Compare And Contrast The Moral And Ethical Dilemmas In The Island Of Dr Moreau

Improved Essays
Physical and Genetic Mutilation One person dies each minute from cancer. Cancer, among other diseases caused by genetic mutation, can potentially be prevented by scientific gene manipulation. Ten percent of the cases of cancer in the United States are caused by genetics, not environmental or physical factors. So if doctors can manipulate the gene pool before birth in an unborn child, would that be an ethical thing to do? There are similar moral and ethical dilemmas in the book The Island of Dr. Moreau, written in 1896, and in our society today.
In the book, The Island of Dr. Moreau, Moreau physically alters and performs vivisection on the bodies of conscious animals. He takes body parts from different animals and sews them together to create a new hybrid organism. The hybrid creatures he builds are “animals carven and wrought into new shapes,” (Wells, 72). Dr. Moreau has an obsession with trying to create the perfect human, similar to how genetic mutation works today in our society. He states that “there is something in the human form that appeals to the artistic turn of mind more powerfully than any animal shape
…show more content…
Moreau, and in our society today. In the book, Dr. Moreau performs vivisection on the animals of the island for his own amusement and interest. But Moreau does not realize the dreadful, depressed, and often frightening hybrid creatures he is creating. He cannot know what kind of monster he will create during his experiments. In society today, the ability to perform genetic manipulation has the potential to turn into something used to change the looks and physical abilities of an unborn child. That child that the parents decided to genetically manipulate could have been the next Albert Einstein, but they would never know because they altered that child’s genetics before they were even born. We as a society cannot know the implications of genetic engineering and

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In this enthralling, enlightening book, Ronald M. Green’s Babes by Design: The Ethics of Genetic Design explores the potential promise and threat in the innovation of genetic engineering. Babies by Design offers several elements of the complicated subject: it presents an eloquent description of the sophisticated technology and science, it clearly recaps the reasonable arguments for and against numerous exercises of biotechnology, and it relates the ideas of science fiction to that of the uncertain future. Green graduated Summa Cum Laude at Brown University, before receiving his Ph.D. in religious ethics from Harvard University in 1973. Green has written nine books and more than 170 articles on theoretical and applied ethics. This gives him…

    • 1004 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    If it's acceptable to modify one gene, why not two, or 20 or 200? At what point do children become artifacts designed to someone's specifications rather than members of a family to be nurtured? Given what we know about human nature, the development and commercial marketing of human genetic modification would likely spark a techno-eugenic rat-race. Even parents opposed to manipulating their children's genes would feel compelled to participate in this race, lest their offspring be left behind.”…

    • 478 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Genetic and genome field development has been vastly expanded over the past decade and with its positive impact on areas of science, medicine, society there is also negative impact such as the ethical issues that can follow. The developments of new genetic technologies will raise some of these ethical issues that will affect the person as well as the society as the whole. In 2010 ethical issues was emerge as big controversial problem within the scientific community by Rebecca Skloot, the publisher of The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lack, a book on the He-La cells and why it was morally unethical. He-La, a cervix cells from a woman named Henrietta Lack’s, a code named that world known to the first immortal human cells. The cells are known…

    • 1562 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Listening for the Public Voice, by Robert Cook-Deegan and Jane Maienschein, discusses the issue of genetic engineering and the ethical dilemma and how the United States, government, and people are interacting in the struggle of the ethics behind genetic engineering. The authors present the facts that genetic engineering has laid in the grey area forever, and still continues to sit in that grey area. Genetic Engineering will occasionally find itself in the news and the argument reignites but falls flat within a couple of weeks waiting till the next breakthrough arises. Cook-Deegan and Maienschein stats some of the most recent progress in genetic engineering, which brings into perspective the relevance, development, and the possibility that soon…

    • 964 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In a study titled “Public and Scientists’ Views on Science and Society,” by Pew Research Center, eighty three percent of people thought that genetic modification for babies to make the baby more intelligent was inappropriate and that it was taking medical advances way to far. (Figure 2) However, people were split on the topic of genetic modification to remove diseases. The importance of this information is that it underlines that a majority of people are not okay with genetically enhancing traits in a baby as it would give it an advantage in the world that many others would not have. The information also allows us to see that genetic modification to remove diseases is something might be favorable and not looked down upon by society.…

    • 1645 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The word monster usually makes one conjure up thoughts of creatures brought up from the foul depths of hell. Their look can make anyone run away in fear of their life. But these are not the thoughts we have for the beasts in The Island of Dr Moreau, although they are the ones called monsters. What truly makes a monster? They way they look, or the way they act?…

    • 750 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Public Voice Argument

    • 854 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The article “listening for the Public Voice” by Robert Cook-Deegan and Jane Maienchein discuses the many arguments, both for and against, surround human embryo gene mutation and experimentation. They then provide multiple examples from scientific history in which the practices had faced the same amount of scrutiny from the public, yet once people saw the rewards that could result from these practices, they allowed these practices to become “normal”. In the article “Listening for the Public Voice”, Robert Cook-Deegan and Jane Maienchein argue the public voice has more power than most people think, if it is used correctly. They do this through logical reasoning with specific examples in society where this has happened in order to encourage the public to stand strong in what they believe.…

    • 854 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sequencing Essay

    • 1108 Words
    • 5 Pages

    With the advancements made in technology daily and new scientific studies and explorations, the science community is always on the brink of something big. And the next big thing might be designer babies. Deeper and more profound exploration into cells and genetics have allowed for the possibility of designer babies to emerge. Before creating designer babies was even an idea, scientists were first working towards sequencing the human genome. By sequencing the human genome, scientists will be able to identify which nucleotide sequences code for which genes.…

    • 1108 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Deciding Actively Listening for the Public Voice, by Robert Cook-Deegan and Jane Maienschein, discusses the issue of genetic engineering and the ethical dilemma and how the United States, government, and people are interacting in the struggle of the ethics behind genetic engineering. The authors present the facts that genetic engineering has laid in the grey area ever since it was first brought to in lab, and still continues to sit in that grey area. Genetic Engineering will occasionally pop up in the news and the argument will be reignited but quickly fizzle out till the next breakthrough appears on media. Cook-Deegan and Maienschein stats some of the most recent breakthroughs in genetic engineering which brings into perspective the relevance,…

    • 904 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    If thinking about Prenatal Genetic Testing solely as an indicator to help the wellbeing of a future child as he/she grows up, then this procedure can be regarded as ethical in Utilitarian terms. However prenatal genome testing can also be considered as unethical if consequences can be detrimental to a child. For example, if a child was to grow up with unnecessary precautions and constant testing that will ruin a child’s process of growing up. A child may be jealous that other children may be able to eat what they want, do what they want, and would not have to be heavily monitored as he/she does. A child can also miss out on activities, events and sports due to this precaution of a possible disease.…

    • 2208 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Natural selection could soon be in the hands of humans. In the 1970s, scientists began to isolate certain genes in DNA for the first time. Gene therapy arose in the 1980s as more researchers became curious. Gene therapy is defined as a "technique where the genes causing a defect are themselves substituted by correct genes in the patient to cure a disease" (Macer, 1990). Natural selection is the process in which organisms that are best adapted to their environment survive and therefor, reproduce more offspring.…

    • 537 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Today, there are more thoughts about allowing parents to bioengineer their children. Instead of relying on fate to see how their baby turns out, some people want the power to genetically modify their kids before birth. For example, if a parent wanted a tall boy, they could predetermine this. Contrastingly, Michael Sandel argues bioengineering because again, it takes away the giftedness of children. He explains, “To appreciate children as gifts is to accept them as they come, not as objects of our design, or products of our will, or instrument of our ambition,” (45).…

    • 1789 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Designer Babies Imagine a society where kids grew up in a defect-free environment. Even if the technology that would create this seems distant, geneticists are actively researching it and there’s even a term for children that could be genetically modified. They’re called designer babies and could revolutionize the effects impairments have on our society. However, this new project could also have a negative effect on our society as well, such as the unsure success rate of the procedure. The use of this technology is a double edged sword, but I believe it could help create a more nourishing environment for youth for every child to thrive.…

    • 540 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “At what point do children become artifacts designed to someone’s specifications rather than members of a family to be nurtured? (Hayes 245).” In “Genetically Modified Humans? No Thanks,” Richard Hayes argues against Ronald M. Green, a professor of Emeritus of Religion and of Ethics and Human Values at Dartmouth College, specifically responding to his essay about using genetic technology to change children’s DNA. Hayes, who holds a Ph.D. in Energy and Resource, which saluted the United States to ban human cloning worldwide, believes it would disrupt human nature and the human future.…

    • 961 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Essay #2: Disability or Enhancement? In this essay, I will argue that Gauvin’s parents were not morally justified in their decision to permanently make their son born and remain deaf because by doing so the parents are treating the child as a lesser equal and are inflicting psychological harm. The role of parents is to ensure the wellbeing, safety, and support of their child in hopes that they can become stable, independent, and functional individuals in the near future. However, choosing a sperm donor with a history of deafness or any other disabilities is morally unjust because it is specifically taking a trait and implanting it upon a child causing them a life of hardships that they have to endure.…

    • 782 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays