Vocational Education Pros And Cons

Improved Essays
When federal funding for the initiative expired in 2001 despite the overwhelmingly positive effects (“School to Work”), some states passively allowed the School-to-Work momentum to slow while other states took initiative to continue investing in vocational education. South Carolina, for example, began an initiative called Apprenticeship Carolina that gave one million dollars to the state’s technical college and offered a one thousand dollar subsidy per apprentice per year to businesses willing to start apprenticeship programs. The state has now doubled the number of apprentices and expanded apprenticeships to even more occupations, such as advanced manufacturing, health care, and informational technology. One of the best outcomes has been the …show more content…
After World War II, international organizations such as UNESCO (United Nations Educational, Scientific, and Cultural Organization) and the International Labor Organization began urging nations around the world to create VET programs (Agrawal 16). Nations use different titles to refer to vocational education. For example, America’s vocational education system is actually called Career and Technical Education (CTE). For sake of clarity, I will use the term VET to refer to all vocational education programs, as this is the common usage in Europe (Agrawal 15). There are three basic models for vocational education: the dual model, the schooling model, and the mixed model. The dual model, most commonly represented by Germany, allows students to graduate earlier and enroll in apprenticeships while continuing education separate from the job. The schooling model, which is the sporadically integrated model for North America, provides vocational education in schools up until age eighteen. Some countries that use the schooling model have separate vocational schools, such as France, whereas others combined academic and vocational education in one institution. Lastly, the mixed model provides vocational education away from school in the non-formal sector (Winch 125). The mixed model has also been referred …show more content…
Singapore, China, and the region of South Asia provide vivid examples along the continuum. Singapore’s VET system has become “world-class” since Singapore has the third-highest Gross Domestic Product per capita and the world’s 40th largest economy with only five million people on the island. In 2010, Singapore had the third-highest production growth rate in the world at twenty-five percent. (Tucker 3). CEO of National Center on Education and Economy Marc Tucker describes the history of Singapore’s VET system and the secrets of its success. He begins by highlighting their determination to implement the best practices by studying the best strategies and policies in other countries and adopting them. He also notes that the stable government that responds to the needs of the people laid an important foundation. Singapore wisely invested in VET in cycles, aligning the goals of VET with the economy each step of the way (40). Fostered collaboration between businesses and the VET system was also of strategic importance. The realization that a VET system is only as strong as the compulsory education beneath it led to excellent classrooms for young children (41). Finally, one of the most interesting successes Tucker notes is that Singapore made large investments in order to “rebrand” VET in the eyes of the public as a respected option to

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    A man who obtained a B.A. degree in history from Harvard and a Ph.D. in political science from Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Charles Murray wrote an opinion piece with the title “What's Wrong With Vocational School,” published in The Wall Street Journal. Murray argues that not every high school graduates should go to a four year college and waste their time. Murry starts with giving his opinion, citing convincing facts and statistics, and employing very few emotional appeals; however, at the end of the piece, his attempts to appeal to logic ultimately weakens his argument. Charles Murray is an American libertarian, political scientist, sociologist, author, and columnist.…

    • 1005 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Charles Murray’s What’s Wrong with Vocational School he claims that only a certain percentage of high school graduates are going to college and will pass. Murray is trying to appeal to the students with high IQ’s and tell them that going to vocational school might be more educational and the students will learn more while getting jobs that pay more sometimes six figures. Murray also argues that sometimes going into the work force after high school is better than going to college because a certification can always be overlooked on certain jobs rather than experience is looked at on every job interview. Murray uses ethos, logos and pathos along with several other rhetorical devices to explain why college is not always the best choice.…

    • 1183 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Closing of the Bethlehem Steel The early 1980’s was a hard time for the working class of the city of Allentown. The closing of the Bethlehem Steel and other factories left a variety of individuals jobless and depressed. Residents knew that they had to leave the town, but they were still holding on to the glory that their parents were able to achieve there. The singer Billy Joel, in his song “Allentown” describes the struggle of the high unemployment rate, useless diplomas in the competitive job market, and the closing of the town’s main source of income making residents want to leave the town they grew up in.…

    • 573 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    My personal philosophy on Career and Technical Education (CTE), comes from my life’s professional experience of working in Emergency Medicine and working with CTE programs. I believe that CTE prepares secondary and postsecondary students of all diverse backgrounds to obtain gainful employment and creates an ultimate experience of knowledge and development. I have had the opportunity to work in a CTE field of healthcare for my adult life. I believe there is no better educational system to have real measurable growth for many students than CTE. Many of the students and graduates I have had the opportunity to work with would have never had the chance for personal and financial growth if it were not for a CTE programs.…

    • 478 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    No Kid Deserted Act

    • 1612 Words
    • 7 Pages

    No Kid Deserted Act This paper will concentrate on the no kid deserted Act approaches and methods. To begin with let me disclose to you what is (NCLB) The No Tyke Deserted Act, which passed Congress with overpowering bipartisan support. In 2001 and was marked into law by President George W. Bramble on Jan. 8, 2002, is the name for the latest overhaul to the Rudimentary and Auxiliary Training Demonstration of 1965. The NCLB law which became out of worry that the American instruction framework was no more extended global focused altogether expanded the government part in considering schools in charge of the scholastic advance of all understudies.…

    • 1612 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Vocational programs, the only classes that truly grant students with the freedom to learn on their own. Not only are they valued for their education, but also their ability to teach hands-on experience. In a world as complex as ours nothing is more important than that of understanding and mastering a skill. The skills taught by these classes are irreplaceable yet schools are blocking them from our common curriculum. Imagine a child, a child who not only succeeds in vocational programs but thrives.…

    • 1128 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There are many people who believe that college isn’t for everyone and there are many people who believe that it is. Both sides usually have valid arguments, and typically, they both stick to their belief and assume that they’re right. After reading two essays, one called “What’s Wrong with Vocational School?” by Charles Murray, and another called “On ‘Real Education’” by Robert T. Perry, I came to the conclusion that they both agree on the same thing. They both believe that no, a four-year college isn’t for everyone, but people still need some sort of education after high school, whether it’s vocational school, or some type of certificate program.…

    • 1179 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The essay is aimed at outlining and explaining the reasons why vocational schools is just as important as college and why it should be recommended as an option to the youths in the United States of America. The main audience that Murray targets in the article consists of the parents, guardians and the…

    • 1177 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For Taiwan’s healthcare system, they took a bunch of good ideas from different countries around the world and made their own. They gathered many different experts from many different places to go over things like how to avoid making the same mistakes other countries did. The Taiwanese have smart cards that hold all of their medical information and their bills are paid automatically. However, they are not paying enough to keep their healthcare system…

    • 941 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Leaving High school isn’t the same for everyone. Some leave knowing what they want to do at the end, while others have no clue. Charles Murray expresses his disagreement that too many kids are going to four-year colleges. In his essay, “What’s wrong with Vocational School?” Murray States that Vocational schools should be more of an option to people rather than having everyone go to a four-year college.…

    • 1402 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Based on the issues raised by the books and research done this semester, college life is changing to career focused training. Between the cost of college and the need for career and job ready employees, college is changing into a vocational and job training centers. Providing students with career pathways. Students that need to work can enter the work force at a livable wage by completing a certificate program that compliments the completion of a two-year degree on the same subject matter. Many pathway programs have direct admissions avenues to four-year school to continue educational requirement for students who want to advance their education and career opportunities.…

    • 455 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The role of education in the development of all nations around the globe is undeniably critical; this underlines the need for every government to establish a suitable schooling system for their citizens, which obviously bears little resemblance to that of any other country. This essay will point out the likeness and difference between the education systems of Vietnam and the United States in two aspects: education ladder and tertiary education. Firstly, in terms of the education ladder, the two systems are similar only in that children aged 3 to 5 receive pre-school education before attending elementary school for six years in the US and primary school for five years in Vietnam. After two years of middle school, United States’ students spend…

    • 385 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In today’s society, a college degree is more often encouraged than not for students soon to graduate from high school or older adults looking to further themselves in the work force. Employers are even more likely to hire an applicant if they have a degree in the field. Unfortunately, as swiftly as the demand for college degrees increases so does the cost for a college education. A growing number of students have to turn away from furthering their education because the cost is much too steep. Reducing college tuition fees and expenses will encourage more students to pursue higher education, making them more qualified for the job market and will, in turn, improve the US economy.…

    • 1043 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The more an individual has to compensate to attend a school, then the lower the net benefit will be of attending. The Hamilton Project calculates a four-year degree to cost approximately $54,000. In addition, other recent studies Consumer Financial Protection Bureau has exemplified that repaying college tuition can last up to ten years or more. “After attempting to account for in-state vs. out-of-state tuition, financial aid, graduation rates, years taken to graduate, wage inflation, and selection, nearly to hundred schools on the 2012 list have negative ROIs” (Owen and Sawhill 214). With the rising cost of tuition and indefinite job market, individual’s should consider whether obtaining a bachelor’s degree is essential in today’s…

    • 1115 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    These schools are schooling systems that are specifically designed for one occupation. They’re built with curriculums that solely meant to teach and train students the skills and basic knowledge for a specific job. As a society we have begun to focus on general academic instruction rather than the importance of workforce education. Grades have become dominant to life skills.…

    • 832 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays