R Alexander Pyron Save Endangered Species Analysis

Improved Essays
3. In class we read and critically evaluated an opinion article by R. Alexander Pyron in the Washington Post entitled “We don’t need to save endangered species. Extinction is part of evolution.” After summarizing our critique of the article (and this the article) how might Kolbert respond to Pyron? In this second part of your response please especially draw on Kolbert’s chapter 12 and 13. R. Alexander Pyron presents an article to the public in which he attempts to undermine the occurrence of extinction. What is important to understand from the article is that Pyron does not simply argue extinction occurs, but that even when it is human caused, there is no need to feel any guilt. What Pyron fails to comprehend is that when he says, “This is how evolution proceeds: through extinction. The inevitability of death is the only constant in life… as many as 50 billion, have already gone …show more content…
She does not see the actual species though, but sees their DNA in a frozen vial. Here she thinks to herself “Does it have to end this way?” and contemplates human affect over species. Both the article and our reading mentions Neanderthals and how we as homo sapiens killed them off and similarly to “dodo birds” or “saber toothed tigers” they go unmissed. Pyron attempts to relate this to the extinction of species in modern day and what is sad is that an average American citizen may see this article and believe it without thinking much about the reality of what he is saying. Pyron believes that humans have the right to live our life in anyway necessary and that is species of animals but die in the process it is all just part of the circle of life. Kolbert focuses on the Neanderthals and contemplates the relations of them with current humans and how if we did not come about then they, along with horses and wooly rhinos would still be present on

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Evaluation Argument As humans are we driving ourselves into a sixth extinction? According to Elizabeth Kolbert, writer of The Sixth Extinction, we as humans are so careless that we are literally driving ourselves into a nonexistence. The book starts off with stories of how different species has become extinct or are currently endangered. The book has a lot of facts and they all seem to support the theory that humans are making a mess of things.…

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    While the reading passage enumerates the three types of damage often cited by the critics of the "Let It Burn Policy," the professor in the lecture effectively refutes the validity of each of these arguments by redirecting attention to the long term benefits that resulted from the recovery process. The first serious damage cited by the critics is the loss of vegetation. There was significant loss of trees and other vegetation in the park as some one-third of Yellowstone national park was engulfed by the fire. It would have been understandably shocking for people to witness the charred remains of trees and ashes left on the landscape. The professor, however, points out that vegetation did, indeed, return to the area, and more significantly, new forms of botanical…

    • 533 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This week, the reading selections were quite interesting. We have these two authors, Taylor and Epstein, who truly approach the environmental topic in separate ways. On one hand, we have Paul Taylor defending our environment all the way in the article “The Ethics of Respect for Nature”. In this article, Taylor insists that we switch our current perspectives, regarding the environment, to ones that further zoom in on the sake of nature. In fact, Taylor states that “once we reject the claim that humans are superior either in merit or in worth to other living things, we are ready to adopt the attitude of respect” (330).…

    • 689 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    “A Whole New World” Living in a twenty-first century society having a relationship with the natural world is the last thing on a person’s mind. In this century, nature is taken for granted. One might say nature is underappreciated and not as valued as it probably should be. Jane Goodall’s essay “In the Forests of Gombe” shows the flip side of what we believe the natural world to be. In Goodall’s essay she describes the many things she has learned while spending time in Gombe.…

    • 1356 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    You Decide It is rare to find an article or story explaining a certain topic without the author trying to convince the reader to agree with his or her opinion. Michael Pollan’s essay An Animal’s Place is effective because of the way he presents facts and his personal experience while allowing the reader to formulate their own unpersuaded opinion.…

    • 396 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Morelle cites five different perspectives, ranging from professionals in wildlife to well known organizations, in regard to the decline of wildlife. Through the use of reasoning, emotional appeals and credible sources, Morelle effectively convinces her audience that the decline of wildlife poses a serious problem and action must be taken to slow the situation. Morelle starts the article with a statement made by the World Wide Fund for Nature (WWF) and the Zoological Society of London (ZSL) claiming that vertebrate population would reduce to two-thirds by 2020 and that…

    • 961 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    There has been an ongoing debate on whether it is logical to have animal rights or not. You can either say that animal rights is foolish because animals are not developed enough to understand human behavior and they do not experience the same struggles as humans, therefore, they should not be given the same rights. On the other hand, one who supports animal rights, might say that animals should be given rights because even though they may not have the same human experiences, they do experience physical pain, emotion, and stress. They are still living beings, which makes it our responsibility to preserve the welfare of animals. Well what do you think?…

    • 1452 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Wilderness is a highly idealized concept in today’s society – we simply put it on a pedestal and choose to admire it as we see fit. Separate from our everyday, civilized lives, nature and wilderness are distant and remote concepts. By approaching the natural realm in this sense, we simply detach ourselves from our origin, which leaves us to fantasize about the great outdoors as an escape from the artificial creations of our everyday life. This dualistic notion and the desire to escape our artificial lives has lead to the construction of locations such as national parks, which merely appear to be the natural world, yet in reality are simply just facets of the modernized world we have created.…

    • 1187 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However, as I got farther along in the reading, I began to think that Stephen Gould’s purpose was to inform us of three reasons that could account for the extinction of dinosaurs. I believe that the purpose of this article was informative, as Gould wasn’t trying to entertain or persuade us to do anything. Stephen Gould was giving detailed facts on why each of the three theories were good or bad hypotheses. In my opinion, I believe that Gould did an excellent job in informing his readers and was successful in achieving his purpose because the intent can easily be detected in the reading. Throughout the essay, Gould made several valuable points that I agree with.…

    • 733 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Michael Pollan’s “An Animal’s Place” Pollan provides an argument on whether or not Americans should consume animals, and specifically, if the fashion in which animals are farmed and slaughtered respects their capacity to suffer. Pollan illustrates his personal dilemma particularly when he ironically points his debate on whether or not to eat meat began while he was dining at a steakhouse. To develop his argument, Pollan initially exclusively uses the citation of animal rights activists, but then gradually cites experts that support his conclusion that Americans eat animals as long as the principle behind it is correct, and animals are treated with respect. He asserts to accomplish respecting animals that Americans need to regain their contact…

    • 1386 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Essay On De-Extinction

    • 900 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Currently many animals are at risk of extinction due to pollution, overharvesting and habitat destruction. (Text 4) In text 3 it states “de -extinction tend to resurrect single charismatic species yet millions of species are at risk of extinction.” In other words there are many species at the brink of extinction yet scientists are concerned about the de-extinction of species. In addition it is believed that de-extinction will become a “moral hazard”.…

    • 900 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    That’s like someone telling humans that if we do not do what we have to do for this environment in a good way, we do not deserve to be saved or be living. The other method that is mentioned in this is called the Evolution First. This method saves the species that have a genetic biodiversity. I feel that species, who are becoming extinct and are becoming smaller in their group size, are ok if they are chosen not to be saved due to the facts that are placed on them as a whole. To not save species, who do not harm or do anything to the environment in a bad way and who are actually growing in size is a horrific and cruel motion to…

    • 899 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Neanderthal Essay

    • 847 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In human history, we came to find that there are many different species relating to the human species. One of these species is called the Neanderthals or also known as cavemen. Approximately 40,000 years ago the neanderthals lived but, they vanished instantly at a period of time. Not many people know why or how this happened, who really were the neanderthals and finally what they were like. Neanderthals were a species that branched off of our ancestral tree.…

    • 847 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many species in the world are endangered and eventually becoming extinct. The main problem that generates extinction is human activity; people cause extinction every day and unknowingly to them, it is killing innocent animals. Due to pollution, natural forces, human interaction, and loss of habitats, animal extinction is a major crisis in the world; people are the only ones that can save the animal population before it is too late. Pollution is among the most insidious threats to animal extinction. It can be as obvious as sewage and oil spills in water or as invisible as chemicals used every day.…

    • 1772 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Areas that have been effected by overconsumption and the conflict this has on nature and society The natural world has fallen victim to the anthropocentric ideal of evolution as the natural world has been overconsumed by society in order for global development. Cronon (1995) states that natures worth is measured and judged by civilisation, claiming that society produces a dualistic world of humans and nature being placed at opposite ends of the spectrum. This ideal is ironic seeing as development cannot be achieved without nature, and nature cannot be sustained and conserved without the protection of society. Cronon (1995) displays the false truths of society as we live in an urbanized world although beliefs are held that our natural home…

    • 862 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays