Evil Means Justify Honorable Ends Analysis

Improved Essays
Prompt: Do you agree or disagree with the following: “Evil means justify honorable ends.” Using your knowledge of the text, write a well thought out analysis relating to the quote.

In Catch-22, the definition of terms such as ‘evil’ and ‘honorable’ are as warped and contorted as possible. As a result, there is an unethical solace found in the ruling of the bureaucracy, who, as stated in the journal prior, are the clear antagonists. Lead by Colonel Cathcart, the sinister ruling states that there is a certain quota of flights that must be carried out before one is cleared to leave the forces. However, upon meeting that criteria and applying for leave, Cathcart would irrationally raise the required amount, placating the belief amongst the soldiers that escape is possible. To directly answer the question, I completely disagree with the
…show more content…
To say that evil means justify honorable ends would be the equivalent of accepting that success is borne more often than failure out of cruelty. In the example of Yossarian, the abusive regime leads him to eventually begin sabotaging his own missions, putting not only the sanctity of the bombing flights but also the lives of his comrades in harm’s way. The idea behind the malicious intent of the bureaucracy is that their prestige as superiors can be wielded as an oppressor’s tool– to blatantly create unorthodox, harsh rules that the soldiers are forced to follow. Yet the question stands: where are the honorable means? Even in the original proverb, it is written as “the end justifies the means”, yet all they accomplish through keeping them in this limbo is having their mental strength battered until they have no sense of rhyme or reason. Two characters who symbolize this are Piltchard and Wren, the captain duo who are

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    In regards to the text, Rowan symbolizes the archetype of a civilization; a place that is sheltered with regulations, where moral values and ethics play a key role in determining a cultivating a refined civilization. On the other hand, one of the influential characters who molds Rowan into the ambivalent figure towards the end of the novel—Honorable Scythe Goddard— symbolizes the atrocious nature of savagery within this dystopian novel. Scythe Goddard displays the psychological aspect of an untamed poison; the use of corruption which disguises the malevolence of savagery, by maliciously enjoying the thrill of murdering others for the sake of pleasure and fame. Based on the theme that has been weaved throughout the storyline delicately by the author, Neal Shusterman, the personality of Rowan is overshadowed by the values of the society that is inflicted upon him to provide guidance against the evils of humanity. Rowan diligently strives to remain above the inner psychological conflicts preventing Rowan from acting upon the “revelations” that Scythe Godard illustrated another pivotal theme of individual versus…

    • 1910 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Fascism Disadvantages

    • 982 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The main dangerous potential outcome of fascism is that the sole leader is a human being that may subconsciously have the desire of misusing his power. This fact can urge him to take advantage of his position to follow certain actions in order to serve his own benefit and not that of the nation. An additional disadvantage of fascism is that the individuals who condemn the dictator could be punished by imprisonment or, in the worst case, death. In that way, human rights play second fiddle. Similarly, fascism as an ideology aims in uniting the different classes so that there are no divisions.…

    • 982 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Sleepwalkers Summary

    • 780 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The historian uses the attacks on Louvain to highlight the senseless destruction of culture from the war, which was inconvenient to all parties as a result of their interlinking economies. However, countries, such as Russia, underestimated the future impact the war and saw in it advantages such as ending tensions or uniting their countries. Similar to Clark, MacMillan also explains the complications of holding Germany as the responsible party and how this is an ongoing debate to this…

    • 780 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    If he flew them he was crazy and didn’t have to; but if he didn’t want to he was sane and had to” (46). The air missions the soldiers must fly are considered to be deadly and choosing to fly them equates to suicide. Through this manipulation of words, either of the available outcomes leads the soldier to fly more missions, benefitting the bureaucracy and taking away soldiers’ freedom to choose their fates. Therefore, soldiers are oppressed because they are forced to risk their lives as a result of the military’s misleading and roundabout phrasing. With this humorous yet frightening rule, Heller critiques the corruption and power found in bureaucracies in the real world, which oppress people through confusingly worded legislation that keeps them suffering for the state’s gains.…

    • 1649 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    By using propaganda, the Party implements a hatred of their enemies upon the people: in particular, the hatred of Emmanuel Goldstein. Winston describes him as “the primal traitor, the earliest defiler of the Party’s purity” (Orwell 14), an image that has presumably been manipulated by the Party. The Two Minutes Hate is a form of propaganda that helps spread this hatred. “The horrible thing about the Two Minutes Hate was not that one was obliged to act a part, but that it was impossible to avoid joining in” (Orwell 16). Even if a person does not find Goldstein to be horrible, they are conditioned to react negatively to the Two Minutes Hate, indicative of a loss of free will, playing directly into the Party’s hand.…

    • 1581 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The guilty one is not he who commits the sin, but the who causes the darkness.” (Les Miserables) Through this Hugo clearly shows that the blame is meant to lie with the society and the justice system which produces only hardened women and men as presented through Valjean. Also, Hugo demonstrates the corrupt state of the French justice system. Hugo uses Champmathieu’s trial in Les Miserables to show the ease at which a biased testimony can sentence an innocent man to a lifetime of hard labor in the corrupt justice…

    • 1003 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This poster is a clear example of how governments strived to make their opposition look worse and display them in a way that makes the audience hate them (Hopps). This idea of negatively depicting the enemy implies the moral duty of one country’s citizens--to only support their country, not the enemy. By twisting the truth about World War I and the opposing countries, propagandists were able to give audiences the perspective that this war was morally justified and worth fighting…

    • 1045 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When a person is blinded by his own selfishness, he breaks away from the understood standard of decent morality to prepare to fight in war for what he wants. Consequently, those battling against the good receive the label of evil. Therefore, the triumph of good over evil is an important universal theme to analyze in order to help…

    • 1740 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Treaty of Versailles may have been written in an effort to stop World War I and bring peace between the opposing countries, but it 's outcome was much more harmful. Most facts show and support that the Treaty of Versailles failed in many ways, which therefore lead to World War I. Some facts that help me prove my point include, the treaty highly offended Germany causing them to want revenge, the treaty diminished Germany 's economy, and the treaty affected Germany 's military. All of these points show how the Treaty was responsible for World War II, and how it failed in many different ways. Also, these atrocities made Germany very vulnerable, and lead to the rise in power of Adolf Hitler.…

    • 1707 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    is no more than a symbolic plot device to the author: as the catalyst of conflict, his character symbolizes the pure malice which tears apart those who do not correspond with society’s frequently harsh standards. This is hinted at by some of his first actions in the book: stating that Hassan’s caste, the Hazara, dirty the blood of the pure Pashtun race, then condemning Amir for being at all involved with him (40). By providing Assef’s bigoted perspective, Hosseini clarifies that the companionship between Amir and Hassan is inevitably going to end because of their various differences being inharmonious with the significantly more powerful force of society. Furthermore, through this small moment, Assef is able to plant a seed of doubt within…

    • 1071 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays