Moral Reasoning Case Study

Improved Essays
There is a place for emotion within moral reasoning, in fact emotions are essential in the process of gaining moral understanding. Morality consists of principles that tell individuals how they ought to treat one another regarding what is considered right and wrong. To truly understand one another, we must understand each other’s emotions. Feelings are most commonly associated with women since men make most rational decisions and ideas, and as a result, these decisions are flawed to an extent. To prevent this, women should be more involved in the philosophical reasoning process.
In Feminist Transformations of Moral Theory, Virginia states that emotions are essential in the process of gaining moral understanding. Held argues that the male bias
…show more content…
Emotions can help people make decisions based on their particular situation and self-interest. The purpose of emotion is to facilitate awareness and action. If individuals choose to disregard feelings when making crucial decisions it can lead others to feel dissatisfied because the decision is not necessarily made in their best interest. John Stuart Mill believes that one should make decisions based on how they promote happiness since it is considered immoral to encourage the reverse. Even though Mill says that these decisions should be rational, they still take into mind how others feel. Kant says that all moral problems can be handled by applying an impartial, pure, rational principle to a particular case. Individuals can gain moral understanding by instructing people on how to pursue particular objectives most rationally. Immanuel Kant created the categorical imperative which is based upon the idea that morality is derived from rationality and all moral judgements are logically supported. Kant argues that this is the standard of rationality, and it is how we can gain moral understanding. In using the categorical imperative, one can act as reason recommends and resist yielding to emotional inclinations and desires in conflict with our rational …show more content…
Sigmund Freud says that girls are much slower than boys to develop a sense of themselves as autonomous moral agents personally responsible for the consequences of their actions or inactions. He attributed this supposed moral inferiority to girls’ psychosexual development. Feminists argue that Freud’s theory is sexist and it refuses to recognize that women’s sexualities are independent of men. This theory and others like it have concluded that women are not as civilized as men. This is because it is believed that to be civilized, decisions have to be made with logic rather than intuition. Since women are known to decide using their hearts rather than their heads, they are considered less civilized than men. Lawrence Kohlberg held the belief that moral reasoning is the basis for ethical behaviour and came up with six identifiable developmental stages to evaluate how morally people behave. It is believed to be that men are able to reach the sixth stage, whereas women stop developing at three. This is because women tend to focus on maintaining relationships and care more about the well-being of others, whereas men focus on the logistics of a situation and are usually less concerned with who it will

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    These examples of underlying sexism and misogynistic ways of thinking can be traced back to the morals established by Puritan religion. Men were thought to be the head of household, with no exceptions, and a challenge to a male was seen as a challenge to God’s authority. As women were acquiring more independence, this was seen as a challenge to male power. In response, women who acted outside of their gender roles were seen as threats to the…

    • 1032 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    I feel making the morally correct decision should in most cases out weigh what is politically and legally correct. In the Kosovo intervention the United States and NATO went behind the UN in an attempt to do what they felt was morally just. Although, they justify using force is acceptable in order to fight for human rights. The real question... In an time of emerging moral order, should we put legality in the distance and focus on doing the right thing instead of what is politically correct?…

    • 113 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As East High graduation approaches, our Newsletter would like to recognize an admirable student, who has been known to be involved with the Athletic Department, and fine arts, Troy Bolton. He is known to be East High’s basketball captain, and taken the stage. Unfortunately, Mr. Bolton has passed away from a heart-attack at the age of eighty-eight. For this segment, we will discuss the road map of Bolton’s success of his life using Kohlberg’s three levels and six stages of moral reasoning.…

    • 519 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Kant proposes there are laws dictating two types of behavior, involuntary behavior (biological needs, impulse, etc.,) and voluntary behavior (morals and free will) (Kant 4:388). He distinguishes irrational beings as those acting from impulse from rational beings as those who can deliberate and act from free will or reason. Kant claims the major difference between irrational beings and rational beings is in the ability for their actions to be universalized; it is sustainable and maintains order for all beings to act from reason at all times but it is not sustainable for all beings to act from impulse or inclination because these are subjective values and often lead to selfish behavior (Kant 4:402). For Kant, this is the categorical imperative that guides morality; he puts forth the claim that all rational beings should behave in a way that could be written into law and order would be maintained (Kant 4:416). Additionally, the categorical imperative is “limited by no condition and, as absolutely although practically necessary, can be called quite strictly a command” (Kant 4:417)…

    • 862 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Following that logic, men were seen as rational, reasonable human beings, and women were seen as passionate. In other words, men were not concerned with passion or emotion, and women did not operate with reason and logic. Held observes the use of the word “human” and how it has repeatedly been categorized as a gendered-word; “‘Man’ has been associated with the human, ‘woman’ with the natural” (323). Thus, with the suggestion that men were reasonable and women were without reason, followed by the theory that reason is one of the defining characteristics of being human, there is an indication that women were less than human. The split that exists between reason and emotion is parallel to the split between man and woman – men can assert their dominance in the public realm, and can tame the unruliness that is a woman’s emotions with that assertion of dominance, supposed assumed superiority, and…

    • 1309 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In the last Chapter, Rachels discusses the creation of a "Satisfactory Moral Theory”, in this paper I will discuss my own creation of the Satisfactory Moral Theory. The moral theories are supposed to help us decide what are the right and wrong actions, but, not all the moral theories are perfect. We may feel that a certain conclusion to a problem is fair or unfair, but what theory do we use to make judgments?. I will start with the cultural relativism theory, to understand different cultures, There is a need to know that one community’s beliefs and practices are not usually the same as the other community. In fact, cultural relativism seems the most applicable approach to be taken on for communications purposes.…

    • 1181 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    They do not always end up being positively placed and in their initial state are often immature. The emotions should be cultivated through the development of though and character, so that they are reasonable and they are able to manifest the noblest types of sentiments. So that emotions transcend destructive egoistic and hedonistic preferences, establish a care for the greater people (individually and collectively), and a standard is set in favor of higher value. Developed sentiments can aid in establishing appreciation for values. This appreciation of values, which cultivated emotions an aid in, is a key portion in the shift from ethical understanding to ethical…

    • 1107 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Emotions and feeling are critical components to a moral system. To come to that conclusion, one needs to know what motivates a person initiate any action. Emotions are the driving force for humans for any and all actions. A majority of the time, people do something to obtain some sense of satisfaction and/or desire for an outcome. Although, fear is probably the most influential human emotion that people deal with daily.…

    • 520 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Throughout Chapter 16, various ideologies are highlighted upon through the writings of progressive feminists interested in debunking the superior method of acquiring knowledge and utilizing it to the best of our abilities. Due to the impact of ethics on society, feminist perspectives find their attention most frequently attuned to the study of “values and virtues,” most often appearing nontraditional yet empathic (376). For this reason, the origins of several feminist themes lie in the “ethics of care,” a version of moral principles that emphasize the importance of including the “empathy, compassion, love, sympathy, and fidelity” one feels for their fellow people(377). Unlike Kant, which strictly declares one’s duty to be above all else, the “ethics of care” are not indifferent to the emotions involved when generating a solution to an issue.…

    • 516 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Kant states that it is the Categorical Imperative ( an unqualified moral obligation that applies to all rational beings ) what helps reason provide the standard. However, Kant’s moral theory is defined as deontological where actions are determined by rules of behavior. According to Kant, we experience reason as an obligation so we act in distinct ways or imperatives which can be found in two different ways: Categorical imperative and Hypothetical Imperative. Hypothetical Imperative is defined as; the performance of an action for the sake of the desired end. I.e if you want to lose weight, you must eat healthily, or if you want to pass the class, you must turn in your work.…

    • 746 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Moral absolutism is an ethical theory that views moral rules hold without exception. What is right is right and what is wrong is wrong, there are no such things that fall in between. For instance, rape is absolutely wrong. “Even if a woman wears a very short, tight skirt, she should not be raped. Even if the rapist was abused as a child.…

    • 1219 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Furthermore, Scout at the end of the book got the to postconventional moral reasoning stage five legal principle because in the moment in where she understood the situation that Boo Radley would be put in if everyone knew what had truly happened with the dead of Bob. She understood that by putting Boo in the public eye would be the death of him. Moreover that gives the ability to understand that her understanding of the situation was of a higher moral reasoning level. At the same time she had been through an attack that had put her life in danger; she wasn't truly aware of what had happened of who had helped her. With is in mind, the legal principle stage was identified to be the second before getting to universal moral principles which is…

    • 459 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    1. The belief of how people make meaning of their world are very different between Kohlberg and Gilligan (as cited in Patton et al., 2016). One difference between to two theorist is a concept of justice versus the concept of care. Kohlberg’s theory of Moral Development was based on a study conducted on 72 upper and middle class males, which does not give complete picture of the process of moral development of human beings because it only focuses on one sex. Gilligan challenged Kohlberg’s model by constructing a separate moral development theory for women.…

    • 1701 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    1. Based on the combination of response in which stage of moral development would Kohlberg most likely place these students? Kohlberg would most likely place these high school students at the convention level in the social authority stage because this stage goes from childhood to adolescence. These high school students are at the point where they are complying with rules or laws and social norms. From the reading, one teacher states that teacher needs to have firm policies and be on board to enforce the rules of the school, so the students don’t have behaviors issue at school.…

    • 732 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Emotion And Reason Essay

    • 1455 Words
    • 6 Pages

    As emotion and reason cooperate? Although the reason and emotions can be perceived as absolutely opposite human characteristics, they are actually very closely related. These two features affect each other, and somehow help shape each other. The reason is often associated with the brain, while the emotions are connected more with the heart.…

    • 1455 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays