Ethical Dilemma Of Performance Appraisal

Great Essays
Performance Appraisal
At one point, companies leaders are faced with the dilemma of deciding an employee's future in the company. Unfortunately, many companies look to downsizing as a solution, yet there are many alternatives than just firing employees. Employees should be evaluated and judged by their performance, time commitment, attitude, and communication skills. The evaluation of employees is important, and if done right, they become aware of what they need to improve on and realistically shows their performance levels. In this ethical case, a CEO of a small family owned business wants to fire the “older” workers but Frank, the new chief financial officer, has a problem with the decision. Despite the amount of time in a specific workplace,
…show more content…
Roberts & Pregitzer (2007) note that rating bias, hypocrisy, poor informal feedback, poor communication during formal feedback sessions, and rater errors are factors that create animosity towards feedback systems. However, this can be solved through a balanced system that uses maximum effort from the managers. There are multiple aspects to an employee's performance that should not only focus on quantitative results but job knowledge and skills, quality of work, work habits, and attitude (Capko, 2007, sec. 3-7). Along with an ineffective appraisal system, downsizing can leave to detrimental effects on the company. Using downsizing as a first response, failing to change the way work is approached and involving employees plus their feedback are practices to avoid when downsizing (Uhlig, 2017, para. 1-3). Downsizing can also generate resentment and anger especially when there is a lack of clarity and when supervisors fail to provide direction, support, or information (Amundson et. al, 2004, p. 256-269). The time for employees can also give the company a chance to look at other alternatives, manage a more effective plan to downsize, and look at arrangements and a new system to implement after downsizing. Overall the plan seems to create a moderate agreeable medium that is more ethical in providing compensation for time commitment, meeting the demands of the company, and setting the business down a more successful

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Some of these events could be harassment in the workplace, narcissistic replies towards other employees, absenteeism. These examples that dysfunctional managers show can cause burnout in the subordinates. It causes absenteeism and the lack of motivation for some people with this type of manager. Narcissism plays a major role in poor leadership skills. Narcissist usually are self-motivated however, they seek admiration from others about their superiority (Judge, LePine, & Rich, 2006).…

    • 2384 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Low Morale

    • 719 Words
    • 3 Pages

    This means that the company could lose valuable employees to a competitor which would be a sad site in our eyes. The previous argument also leads to another point for low morale within the organization, which is how the company is being run. A main question which you should ask yourself is, “Does the company have a great leader, or are you working under a person with poor leadership skill?”. Poor leadership skill can also have a negative influence on the morale of the company, which is why it’s key to have a manager that has the qualities required for a the…

    • 719 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Organization: Cause of Resistance According to Tanner (2015), senior sponsors of the change often blame its failure on employee and middle manager resistance to change. Resistance reflect uncertainties which cause conflict to the ideal of change regardless of positions within the organization. The direct consequences of change being resist is due to management failure. With the growing rate…

    • 1386 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In such a scenario, a professional employee would feel unappreciated if decision-making is still retained in the family. A company with such value conflicts is considered to stifle careers and inappropriate for individual’s growth prompting one to leave the company. Conclusion In conclusion, it is evident that managers play a role in a significant proportion of decisions to leave a company. Such reflects the considerable share of influence or control that managers have in preventing or correcting the situations that prompt employees to consider working elsewhere. Ineffectiveness of a manager tends to reflect in low employee productivity, limited contentment and increased drive to leave the company.…

    • 1274 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Kerrie Peterson Case Study

    • 1131 Words
    • 5 Pages

    There is bitterness among the members as exposed through the exchanges during the meeting. The change will also not be supported by the account managers as they think that the changes are to benefit the senior management at their own expense. Kerrie’s inexperience in leadership is also brought up as the redesign team findings highlight poor communication. All in all, means of achieving the 15% cost reduction goal are proposed to be reducing travel expenses and other discretionary expenses and redesigning how employees carry out their operations (to limit the low value adding activities). It is expected, that there is likely resistance from the workforce as the rumors have already started going around.…

    • 1131 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    They may also avoid communication for fear of being labeled a trouble maker. Lack of transparency on the part of the leadership can cause an attitude to develop among the employees that shun being transparent with…

    • 781 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Tension within employees can cause the workplace to have a bad atmosphere and the company is at risk of losing and gaining any employees. Workers are not willing to work in an environment that they don 't feel comfortable in, as well as business partners are not willing to sign a deal with a company who lacks discipline and is untrustworthy. Therefore business ethics has not improved the relationships between their employees or…

    • 1320 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Bad attitudes within a workplace will decrease the performance of the whole group of workers, but also will deliver to have unhappy customers. Observing and identifying who is the person (s) causing problems is a good way to start making changes to improve the environment. Bad attitudes includes laziness, tardiness, rudeness, rumor mongering or any other attitude or activity that lowers overall morale, but bad attitudes can result from adverse events as firing, salary decreases or small problem between employees. The decreasing on the performance of the staff could come from a bad attitude of a single employee. One employee begins complaining, the complaint can spread to the rest of the workers and can also decline performance.…

    • 1491 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    c. Negative feedback with sites such as Glassdoor.com a business can be put on shame for not being kind to their employees and treating them as cattle. Either not being consistent with what management is telling an employee of or simply giving them negative feedback by not addressing 3. Result of Bad management: (Rocio) Overall, if an employee’s needs are not heard and the employee is not put first then you can pretty much expect your business to fail if you do not plan on someone addressing…

    • 988 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    These might affect the management at the company and also affect the bottom line of business in all size. A bad match between the employee's skills and the job may cause the understaff issue. Employees who are hired in jobs that are too difficult for them or whose skills are underutilized may become discouraged and quit. Insufficient information about skill requirements that are needed to fill a job may result in the hiring of either under skilled or overqualified workers. Furthermore, the substandard equipment, tools, or facilities in the company may lead to this issue.…

    • 1133 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays