The research itself behind human tissues has actually made leaps and bounds in the medical field. Because of collection from a human tissue, a doctor was able to create vaccines for both HPV and Polio. (Nicollette B, 2016) Human tissue has revealed so much to us in the recent past. Because of this kind of research, cures have been found for diseases that previously were

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Embryonic Stem Cells

    • 1249 Words
    • 5 Pages

    When using stem cells, it advances medical research and medicines in various reasons. They also have the ability to treat very serious diseases and even cure cancer. Stem cells can advance in medications. They are able to test for new drugs and treat many illnesses. Arguments Against Using Stem Cells in Biomedical Research and Medicine There are a lot of arguments facing the use of stem cells.…

    • 1249 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Another includes, the Science of Mental Illness developing more guaranteed drugs and tests to treat patients. Those victories have made major impacts in patients’ lives. The new tests and treatments has helped both psychologists and psychiatrists make miserable people less miserable. These were a few examples of their achievements, but there were also three costs of the Disease Model. These areas also became victimologists and pathologizers toward…

    • 750 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    One could say, she is in her own little bubble of sorrow. This alienation from the world outside her door couldn’t be more obvious than when Miss Emily 's necrophilia is revealed. For example, the very first line of the story reads, “When Emily Grierson died, our whole town went to her funeral… (998).” Throughout her whole life, Emily was sheltered from the rest of the town by her father. She was so kept away from society and normalcy that it hindered her growth. Her father never allowed her to properly court any young man due to the fact that, “None of the young men were quite good enough for Miss Emily and such (1000).” When the only human relationship she has left dies, it’s no wonder she goes mentally insane.…

    • 1531 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Why Mothers Kill Analysis

    • 1149 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Vanessa avoided the health care system the first time because she hit her child and broke her arm. Then resetting it herself, she was reported to Child Protection Services and her baby was taken away. Regaining custody two years later her child died from an infection caused by a burn, in which Vanessa refused to take her to the doctor because she was scared to lose her daughter again (114). Agencies and organizations failed to protect these children, many of the women were investigated, but then failed to see the true risk…

    • 1149 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This is the story of how a woman who had postpartum depression and how her husband John didn’t understand what the problem was and how it affected her. In the result of him trying to cure his wife, John locked her in a room with bars on the windows expecting her to do nothing all day. Overall, I believe this because she has been falsely diagnosed, had postpartum depression, and because of the sexism of the time no one would listen to…

    • 748 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Although, gene therapy is a great treatment option for number of diseases like cancer, blindness and many genetic disabilities, this treatment somehow considered risky and it is under study to make sure it will be safe and effective. Many people view the gene therapy technique as a great weapon to fight against diseases; others are worried about what if gene therapy turns the human species into technology products. Furthermore, gene therapy is not widely used in all clinical institutions; doctors consider using it in a situation where it might be possible to treat certain and wide range of genetic disorders (Ruggles par. 5). There are many ethical issues and questions rise on this topic, keeping that in mind, it should be seriously and carefully re-evaluated, just to change the world’s view about human gene therapy technique.…

    • 1351 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A biomedical engineer’s job is to seek solutions for illnesses and to advance the medical field. To help find these solutions biomedical engineers are inventing a way to create artificial organs to make more accurate drugs without side effects. As a result, much controversy has resulted from biomedical research and how biomedical engineers obtain their specimen. The results of this research have yet to be determined, but many researchers believe the benefits will be worth the risks and will put a halt to the criticism. As a biomedical engineer, ethics is an issue that is constantly faced because of controversial research; therefore, supporters and opposers are seeking a solution to unethical research.…

    • 1012 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    It is quite possible that the key to the future of human life is ourselves. The advancements in cloning technology have progressed to the point that in the near future we may see the possibility of cloning human beings. The most medically beneficial idea in cloning humans, or more likely parts of humans, is that it completely simplifies the way we treat patients. The two categories of cloning are therapeutic and reproductive. Therapeutic cloning involves treating injured body parts by regrowing stem cells in the afflicted area.…

    • 1804 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The stem cells or embryonic cells “can be harvested for treatment use from the cellular blastocyst. The harvesting or “stealing” of these cells results in the end of life for the “innocent human beings.”’(Siegel, Andrew). When it comes to stem cell use and where they are acquired from is a big debate between many doctors, scientists and citizens. The real question is from who, what, why, and legal and many people believe that it should be legal due to a belief that conception is the creation of a life and using stem cells from an aborted fetus ruins that. ESCR (embryonic stem cell research) is argued to be a motive that is unfair as well as the debate on whether it should be declared illegal due to the possible death, pain and unfair treatment to all involved ("Ten Problems with Embryonic Stem Cell Research.").…

    • 1258 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Many people think it might be neat if they could witness cloning. However there are more negatives than positives when doing this action. Some of those negative reasons are medical related, the cost, the technology, and the religious points. But the positives include fertility problems. So in those defenses the debate over cloning in the U.S. remains intense because it is against human nature.…

    • 1244 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays