Analysis Of The Karen Healey, Becoming A Trustworthy Profession

Improved Essays
Overview

The Karen Healey, Becoming a trustworthy profession, concerns the practicalities of social work as a profession with emphasis on trust. Additionally it's intention is to illustrate how trust is a functioning pillar of social work as a profession and when broken can undermined it's intentions. An example given is the royal commission into abuse in institutions to demonstrate how a breach of trust can destroy reputations and trustworthiness of professions. Healey then goes onto elaborate as to how social workers must view themselves and the skills they can accrue to be both effective and trustworthy. Finally the essay is summarized by reiterating how social work discipline must learn from the past if it is to continue into the future
…show more content…
From the essay, I argue that before any social work could be conducted , that the stereotypes surrounding practice makes the job more difficult. Social workers are working from a bias before they begin as almost an admission to prove themselves trustworthy. Social work however does not exist alone other professions require trust, I believe this is more evident when dealing with vulnerable people. The paper appears to be arguing that high standards is a moral obligation or higher ground this may infer that most other people in a particular situation would act against what is correct for the sake of themselves or the institution they work for. I believe Healey arguments whilst correct may have limitations as all jobs no matter the transparency can create a culture of covering up based on hierarchal structure and job security no matter the regulations. I agree that a knowledge based practice is the most effective way of improving the skills of the social workers. I think the practice should have a degree of fluidity depending on circumstances and also be at the discretion of the social worker. Therefore having ethics would transcend the case by case basis and would be a moral compass on which we can base our decisions. The most important point I would take from the essay is social workers must conduct themselves in a higher standard than simply continuing the statusqou. The reasoning for this point the main principle of social work is to make social

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    Critical Analysis Paper #1 Question #1: Social Work and Systems Theory Social Work as a concept and a career is simple, yet difficult to define. Social work has grown and developed from the seed that is envelops social issues in our society. As Robbins, Chatterjee, and Canda state in Contemporary Human Behavior Theory (2012), defined situations within society have dictated the need for social work and advocates to speak on behalf of those who are unable to speak for themselves. From the inception of its career, social work has been associated with helping those in need, whether that be at a micro-level with individual therapy and case management, or a macro level with policy development and large scale advocacy efforts.…

    • 2214 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Canadian Social Work Understandings Understanding on the Comparisons Perusing the various Canadian literature and comparing them to my past experiences in child protection enlightened me to the differences in practices between the First world and the third world as created and influenced by Western concepts and practices. First, social workers are bestowed with high power that it must be used with caution. The use of power by the social worker contributes and influences how the interaction between the client and the worker will unravel (Gladstone, Dumbrill, Leslie, Koster, Young, & Ismaila, 2012). For these reasons, various theories employed in practice stresses the significance of consciously minimizing the power imbalance within and while…

    • 848 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    (2014). Critical practice. Modern Social Work Theory. (4th ed.). (Chapter 12, 319-347).…

    • 510 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Because of this, social justice is achieved through the servitude of people deemed as vulnerable, and oppressed, along with living in poverty (Jacobson, 2001). We also understand its pivotal role in the service it delivers to those in need by a way of the social policy arena devising and advocating to address the wide range of social problems in order to bring about change (Jacobson, 2001). Ironically, social policy efforts that are recent is aimed at the establishment or the protection of social workers roles, verses promoting transformations in the delivery of human services (Jacobson, 2001). It is also suggest more often in today’s society, social work students are more readily trained as clinical practitioners than advocates of change (Jacobson, 2001). Although there is a continuation of promoting social justice and action, strategies of this type is no longer prioritized (Jacobson, 2001).…

    • 781 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this profession, it is essential that social workers know the roles on how oppression and discrimination can affect a certain population and the ways to positively impact the community they are working with (“Institutional…

    • 708 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    I find this article significant because as a social worker we should have that kind of attitude such caring and love to help people. However,we are limited to certain things , we shouldn’t get our self-involve in helping a client that a case has already been close by a new worker who couldn’t handle the case. For example, although koorer was doing the right thing for caring and helping but she didn’t do it the right way,she should have known her limit because that is how she got into trouble. This is a way to show that social worker shouldn’t have relationship outside with client especially,when the client is no longer assigned to you. According to the other the worker went to court for that because Skovholt, T., & Mathison, M. (2010).…

    • 1294 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the contemporary British social work, it is largely spread the perception of a current crisis, due to rapid changes that take place in our everyday lives. The 'crisis' nature is about the urgent need for this profession to clarify and establish its identity. ‘Indeed we have only the most general ideas of what we are trying to produce, what constitutes the essential skill of the social worker and consequently still more varied ideas as to how to set about it’ (Younghusband, 1959, p.28). The current literature already identified a few key concepts about the nature of the social work role, such as: a function of social integration, support and assistance, ,counseling, advocating, dealing with other policy areas failure, such as health, education…

    • 782 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The social work profession is to infuse change into the lives of individuals and into the community to reduce or eradicate the ill effects of personal distress and social inequality (Cox, Long, & Tice, 2016). Social workers are constantly working on brooding their horizons, by learning on the job or continuing education. Social work has seven values, some of which are grouped together, “dignity and worth of person, competence, importance of human relationships, integrity, human services, and social justice” (Code of Ethics, 2011). In the 2016 election Trump promised to deport all “illegals,” many to a country that they have never seen.…

    • 460 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Social Workers are often given enormous amount of caseload. Often one social worker could have over 30 cases they have to manage and investigate. The social workers Andy encounter all lack empathy. Many of the social workers are not genuine, promising actions that cannot be complete. It is unfortunately that some social workers are in this profession just to collect a paycheck.…

    • 964 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As I have learned throughout my time as a social work student at Carleton University, I have become familiar with the generalist perspective of social work practice. My understanding of the general perspective stipulates, that it is better for a social worker to have a strong understanding of multiple theories and ways of practice, rather than being proficient in solely one theory or practice. This is directly related to the changes that have occurred at my placement, I have luckily been able to learn from two supervisors. Therefore, I was able to develop 2 distinct practices, which were influenced by my first supervisor Hadiya, and my second supervisor Caitlin. Both of the practices that I have learned were developed by watching how both of my supervisors respond to different experiences, as well as their interaction patterns with the residents of Harmony House.…

    • 1065 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Providing love, meeting their basic needs, food, shelter, safe environment, and implement a child care plan, promoting health growth. This would also include working with social workers and other professionals involved in their lives. However, the system failed Cupcake and others due to lack of knowledge at this time. Therefore, it’s important for all Social Workers to practice pedagogical. Practicing pedagogical will enable the Social Workers to provide opportunities for learning in the basic subjects.…

    • 1274 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The paper consists of six core values of the social work profession that are displayed throughout the movie. Service There were three themes of service used in the movie “The Help”. The first theme that was used is when Eugenia, as known as “Skeeter”, started defending colored people whenever white people would say a rude comment or mistreated them. She breaks all the rules and does not seem to care about what others will say about…

    • 1222 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Social workers aim to protect vulnerable people from abuse, neglect or self-harm and help to enhance their well-being and quality of life (University of York, 2014). It can be achieved via anti-oppressive practice (AOP) and anti-discriminatory practice (ADP). These two approaches are linked but differ in focus. Social Care Institute for Excellence defines ADP as an approach which seeks to reduce, undermine or eliminate discrimination, eradicate it from the social workers practice and challenge it in the practice of others (SCIE. 2014). Payne in 2005 defined discrimination as a means of identifying individuals and groups with certain characteristics and treating them less well than people or groups with conventionally valued characteristics…

    • 770 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Being a social worker is often a challenging, yet rewarding career. Social workers are responsible for helping individuals, families, and groups of people to cope with problems they’re facing to improve their patients’ lives. Social workers are also trained caseworkers in social service agencies who perform several functions which they use different components of the practice framework, the theoretical underpinnings to in order to build helping relationships. After interviewing a caseworker in a specific social agency there were advantages and disadvantages of methods along with challenges encountered in working in that specific agency. With all of these the functions, roles and responsibilities of a caseworker is what helps any agency to uphold…

    • 1944 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    REVIEW OF ABRAHAM FLEXNER’S ARTICLE “IS SOCIAL WORK A PROFESSION? ” BY ABRAHAM FLEXNER The paper on “ Is social work a profession?” by Abraham Flexner, which was presented at the Forty Second Annual session of The National Conference on Charities and Correction on May 17th, 1915 at Baltimore, Maryland, is said to be an extended argument about whether social work can be considered a profession or not. Flexner shows us a brief picture of how a profession would be, where he brings in a comparison between a professional and an amateur; he portrays the professional as someone whose entire time is devoted to an activity and the latter who is transiently and provisionally so engaged.…

    • 1312 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays