The Themes Of Feminism In Meet Me In St. Louis By Vincente Minnelli

Superior Essays
“A film is made up of a hundred or more hidden things,” Vincente Minnelli once said in an interview. The quote seems to sum up Minnelli’s layered film making style. In this essay I will be exploring the themes of feminism, one of the hundred or more hidden things in Minnelli’s work. The essay will move through the life of Minnelli, analysing films from both the beginning and end of his career in the context of the time in which they were made.
Vincente Minnelli was born Lester Anthony Minnelli in Chicago on February 28 of 1903 into a theatrical family. His father and mother were both performers who travelled and owned half of the Minnelli Brothers’ Dramatic and Tent Theatre. Minnelli first worked as a child performer with his mother, then
…show more content…
Louis, Minnelli was granted creative freedom to explore more unique and artistic films. One such film was The Pirate starring Gene Kelly and Minnelli’s wife, Judy Garland. While The Pirate endured tumultuous filming, negative critical reviews and underwhelming box office, it still stands as one of Minnelli’s most intriguing pieces of work. While he had been less outright with his feminist perspective in Meet Me in St. Louis, he enjoyed his newly allotted creative freedom to explore the idea in more depth and with a greater sense of satire toward patriarchal …show more content…
From the onset of the film Manuela appears on the balcony, fenced in by the metal lattice work, echoed in shadow behind her. This continues whenever the character is trapped within the expectations of society to settle down and marry. Then, when she is able to escape and be her own person the prison like line work disappears, being replaced with open skies or loose hanging swaths of fabric. Probably the most obvious shift from line work is when she first meets the showman at the seafront. There are no harsh lines at all, just a wide open

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    La Habanera Women Analysis

    • 1006 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Depictions of Traditional Women in Fascism Unlike many fascism films barely illustrate about the female (Rentschler 15), both the Italian historical film 1860 directed by Alessandro and the German melodramatic feature film La Habanera directed by Detlev Sierck are united by their portraits of traditional women like Carmeniddu’s wife, Gesuzza in 1860, and Astrée in La Habanera. These two films depict the women’s images in two forms. First, both 1860 and La Habanera directly portray the women as the family keepers. Second, both the Italian film and the German film use the set designs to reflect the females’ feelings.…

    • 1006 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Laura Esquivel’s film adaptation of Like Water for Chocolate and Kate Chopin’s stories, A Pair of Silk Stockings and The Storm, share a similar theme. They all focus on the complexity of women’s struggles to discover their freedom and individuality against social norms and traditions. At first they all place their desires aside because they feel a sense of duty whether they are forced or self imposed. Eventually, each woman takes a step to fulfill their desires if only for one brief time. In the film Like Water for Chocolate Tita is struggling with the desire to be with her true love and find her independence and individuality.…

    • 1110 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In the article “The Princess Paradox,” Poniewozik discusses Hollywood movies produced for the public that convey an idealistic culture. Poniewozik claims that the princess culture is not despicable for young girls to know or experience and promotes feministic ideas by introducing certain movies. Poniewozik introduces that in 2001, many cinderella stories were produced bringing in a gross profit of 108 million dollars. Since then, Hollywood has decided to keep producing these cinderella stories and fairytales to continue bringing in this profit. “Call it nature or nurture, harmless fantasy or insidious indoctrination, but Hollywood is discovering that it still pays not to fight the royal urge” (323).…

    • 277 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Instead, the film is simple and tugs at the viewer’s heart strings. Riefenstahl’s purpose is not just to tell this fairy tale story about natural beauty and the tragic loss of it. Instead, her film grazes the surface of National Socialism. Riefenstahl’s film begins with two visitors being greeted by…

    • 1374 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Before and after 1949, the gap between the possibilities and limits of Chinese women’s lives was large, where the limits on women far surpassed the possibilities for a prolonged amount of time. Societal views were placed upon women, creating a system in which women must conform to a specific type of person or they would be shunned upon by those around them. This system was what determined the future of a woman in China. In the following stories, “Sealed Off”, by Ailing Zhang, “A Woman Like Me”, by Xi Xi, and “Fin de Siecle Splendor” by Zhu Tianwen, we explore the status of women during these periods of times.…

    • 1295 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Although she probably never considered herself a feminist (she was very conservative politically and socially), her life and work nevertheless provided a valuable role model for women.” (Judith S. Baughman, 1998) Her field of acting, directing, even writing and producing changed because of her first impact showing not only what women can do, she also was one of the first people to do all of it to start with. All of these attributes made her the most elusive star in early cinema in the…

    • 987 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Susan McClary believed, that as film and media continue the discourse on gender identities today, early-modern opera was a pioneer in the construction of gender identities to the public sphere. The construction of gender became necessary when presented portrayals of the world had to differentiate between male or female characters, as one sex could play the other. These constructions were shaped by the time and place in which the work was presented. The issue on how to represent women was controversial during Monteverdi’s time as perspectives on the female rhetoric were divided. McClary analyses Monteverdi’s L'Orfeo and believes that men had a more provocative stage presence while women had to have an innocent portrayal to remain attractive…

    • 1077 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In “All About Eve” Margo ultimately triumphs over Eve. To what extent do you agree? Joseph Mankiewicz’s melodrama “All about eve”, in the context of the 1950’s provides the audience with an insight into the pretentious and ruthless world of the theatre. Margo Channing and her newly appointed “junior” competitor Eve are viewed as too ambitious by the 1950’s audience, who encouraged women to be stereotypical wives rather than independent career women.…

    • 1030 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In feminist ideologies, the male gaze is the act of presenting women as objects of pleasure, from the perspective of heterosexual males. The male gaze is internationally prevalent throughout the history of art and film. The gender power asymmetry that dominated the nineteenth-century was a commanding force in how artists catered to the male viewer. This only further encouraged the pre-existing patriarchal ideologies and discourses. A Roman Slave Market by Jean-Leon Gerome will be formally analyzed in order to expound upon the presence of male dominated perspectives of women in art.…

    • 951 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Borrowing the genre of melodrama, Almodóvar’s award-winning film, All About My Mother (1999), features transgender and post-queer study of sexuality. Apart from presenting two pre-op transgenders, the film renders a variety of “abnormal” intimate relationships, including the protagonist, Manuela’s family without a father, Huma’s ultimately failed lesbian relationship with Nina, and the family formed at the end of the film, constituted by Manuela, Rosa’s baby, and queer girlfriends. These unusual forms of intimacy disturb the hereto-sexist institutions, e.g. marriage and family. Portraying gender, sexuality, and identity as unfixed, the film mocks the conventional perception by interweaving the theatrical performance with the real life: On the one hand, the fixity and stereotype of femininity and masculinity are fostered by cinematic representations, exemplified by Hollywood productions; On the other hand, the reference to…

    • 806 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The article, ‘Film Bodies: Gender, Genre & Excess’1 by Linda Williams explores whether the forms of sex, violence and emotion found in the genres of pornography, horror, and melodrama (specifically the woman’s weepie) respectively, are as gratuitous as my film scholars and critics believe them to be. Setting out to disprove this idea, Williams’ investigates and compares the form, function, and system of the three genres. Ultimately, William’s central claims reveal the value in the supposed excess of these three genres that benefit a spectator in a variety of ways. Seeking to argue her idea, Williams’ firstly uncovers why elements of these genres are regularly deemed as excessive. This is presented with the contrast of Classic Hollywood and…

    • 1465 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Rose Dawson demonstrates qualities of the liberated women of the 1910’s, taking place during women suffrage, as innovative women. Thus, the popular Oscar award winning…

    • 1244 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The moral philosophy of feminism is a big part of today's world socially. Women feel that they are not treated the same as men on a social level considering that men do not receive the same consequences that women do when they do not accept their traditional gender role. In “Feminist Criticism” an article by Lois Tyson from 2006, Tyson talks about what traditional gender roles are in today's society. She compares the ways in which men and women are seen in society and how women can be seen as “bad girls” meaning they don't accept their gender role. The traditional roles are seen as girls are emotional and weak while men are strong and rational.…

    • 1889 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mona Lisa Smile: Joan Brandwyn Character Analysis “So the choice is yours, ladies. You can conform to what other people expect, or, you can…” “I know. Be ourselves.”…

    • 1167 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This writing considers the question of Yoko Ono’s “Cut Piece,” which is one of the most important works of that artist’s career and of its period. The essay specifically investigates the critical question of what one can learn from “Cut Piece” about the role of women in society at large. It seeks in investigating this question to uncover trends over time, seeing how the role of women has changed over time and how the role of women has been depicted in art. There will be three primary sections to the body of this work that will help to provide a clear picture of the overall meaning of this piece of art in conjunction with feminism and the role of women (Johnson). First, there will be an investigation of the piece itself to ensure a proper understanding of what is actually being studied.…

    • 1043 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays