Euthyphro Pious Analysis

Improved Essays
What is the true consensus of piety defined as? Through several dialogues created by Euthyphro and Socrates impious and pious is the main focus of both Gods who are both being prosecuted for different reasons. “Is what is morally good commanded by God because it is morally good, or is it morally good because it is commanded by God?” Under what circumstances should piety be considered and is there an agreeable outcome of what is pious? Given the views of both Socrates and Euthyphro, both philosophers weigh their opinions heavily on one another trying to come to an agreement of what is pious, if it is not already unknown.
Socrates view
Euthyphro is on trial for taking his father to court for the manslaughter of a servant and while awaiting trial he comes upon Socrates who is also being indicted. Socrates is shocked and in disbelief that Euthyphro would take such
…show more content…
But that can’t be true because Zeus is putting him on trial and if what the Gods agree on what is pious and impious then Euthyphro would not be in the position he is in now. Euthyphro once again response to Socrates and his question to what is pious with a broad answer instead of his own opinion which gives Socrates an indication that he does not know, even with his knowledge, the true definition of pious and instead gives the definition that Gods would see fit. "Well then what is dear to the Gods is pious, what is not pious." Socrates informs Euthyphro that it cannot be trusted upon the Gods what pious and impious is because they too have a difference in opinion and do not often agree and sometimes dispute, so by Euthyphro using the definition and of what the Gods say are pious is not valid because the Gods themselves are unable to determine what is pious and

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Euthyphro Pious Analysis

    • 729 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Euthyphro goes to charge his father for killing his slave after a slave killed another. Euthyphro states that it is because it is pious to do so, however Socrates sees through that and tells him to repeat his reasoning. After Socrates agrees with the way Euthyphro explains the use of piety again, Socrates restates into more detail piety and impiety in the way that Euthyphro means it. This is the instance at which Socrates states “An action or a person that I beloved by the gods is pious, while an action or person that is despised by the gods is impious. They are not the same, but complete opposites” (7a. p.5).…

    • 729 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this paper, I argue that Euthyphro’s defense of his view that his father is guilty of murder is not cogent. I will first present the argument that Euthyphro’s claim against his father is mainly rooted in circumstantial beliefs that can easily be disputed. Secondly, I will prove that Euthyphro is too unreliable of a source for the cogency of his sole account to be convincing. And lastly, I will argue that Euthyphro’s main reason for prosecuting his father does not have to do with his own moral compass, but rather with his own pride and hunger for recognition.…

    • 1153 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In Plato’s three works Crito, Apology, and Euthyphro, Socrates’ conception of virtue and pursuit of knowledge about virtue, leads him to question and in some cases reject the ideas of others. Examples that show this are: Socrates discussion with Crito, his questioning of Meletus in the Apology, his speech to the jury before and after his conviction, and in his discussion with Euthyphro about what is pious. The teachings of these three works seem to go hand and hand with one another, with the teaching of the Crito being a culmination of the teachings of Euthyphro and Apology. If one were to read Apology and Euthyphro without reading the Crito, one may not understand the teachings of the formers since the Crito gives practice to the teachings…

    • 1839 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Socrates points out that this is simply one example of piety, not a meaningful explanation, and in reply to this Euthyphro insists that…

    • 1024 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Euthyphro cannot give a definition that delivers a mastery of the word without contradicting himself. Socrates /concluded that Euthyphro could not possibly use the gods as an excuse for his actions because he cannot define what piety…

    • 923 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Given the Supreme Court’s assertion that the associations and activities of the Humanitarian Law Project were a threat to national security, I believe that Plato’s Socrates would have found the decision of the Court to be unjust. Like HLP, Socrates’s behavior was perceived as a threat to the nation, in that he was impious and corrupting the youth with his beliefs. However, Socrates found that “piety” was subjective, saying that his relentless search to confirm the words of the Oracle made him “In ten-thousandfold poverty because of [my] devotion to the god.” In this quote, Socrates alludes to the ambiguity that exists in the legal system, specifically in defining the nature of piety. Given the similarly ambiguous terminology of the HLP case, I believe that Socrates would not find it lawful to punish HLP.…

    • 312 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Fourth and Fifth of Euthyphro's Definitions to Piety In the fourth definition of Euthyphro in Plato's dialogue of “Euthyphro”, he describes piety is as a “servants show to their master” (Plato 71). meaning the one should follow the god's ways, like in a way in how a priest would follow the words of the gods in what could be good or evil. Furthermore, Euthyphro could be suggesting that attending to gods is piety (good), meaning doing things that would please the gods would be seeing as goods or just. While not attending to the gods would be seen as impiety to the gods, meaning doing things that the gods would not like would seeing as an evil deed.…

    • 739 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    This is why he asks Euthyphro to define piety, so that he himself will have a measure for deciding what is religious and what is not, thus be able to defend himself in court. Euthyphro answers that what he is doing in prosecuting his father is religious, and he cites the precedent of Zeus punishing his own father (Cronos). Socrates then questions many of the stories about strife among the gods over the next few passages as Euthyphro continues to defend the gods. This questioning of the stories about the gods is what leads to his trial in the first place, that he questioned them and that because he was a teacher it caused the youth to question the gods. If you question the gods and the gods are pious, you are in turn acting with impiety.…

    • 2276 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Euthyphro, Euthyphro tells Socrates he is prosecuting his own father for having accidentally killed a murderer. Euthyphro feels obligated to prosecute his father, against his family’s wishes, because the gods would want him to, and it would be impious for Euthyphro to let his father slide. Socrates asks Euthyphro what the definition of piety is. Euthyphro asserts that piety is prosecuting people for the wrong they have done, and not doing so would be impious. Socrates asks for a more conclusive definition, so Euthyphro answers that piety is what is dear to the gods.…

    • 460 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In Euthyphro, Socrates is being prosecuted for corrupting the youth and for impiety, while Euthyphro is being charged for murder. In conversations between the two, Socrates asks Euthyphro to teach him “what is piety” (Euthyphro, pg.47). Socrates engages Euthyphro in a discussion that will help him find the meaning of piety and by doing so, Socrates can use this to defend himself against the charges he faces. In the Platonic dialogues, Plato’s defense of Socrates illustrates that Socrates is a political philosopher in question for the truth. It is important to understand that Plato and Aristophanes both had different representations of Socrates but because of the portrayal of Aristophanes’ Clouds, his play had a profound impact on Athenian society.…

    • 1689 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Socrates claims to have no knowledge of these types of things, and concedes that if he has any knowledge at all it is of worthless or trivial things. He claims that his purpose for initiating interactions with these reputedly knowledgeable people is first and foremost to prove the oracle wrong, because he believes he really knows nothing. If he can successfully prove the oracle wrong by finding someone who is indeed wiser or more knowledgeable than him, then he will be presented with the opportunity to learn something worthwhile from the person he is engaging, which is his second purpose for these interactions. Unfortunately, this proves to be an unsuccessful method of learning for Socrates because he does not actually learn the fine and good things he has sought to learn; instead he has learned that the reputedly knowledgeable people are merely ignorant of their own ignorance. He determines that they are only truly capable of giving him examples of specific instances where actions seem to showcase the thing that he is seeking knowledge of—such the examples of piety that Euthyphro describes; he also discerns that they are incapable of giving him a definitive definition that is not easily shown to be a contradiction or fallacious in some other way.…

    • 709 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Euthyphro makes the comment, regarding his families’ ill-temperaments towards him, “Which shows, Socrates, how little they know what the gods think about piety and impiety.” (Jowett, 1868, p. 3) In justification, Euthyphro claims he his act is just according to a higher, or divine, law, which is ironically, due opposite the position Anytus, Lycon and Meletus hold against Socrates. Enter now the unmatched wisdom and adroitness of Socrates, as detailed by Plato, whereby he [Socrates] challenges and pursues Euthyphro through logic and rhetorical…

    • 600 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Although both the Bacchae and Euthyphro answer the problem of conduct, it can be argued that the conclusion Socrates comes to in Euthyphro is far more appealing to the masses, when compared to the Bacchae’s conclusion. The way the information is presented in Euthyphro and Bacchae is unique to each work. The information in Euthyphro is presented in a dialogue form with Socrates talking with an elderly man named Euthyphro outside of a courthouse, whereas the information…

    • 1683 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Euthyphro’s definition of piety is the action/way that all the gods love. This means that the gods actions are not arbitrary or relative, rather they are deeply rooted in principles which are shared. The similarity I want to draw on is in Mill’s approach to higher pleasures where he believes that competent judges’ preferences are not as relative as they are principled, hence encompassing a deeper and higher value associated with higher pleasures that outweigh the pleasure amount argument. However, it’s important to realize that this justification takes the ideology further away from hedonism as it has now involved other higher senses and principles, which defeats the purpose of hedonism. Still, it does explain the dignity and value we as mortals attach to higher pleasures that are achieved by higher capacity exercises.…

    • 1387 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Socrates was a person feared most by the Athenian’s because of his wisdom and his ability to attract others like him. His teachings were based on discovering the actual truth of morality and instilling them into the youth and talking to people about what it takes to make a good life. The dialogue in Euthyphro took place before Socrates’ trial, for which he was charged with impiety and corrupting the youth of his time.…

    • 1031 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays