The Perils Of Obedience Asch Analysis

Better Essays
Dilemmas of obedience is a widespread topic that has been studied by Solomon Asch and Stanly Milgram. Asch studied the probability of a person to conform to a group and Milgram investigated one’s ability to resist authority. Although there’s variations in the way each experiment was conducted, there’s many similarities that relate to the treatment of each subject. Results of these studies support the reasoning behind the different ways that people act. Events in the past can also correlate with the way people act in modern times. Today, college is problematic for students due to the effects of group pressure and authority which creates flaws in our educational system. Solomon Asch discusses his experiment in the article, “Opinions and Social …show more content…
His main purpose was to, “test how much pain an ordinary citizen would inflict on another person simply because he was ordered to by an experimental scientist” (Milgram 1). The subjects were misled when they were told this was the effect of pain on memory. Their role in this experiment was to be a “teacher” who administers the shock. Also, there’s a “learner” who is strapped into an electric chair and is purposely told to give the wrong answers. Each time a question is answered incorrectly, the shock level increases. An experimenter is placed in the laboratory that stands as the figure of authority. Their job is to tell the teacher to keep going and to finish the experiment. There’s thirty switches that range from slight shock, to danger. Two levels of shock after danger are labeled XXX. It was predicted that each examinee would disobey the experimenter. Unexpectedly, 25 of the 40 subjects followed each command until the study was finished. Many subjects voiced their concern that they are hurting the learner. Fred Prozi states, “I can’t stand it I’m not going to kill that man in there” (Milgram 3). Even though the teacher isn’t okay with potentially hurting the learner, they still obeying to authority. When the teachers had the choice of how much shock was administered, only two went above 75 volts. One of the subjects who went above 75 volts laughed and said it was due to, “sheer reaction …show more content…
For example, many of my friends in my science class wanted to skip one of the labs. This is because there’s a paper that would be assigned during the Thanksgiving break. Although it was tempting, I still went to the class. My best friend conformed to the group and didn’t go. I was one of the few who didn’t succumb to group pressure. I knew that it would be wrong and unfair to the professor if I didn’t attend. This can relate to Solomon Asch’s experiment. Often, the subjects in that study conformed to the group. Maltreatment of students is also seen in colleges today. Sometimes, teachers expect too much from their students not realizing they have other responsibilities. For instance, one of my professors heavily weighs our chances of being exempt from the final. In order to be eligible to not take it, we have to take many quizzes and write many papers every week for the duration of the semester. The professor lost all the quiz grades that the students worked very hard on. He continues to give a large work-load week after week even though the students have other work to do from other classes. The class impacts me negatively because sometimes I don’t have enough time to devote myself to other classes which is very stressful when time managing. During time that would be spent with friends, I have to work on other classes which barely leaves any time to myself. This could relate to Milgram’s experiment

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    The subjects (teachers) were unaware that shocks were not really being delivered, and the learner (confederate) was just acting. The confederate’s responses were programmed to be correct or wrong in the same sequence for all the subjects. As the amount of voltage increased with incorrect answers, the learner (confederate) began to shout in discomfort. After 300 voltages, the learner became completely silent and refused to answer any more question. The teacher was instructed to treat this lack of response as an incorrect response, and whenever the subject (teacher) turned to the experimenter for guidance, he would order the subject to continue.…

    • 766 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Yet, the majority of the classes at the time were behind or forward from the set calendar. This had made the situation chaotic, since not only I had to remember when each class begins and when it finishes but It was almost impossible to rotate the teachers to have students experience different teaching styles. Also, the registration of the students was so scattered through different periods that we could not rely on our budget heavily. On top of that, the students could not trace their progress in a year systematically. One of the top priorities in order to organize the school was taking appropriate measurements to have the classes back to the track.…

    • 1186 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Reflection While writing this paper and reflecting back, I just realized that when someone cheated 4 off of me at Cecil College, it was one person who did that and not the entire school. It’s important not judge and forgive others as no one is perfect. While we were all created differently, some people may have the same idea as me, for example, in the discussion posts, so they may not necessarily be cheating off of me. Also, while my belief is still confirmed, that I am against cheating, I realized that it’s important to understand why someone may have cheated. Lang states that people cheat because “It is an inappropriate response to a learning environment that wasn’t working for the student” (Lang, page 1, para 3) If I look back at most of my college courses, this makes sense now on why colleges have students fill out the surveys at the end of the course.…

    • 1010 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Stanford Prison Experiment

    • 1149 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The experiment also shows that good people can also be affected by authority. In the experiment, the teachers were given the list of questions to relay to the students behind a wall. The teacher is told that whenever the student gets a wrong answer he is supposed to apply electric voltage shocks to the student. Whenever the student gets a wrong answer higher the voltage Watts is increased. As the voltage got increasingly higher the student start to complain about how painful the electric shocks are getting.…

    • 1149 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Why does Bullying Happen These days people bullying happens all the time and kids are getting tired of it but, what do you do when we are the bullies?We have only so many teachers at a time to watch all the children in the school. Having people drop out is making our community more dumb due to not getting a high school diploma you can 't go to college. Bullying is an every day annual thing that re-occurs every generation. Don 't you ever wonder what starts bullying and why it happens because I sure do! Ever wonder how bullying starts?…

    • 1420 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In the beginning of this semester, I remember what a nervous wreck I was and how much pressure was put on me. Attending my second semester at UNC Charlotte on academic probation was not my first intention whenever I moved to the city of Charlotte and made the new commitment of attending a four year university. Whenever I was told that I needed to attend a class two times a week so I wouldn’t be kicked out of school, I felt nothing but shame and frustration. I was certain whenever I mentioned to my parents and my girlfriend that I was on academic probation, they would be ashamed of me. I was wrong.…

    • 1735 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Colton would engage in deviant behavior to violate this norm. Disrupting the class is a folkway because it does not affect society. This social norm helps the teacher maintain order in the classroom and it shows that you have respect for your classmates and your teacher as well. It is an interesting norm to violate because not many people even think twice about how they 're supposed to act in a classroom. The reactions that we received from our classmates puzzled me a little bit because they just started laughing and it is not clear to me why the class reacted that way.…

    • 1495 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    They eventually put those answers on the answer key and automatically failed because they were all wrong. The teacher did this to see how many students would cheat of course. The outcome was not only that they failed the test, but also got written up and had to explain in a meeting why they cheated to their parents, teacher, principle, and academic dean. There are many…

    • 496 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Benefits Of Plagiarism

    • 1125 Words
    • 5 Pages

    One of this example appeared in National Certificate of Educational Achievement (NCEA), about fifteen students cheated in the NCEA exam. Finally, they had their qualification cancelled and they cannot go in for the exam for two years. Schools and teachers just want to see how students learn and comment. "Feedback is also telling people that NCEA prepares students well for university classes and further exercise. The mix of internal and external assessment in NCEA gives students achievement results that show a plentiful and accuracy picture of their skills and knowledge and this is what employers, university and polytechnics, both in New Zealand and overseas are wanting to see."…

    • 1125 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    “Paris, along with Richard J. Stiggins, president of the Assessment Training Institute in Portland, Oregon, believes that more educators are now realizing how standardized tests provoke considerable anxiety—anxiety that increases with each year that students move through school. Furthermore, students do not necessarily become “test wise” as is commonly believed. Instead, older students report not checking their answers, filling in bubbles mindlessly, carelessly skimming passages for answers, and occasionally cheating. This “test pollution” encourages destructive habits that undermine genuine learning.”…

    • 924 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays