Analysis Of Antidoping Strategies In Sport By Norman C. Fost

Good Essays
In the article “Ethical and Social Issues in Antidoping Strategies in Sport” by Norman C. Fost, it gives reasons about how the prohibition drugs in athletics have moral principles. Fost is arguing about how prohibiting such drugs is no clear moral principles. I will be analyzing two argument claims in the article of Fost and will also be evaluating Frost’s argument in agreeing with his arguments and reasons.
Fost argues about what things are harmful and explains why it is not a good moral claim reason to prohibit steroids because as Fost also mentions that “two-thirds of premature mortality in the United states is attributed to personal behavior: smoking, heavy drinking, high fat diets, lack of exercise inadequate use of seat belts.” (Fost,481)
…show more content…
For example, he says “The majority of professional football players who play for five years or more develop permanent disability.” (Fost, 481) This shows how any type of sports can be dangerous and there is nothing wrong with playing a sport which means there should not be anything wrong with using steroids. Sports can be dangers and can cause serious problems in an athletics because they could harm themselves and be at risk to death and as frost says it not a good moral argument to prohibit steroids. This means that if harmful things is a good moral reason for banning steroids, then we would ban all harmful things. But we do not ban all harmful things. Therefore, harmfulness is not a good moral reason for banning …show more content…
As he mentioned by trying to take advantage to be better than your opponent is not implicitly immoral and this is correct. It is correct because all athletics want to be better than their opponents which are obvious. Athletics don’t want to lose they want to win which they take advantage of training more and practicing to be prepared.
Although in some places they do not have better equipment and coaches to help them which is unfair because other places do have good coaches and better equipment and that is unfair for other athletics. Gaining an advantage over an opponent is not implicitly unfair as the author gave his reason. Even though it is still not a good moral claim to prohibit drugs is not based on apparent moral principles because many have the access to steroids drugs.
In conclusion, based on analyzing and evaluating Fost main argument about the prohibition of drugs is not based on apparent moral principles and I think something needs to be done. I think we should consider more what is harmful and what is not. Also, we should consider that not many places will have the same access to many things but they are many different ways they can take an advantage by having better equipment to prepare, better sports clothes and to train more to have an advantage

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    From an athlete 's perspective they may see performance- enhancing drugs as just another boost to help them stay on top and nothing is wrong with a little “boost” but because of the lack of information provided to the athletes they are misinformed about what drugs they are taking or the technology of the performance-enhancing drugs such as injury prevention that can occur (Verducci). Finding such information such as performance-enhancing drugs could prevent an athlete from injuries is an even more reason for performance-enhancing drugs to be reviewed before banning them. Injury prevention could change the lives of many athletes, saving them from a lifetime of pain and misery because of a major injury an athlete was not able to fully recover…

    • 1171 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    At least in some cases, Huemer evidently believes that the government should regulate risky behavior, even if there may not be negative consequences. Additionally, Huemer largely overlooks the issue of addiction. He briefly addresses the argument that drug users may not have full autonomy over their decisions. If this is true, according to Huemer, then drugs should legal: “It is unjust to punish a person for something he is not responsible for” (PPE 588). While this reasoning is valid, Huemer does not address the claim that the government should protect the autonomy of its citizens.…

    • 704 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The lowest form of injury they documented was a bruise. After the study was concluded, researches realized that youth football wasn’t any more dangerous than most other sports children would be playing at that age. Over 90% of all players didn’t even sustain an injury that resulted in them missing a single practice. This study was the first long-term study over youth football injuries and could help change many parents opinions on the danger of the sport. The article is very accurate towards the specific subject of injuries during youth football.…

    • 983 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Banned drugs, specifically steroids, are banned for a reason. These drugs should not be legalized in sporting events. One of the most glaring rationalizations for the banning of steroids is that they are bad for the athlete’s short-term and long-term health. According to procon.org some short-term issues are: abnormalities in reproductive organs in both males and females, acne, nausea and vomiting, depression, aggressiveness,…

    • 819 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Likewise, athletes should not be required to follow concussion protocol because concussions are essentially inevitable in sports. According to the video, 1/10 football players become concussed, 35% receive more than one concussion, and between 2005-2008 40% of players continued to play after receiving a blow to the head (CNN,2012). The statistics show how frequent concussions happen to athletes and how those concussions do not always lead to fatal or serious events/problems. As a result, athletes should not be required to follow concussion protocol if they do not want…

    • 994 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Smoking Ban Essay

    • 2570 Words
    • 11 Pages

    If the government continues to declare public smoking legal, non-smokers ' health will be at serious risk as a result of the behavioral decisions made by others. As supporters of smoking bans, such as Rutherford, argue, non-smokers do not deserve to have their own health harmed by the behaviors of others. Therefore, millions of lives are detrimentally affected by secondhand smoke and the only solution to the problem is to implement smoking bans. Thus, secondhand smoke is proven to negatively affect the lives American 's and, therefore, requires government intervention in order to preserve the health of Americans. Even though many believe smoking to be a major cause of health problems facing individuals in society, others acknowledge the many health dangers present in society far more toxic than smoke.…

    • 2570 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The article said, "Performance enhancers, like steroids and other forms of doping, have a negative effect on long-term health. For than users of these enhancers are hurting themselves in the long run without on the average improving their short-term rewards from athletic competition, as long as competitors also use harmful enhancers. This is the main rationale for trying to ban steroids and other forms of doping from athletic competitions" (Gary Becker).When athletes enhance drugs they don’t just play better they get really angry to a point where they want to hurt the person they're competing…

    • 664 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    It was recommended by the DEA, FDA, and the AMA that steroids should not be treated the same as illicit drugs. Congress completely disregarded this recommendation and passed the anabolic steroid control act. I believe this action showed the moral wrongness that people had towards steroids, mostly in relation to sports, despite hard proof of health issues attached to it. When it comes to sports if people really think the use of steroids is unethical then yes it should be restricted for use in such cases, but that does not mean it needs to be made illegal for all. Another thing that caught my attention was the part about Taylor Hooten.…

    • 733 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Why Athletes Use Steroids?

    • 1403 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In some countries it is illegal to take anabolic steroids and in other countries it is illegal to sell them without a doctor’s prescription. (Fitzhugh) “In 1886 a welsh cyclist is reputed to have died after drinking a blend of cocaine, caffeine and strychnine”(Morgan,Homfray)after .Doping in sports is bad because it negatively affects an individual’s health, can cause dangerous behaviors, and can impact an athlete’s ability to compete. Athletes take steroids to try to boost their stamina and their performance but these steroids can have long-lasting physical effects.Fitzhugh emphasizes reasons “But people who use anabolic steroids take them in doses that are tens or even hundreds of times higher than natural hormone levels” (Fitzhugh). People are putting too many hormones in their body which causes their hormone levels to go up and it can be dangerous for them. Fitzhugh confirms “Side effects are most likely to be permanent in teenagers and women” (Fitzhugh) although “The unwanted side effects of anabolic steroids range from mild and temporary to…

    • 1403 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Persuasive Essay Marijuana

    • 1166 Words
    • 5 Pages

    A problem America faces today is the fight for marijuana to be legalized in all fifty states. Would it be wise for the government to legalize recreational and medical use of marijuana? The U.S. can’t come to an agreement all together just to legalize and just profit off of it by taxing marijuana. People with wide chronic pain are requesting for the use of medical weed to help take the edge off of pain because they don’t want to take pills. Pills can lead to addiction and can hurt your body over a long period of use.…

    • 1166 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays