Ethical And Unethical: The Case Of Jeanette M.

Improved Essays
Abstract
Law is formed for a motive and it regulates in many areas like medicine, before practicing any medical procedure or conducting a form of administrative position each medical specialist or non-medical specialist operative must comprehend a difference between ethical or unethical. Ethical and Unethical plays a significant role in our humanity every way it is whether up to how you want to approach it. According to “The case of Jeanette M. And the phone call” altered from the beginning of chapter 1 of “Medical Law and Ethics” inscribed by Bonnie Fremgen, it exemplifies how a medical receptionist and the doctor action resulted in death of Jeanette M. This case falls into so many categories of violations and code of ethics such as being
…show more content…
Signifies as ethical problem. In a real explanation, the medical receptionist should be train if any scenario come to an event such as an emergency they should know that a patient who’s in a life-threatening situation make them as their first priority. When Jeannette called the doctor’s office in the morning by explaining her symptom over the phone to medical receptionist that a patient was having trouble breathing. The receptionist vividly told Jeannette that since the doctor’s office was busy the doctor couldn’t speak to her so the receptionist told her that she would leave the message to the doctor but the message was never given to the doctor. However, what the medical receptionist was did it was unethical. “The healthcare team, composed of these professionals with the addition of healthcare administrator, often must decide on critical issues relating to patient’s needs” (Fremgen, 2015, pp .4). This assumption, in my point of view, what the medical receptionist was unethical and should have not held Jeanette symptom for several hours before sending the message and the receptionist should’ve been more attentive and put patients’ needs at the highest, who is in critical and life-threatening …show more content…
Fremgen. The author adapted the Three-Step Ethics Model by Kenneth Blanchard and Norman Peale. These three steps help you evaluate case when an ethical problem occurs. The first step Is it legal? The case of Jeanette is a legal and ethical problem. When Jeanette called the hospital regarding how she was having difficulty breathing and the receptionist failed to respond back to the doctor and Jeanette about the patient symptom so it was the receptionist and hospital responsibility to train every employee with policies and regulation since it failed to do so it can be conducted as a civil case. The second step Is it balanced? Yes, Jeanette case does have an advantage over the hospital and the receptionist. The patient called the office concerning about a life-threatening symptom instead of leaving Jeanette unseen she could’ve called the paramedics to check Jeanette places. The hospital does not have advantage over Jeanette case because most likely the hospital can be sued for not following the policy and regulation of not treating a critical patient as first priority. The third step How does it make me feel? From my perspective, I would think of this situation as what if it was one of my family member and it’s very sad to see a patient passing away the receptionist indulgency and careless act jeopardized Jeanette

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    The advancement in the field of medicine over the years has led to doctors and health care providers having more responsibilities on their hands. This brings into question what should and shouldn’t be done, as well as what is morally and ethically right. However, this isn’t so cut and dry. Each case is unique and has its own details as to how the alleged incident came into play. Therefore, each case needs to be analyzed in detail and reviewed before deciding who is at fault and to what degree they deserve to be punished. In the situation of “The Case of Jeanette M. and the Phone Call” adapted from chapter one of “Medical Law and Ethics” written by Bonnie Fremgen, it describes a medical situation that resulted in the death of an elderly women. The ethical and or legal issues in…

    • 1877 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    An ethical dilemma is considered a circumstance that requires someone two equally unfavorable situations. Unfortunately the ethical dilemma does not solve the initial problem, but nurses and other health care providers must assess and clarify the ethical dilemma and gather data. Once the dilemma has been identified, healthcare providers can identify options and make decisions to act (Black, 2017). In the Lee’s case, these strategies were not put into place soon enough. Step one in the ethical decision making model is identifing the problem and factors maintaining the problem. On Lia’s first visit to MCMC, there were no translators, so there was no way the Lee family can tell the resident that Lia just had a seizure. The resident just noticed a cough and a congested chest which lead to an x-ray taken, this lead to the diagnosis of “early bronchopneumonia”. Due to the language barrier, the resident wouldn't have known that the congestion was due to her seizure and ultimately the first misdiagnosis of Lia’s…

    • 1023 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A fact that posed as misconduct is the lack in compassion and commitment from both the physician Dr. Evans and the employees at the medical clinic in the institution. Because of the fact that Dr. Evans failed to identify the lump in Tomcik’s breast as a result of a passively performed examination, he did not follow his obligation, as a physician, to deliver the high-quality care that patients should receive. In regard of the employees at the medical clinic, they did not give Tomcik immediate medical attention, even after she stated the reason why she was requesting help from a health care professional when signing the clinic list for almost practically a whole month. Based on this evidence, it is indicative…

    • 1004 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    For instance, one of the patients on the second floor was moaning softly. The doctors and nurses asked what was wrong, but he was unable to respond because he was too ill (Fink, 2013, p. 292). This scene clearly shows a major communication barrier between the health care providers and the patient because the patient was not able to express what was wrong with him or her and the health care providers couldn’t understand what was wrong with him or her. Because of the communication barrier, an ethical issue was involved. During the crisis, a pulmonologist John Thiele gave patients high doses of morphine and midazolam. Most of the patients died shortly after they were being medicated. Since the patients were very ill and weren’t able to respond to his questions, Thiele decided to consult with the nurse manager Karen Wynn, whom he trusted her experience in the ICU and her leadership of the hospital’s ethics committee, about whether or not he could euthanatize the patients. Wynn expressed approval of euthanatizing the patients (Fink, 2013, p. 292). If there were no communication barrier between Thiele and the patients, they could have spoken up and chose whether or not they wanted to survive or be…

    • 2030 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dr. Anna Pou Case Summary

    • 593 Words
    • 3 Pages

    There should always be changes in the laws defining a profession to help them guide with the technology and people, but there are hidden loopholes people find to avoid such laws. The good thing about refining the laws is that it would help point out problems with it as well as help create better working state for professionals. The bad thing about laws is that they are not compartmentalized to help them control the outcomes that would occur preceding the passing of specific laws. On the issue of medical ethics, there will be different situation where doctors would have to take certain steps, would be called immoral under the medical ethics laws, to control a situation to help minimize the damage as well as trying to help patients in any way or form possible. The exact situation occurred in the tragic disaster of Medical Memorial Hospital in New…

    • 593 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Chapter four, titled Contracts and Intentional Torts, pertains to the various laws surrounding physician and patient relationships. A major case that is presented in the chapter pertains to a woman’s false imprisonment by a physician. The case is known as Stowers v. Wolodzko, and it outlines the physician’s rights versus a patient’s rights in a legal lawsuit.…

    • 502 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Although I agree with the court’s decision to amputate Mary’s legs in order to save her life, it is a decision that was not determined in a timely manner. Such decisions regarding patients with severe and deteriorating illness should be processed with respect to the patient’s condition becoming worse with time. Having an ethics board or a medical community to alleviate the pressure of a single doctor making a decision for a patient who is not able to act autonomously would allow for a treatment plan to be determined earlier. In Mary’s case, the court ruling prevented the doctor’s from acting to save her…

    • 815 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The codes of ethics are a principle of right and wrong. They play a vital role in medicine and are referred to as medical ethics. Medical ethics govern the medical profession by guiding physicians’ meet ethical challenges. The five most common types of ethical problems include ethical dilemma, ethical distress, the dilemma of justice, the locus of authority, and whistleblowing. The current ethical problem that is going to be discussed in this paper is an ethical dilemma. Ethical dilemma occurs when acting on one moral conviction means that another example is broken. In the article, Is Exposure to Secondhand Smoke Child Abuse? the parents are constituting child abuse by failing to remove their children from recurrent, life-threatening harm by secondhand smoke.…

    • 1245 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I feel like I am missing some information that can be crucial in this case. On the one hand, it is unknown if Jeanette was previously ill or if she was under care of the physician for any condition. If she had a history of pulmonary or heart diseases and needed to be monitored by a doctor, the physician supposed to take this call as an emergency and get back immediately. Also, receptionist in this office should be instructed to bring to the doctor’s attention any call from a medically compromised patient. In this instance, the case can be present as a legal…

    • 938 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Healthcare professionals have certain ethical and legal standards that they must uphold while practicing their profession to ensure their patients are adequately and safely cared for. They also need to understand that every patient has a right to their own healthcare decision and this can be through written consent, voicing their opinion or through an advance care directive. This essay will concentrate on how a valid and legal ACD must be completed, the importance of valid consent, ethical issues relating to the patient having their on opinion, how to advocate for a patient and lastly, comparing the legal and ethical standards nurses and paramedics abide by everyday to ensure morally safe practice.…

    • 228 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The two medical professionals are discussing protected health information in a public area without regard to the other persons in the area. The citizen walking behind the two professionals realized that they were discussing and mocking her mother. Not only is what the two medical professionals did a violation of HIPAA laws, it is also highly unprofessional and unethical.…

    • 253 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I believe because of a doctor’s critical position placed between life and death, sometimes they are obliged to play God. I do not think doctors should infringe patients’ rights by forcing their moral opinions on patients that are capable of making their own decision, but on a case by case circumstance, it might be important for a doctor to step in and make an ethical decision for a patient. In case II, the four patients were not going to gain any form of life back and were surviving because of the respirators. The patients would have remained in their same state if the nurse had not unplugged the patients from their machines. While she made a decision based on her personal beliefs, the patients were never going to regain…

    • 551 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Defendants alleged that they had no duty of reasonable care to Tatiana since she was not their patient, but that conduct turned to be a mistake because Tatiana paid for the therapist decision. On the case of Heaven v. Pender (1883) 11 Q.B.D. 503, 509 stated: “whenever one person or property is by circumstances placed in such position with regard to another… that if he did not use ordinary care and skill in is own conduct… he would cause danger of injury to the person or property of the other, a duty arises to use ordinary care and skill to avoid such danger.” This case is connected to the Tarasoff case since both defendants had the ability to prevent an incident to occur. Due to factors involved in the case the California Supreme Court held that the defendant had a duty to use reasonable care to protect Tatiana…

    • 1029 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    To act in the patients best interest should incorporate discussing the options to the patient and family in order to understand the desires of the patient. Chevrolet’s main concern is to not cause Monica to be in distress or pain – Chevrolet considers waking the patient to be a form of malpractice. His own moral speculation is affecting his judgment of the situation since he does not want to cause intentional harm to another person. However, Bernice Elger’s opposing argument takes into consideration the chance that Monica would prefer an option other than the doctor’s recommendation which explains why he states waking her up would be the best option in her interest for the long…

    • 807 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There were many errors seen in protecting the patient’s privacy. When the doctor goes to Mildred’s house, the caregiver packs Mildred’s bags for her and goes through her stuff. At the hospital while the nurses were changing Mildred, the doctor walked in with the curtain wide open. The nurse yells out that Mildred wet the bed and she needs help changing the sheets. The ward told Mildred’s daughter that her mother could not talk and when her daughter asked what else was wrong with her he said he could not give out information over the phone. He already gave out information and he went against what he said was the “hospital policy”. Also, the doctor said it was okay if her caregiver signed the consent form since Mildred is right handed and she…

    • 1122 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays