Essay On Plato's Analogy Of The State

Improved Essays
Explain and assess the analogy of the soul and the state.

The analogy of the soul and the state is a key method that Plato used in the Republic. According to Plato, studying the structure of a state is like studying a enlarged version of individual soul, as if they are small and large prints . This essay will outline how the analogy works in the context of the Republic. Restricted to length, the tripartite nature of the soul is assumed valid, despite there were opposite voices from scholars such as N. D. Smith. Instead, the essay argues the analogy is not a strong one as it has flawed consistency throughout the book. It does not show evident answer to the question of justice.
Barker described it as a 'psychological analogy ' . The key element in the analogy is that both a soul and a state should contain three parts, and they function differently. Plato believed that state behaviours are completely a reflection of individual behaviours .
…show more content…
Whereas in a state, each class contains individuals, who are compounds of all three parts of the soul. This is to say, Plato simplified the concept of the soul when he discussed a state, giving individuals only one outstanding characteristic (rationality/courage/desire). However when he went back to analyse a soul he again unpacked the concept and discuss three compounds independently. Consequently when we study an individual in the context of Plato 's ideal state, the soul and the state are no longer analogous in terms of justice. The contradiction is created as soon as Plato made state supersede individuals.
The underlying text is that justice is not an absolute concept for individuals in from the soul. Although in both circumstances there is a higher good separated from the object , the actual concepts of this 'higher good ' are different for different classes in the

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Plato’s Position on Justice in Comparison to Dante and Machiavelli Plato asserts his position on justice throughout “The Republic.” His views constitute a model for how society should behave based on the values presented by Socrates in the dialogue. From Plato’s teachings we can infer that to establish justice, we must establish several principles in our lives including proper education, moderation, and courage. Although Plato describes how to live a just life through the metaphorical creation of a city, as opposed to focusing on the individual or going about the concept in a more abstract manner, he also asserts that justice is the quality of the soul, and a soul can only be pure if temptations are ignored. Socrates concludes that education and obedience are parallels.…

    • 1281 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    By this, Plato meant that reason did not overcome spirit, spirit did not over come appetite and so on. The soul was essentially balanced. Plato believed that a soul that is in disorder is miserable and that person will never achieve happiness. He compared the soul to that of a city. An ideal city is that where all parts of the city are working together.…

    • 1162 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Republic Book IV, Plato introduces a new understanding of the human soul that remains “advantageous for each part and for the whole soul, which is the community of all three parts” (442c6-8). Thus we reach a point…

    • 842 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Socrates Soul Analysis

    • 731 Words
    • 3 Pages

    This section of “Plato’s Republic” demonstrates key ideas of the soul from Socrates view point. From the start of this section Socrates introduces his ideas to Glaucon. Socrates believed that cities have three attributes. He goes on to explain that since the attributes of a city come from the people living within, the soul must also be split into three attributes. Socrates attempts to break down the soul into three different categories; the part of the soul that learns or thinks (rational), the part of the soul that desires pleasure, and the part of the soul that is spirit.…

    • 731 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In book eight of Plato’s Republic, he describes the five different types of constitutions: the first and best being the aristocracy, also known as the kallipolis, followed by the timocracy, third is the oligarchy, fourth is the democracy and finally the last and worst of the cities is the tyranny. The cities, and therefore the corresponding types of the soul degenerate because of the character of the ruler as Plato tells us at the beginning of book eight: “And do you realize that of necessity there are as many forms of human character as there are of constitutions? Or do you think that constitutions are born ‘from oak or rock’ and not from the characters of the people who live in the cities governed by them, which tip the scales, so to speak,…

    • 1142 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Although today’s society views democracy as the ideal form of government, the ancient Greek philosopher Plato had different ideas of how a government should be structured. Born around 428 B.C. into an aristocratic family, “he almost certainly served in the military during the Peloponnesian war;” however, he did not involve himself in political affairs of the state. His reason for doing so was because he “withdrew in disgust from the evils then being practiced” (viii-ix). Yet, Plato still found politics fascinating enough to write entire works based on the subject, as seen in some of his writings including one entitled the Republic. In the Republic, Plato discusses his idea of an ideal political community—an aristocracy, which is accountable…

    • 1776 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One of the main arguments Plato makes is that the soul has the function of “caring for things, ruling and deliberating (Republic, 353d).” He goes on to add that living is also an essential part of the soul. We can conclude from this that a good soul cares, rules, deliberates, and lives well, while a bad soul does none of these…

    • 716 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the Republic, Plato introduces many of his viewpoints and ideals through arguments. Some examples of what he introduces are what defines a city, principles of specialization, the tripartite soul and the sun, the line and the cave. In this paper, we are going to focus on the tripartite soul argument and the nature of justice. The tripartite soul argument states that a human soul is divided into three distinct parts that all want to achieve different goals. The soul, according to Plato, is composed of a rational, a spirited, and an appetitive factor.…

    • 1330 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Firstly, whether or not one believes in universals over and above particulars, or whether one is a nominalist, or abides somewhere in between the pronouncements of both camps, the obvious metaphysical inference from Plato 's account of justice is that abstract properties, such as justice, when instantiated by greater, composite phenomena, such as by a city or nation-state as opposed to a person, inherit the same "structure" rather than the same "essence." By structure, I mean thereby the abstract anatomy of an entity, or that upon which an entity depends or is instantiated by, while, by essence, I mean something less like the traditional philosophical sense of the word, but rather something more on par with its the everyday, conventional usage, i.e., concerning the general import, gist or spirit (as in, "in the spirit of x") belonging to, or associated with, the content, on the one hand, and contained and delineated by that structure, on the other. For Plato, the structure of justice is more important--neigh, is completely sufficient, along with the content, but only secondarily, for describing the nature of justice itself--than the essence, which is what it means for justice to have the content and structure that it…

    • 2077 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Introduction: Over the course of human history there have been a number of highly influential philosophers who have helped shape modern political science. Yet, few can claim to have made as large of an impact on political theory as Plato and his seminal work The Republic. The book takes the form of a dialogue between Socrates and a variety of different individuals, and touches upon a number of subjects, such as the nature of justice, and debating whether the just or unjust man is happier. Despite having put forward a wide collection of arguments, The Republic, and in many ways Plato himself, has had their philosophical legacy defined by the Allegory of the Cave in Book VII.…

    • 1904 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Within every person, there is an immortal soul. Immortal meaning that after death the soul continues to live on. During the paper, I will explain Plato’s view towards the immortality of the soul, which argument of Plato’s is the strongest to defending his claim, then I will talk about three arguments as to why I believe there is an immortal soul within each human being. Finally, I will look back at Plato’s strongest argument from the first section and give my personal take on his belief as to why we have an immortal soul.…

    • 1561 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ethics are how one should govern themselves. This is usually through moral assumptions, but Plato uses the virtues as a way to describe what is virtuous, therefore ultimately good, and what is not virtuous. The State mirrors the individual soul; therefore, the State virtues mirror the virtues of the individual soul. Plato makes the distinction that the human soul actually has three parts, but that will be discussed later. In order to achieve the virtue moderation, or balance, the three parts of the soul must ultimately be in harmony with each…

    • 1287 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Plato felt as the Body was a hindrance to the soul, almost as if the body is the prison of the soul. Plato believed that you need to balance all sides of the soul depending on what kind of society you live…

    • 719 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Plato found moderation in the harmonious interaction between all classes and in the agreement that the highest class should rule and the rest should obey. This led Plato to the conclusion that by process of elimination, justice in the State is found in the harmonious unity of all classes created by the principle of specialization in which each class minds their own business. When each class attends to its own work, then the State is just. If any class attempts to do the work of another, there will be an injustice in the State. Justice can be seen using the metaphor of justice as a person’s soul.…

    • 1482 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    I agree with some part, but not the whole of the argument made. One aspect that I agree with is the argument that the individual should play a key should in the justice cycle. This is because, of the way that he explained the different states of the soul and how harmonious existence results to a virtuous person who in this case performs their duties in the society and listens to reason. However, at the same time, the definition of justice does not seem t fully apply to the modern world that we fit in hence the doubt on its applicability now. Additionally, Plato’s theory of hierocracy seems to not take into consideration the issue of self-determination.…

    • 1424 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays