Nelly Dean In Emily Bronte's Wuthering Heights

Great Essays
The epilogue I put above says exactly nothing related to what I wish to say about “Wuthering Heights” in this paper, but it still shows effectively it needs to take Nelly Dean to its center. David Daiches, the editor of my copy of “Wuthering Heights”, is reluctant to admit Nelly to the group of important characters of the novel without needing parenthesizes, and his very need to separately mention her name to recall her to the reader’s mind as one of the important characters shows that his reluctance is shared by the readers, as well. With her marked status as a “servant” and an “unreliable narrator”, Nelly Dean does not excite much interest: plotwise or otherwise. I suspect her underestimation as a character and an agent in the novel stemming from her status as a servant and narrator with “unreliability” is built on two major false beliefs: that Nelly Dean is merely a machinery to get the story started and continued, a mere observant as a servant and narrator, and that …show more content…
The faith in textual or linguistic truth has been shaken by Derrida and others long ago, and in the case of a novel there can be no claims to reality or reliability unless we have at least two narrators. The Victorian novel not yet making use of the postmodern literary device of multiple narrations, the criticism of unreliability must disperse through the air in the case of “Wuthering Heights”, in which the concern for reliability, to make things worse, is not on material reality, but on moral reality -even the existence of which is doubtful. The term “unreliable narrator”, in fact, is a hollow one when it is admitted that each narrator or author that makes moral judgments is the product of a certain age, psyche or political-economic mode and thus each narration is “unreliable”, wrought with the narrator’s politics. As there is nothing outside the text, there is nothing outside politics,

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    This evidence was not only irrelevant to his claim but it was also unpersuasive toward his audience. This evidence lacked the use of ethos and pathos. Another claim that was made in the text was an audience even clarifies the writer’s mind more than writing does. To support this claim, he provides his audience with an hypothetical evidence using pathos. Thompson relies too much on this theories like the “hand waving” theory but never backs up those theories with any type of reasoning nor analysis about them.…

    • 928 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The dialogue, not the description allows the reader to engage with the world the author creates. One of the reasons this sort of approach is critical is that fiction is participatory in a way the other arts are not – it invokes in us sympathy. Without making use of this faculty, the novel lacks one of the key components that makes it art. Besant then goes on to place a further restriction on what the novelist ought to write about. That is, a fiction writer should stay away from topics of which she has no experience.…

    • 2032 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Logos is one of the three basic rhetorical appeals. Logos refers to logic Ethos to the credibility of the author, and Pathos to the emotion of the audience. She refrains from Ethos since she has as she said in lines 2-3“except that of the weakest on the strongest” and in lines 4-5 “and as named itself little among English poets is unknown to your Majesty”. Thus she can not use Ethos, and Pathos would not fit into the context of the letter. The reason being that she said in lines 20-22 of her relationship with Hugo “I have no personal knowledge of this man; I have never seen his face”.…

    • 983 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A True War Story Analysis

    • 915 Words
    • 4 Pages

    How the reader feels about the war story is more important than the story itself. The details of the story do not matter because, “Absolute occurrence is irrelevant” (O’Brien, 83) The story only has to occur in the minds of the author and the reader to be true. The characters do not have to exist because outside of the mind nobody can go back in time to check the facts of the author. Nobody can question the experience of the author unless they are the author. In war a person loses their sense of reality and causes them to question what is true.…

    • 915 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This begs the question: Does Meursault have emotions that are not depicted within the novel? Based off the descriptions and information given within the novel one would presume that Meursault has no sentimental attachment to his mother, but his use of ‘Maman’ suggests otherwise. This subtlety relates to Camus’ purpose for the novel, in exploring absurdity it is presumable that there was a point in time when Camus, and Meursault alike, did not question the world and accepted life as it was. Most likely in their earlier years, which is when the attachment to Maman would have formed. Even in his existentialist ideologies, that attachment remained.…

    • 1226 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The problem here is that we don’t have, Street says, an account for how the evolution pushed us towards the independent moral truths because the best scientific attempts to explain how the evolutionary past influenced our moral judgments do not make any reference to the moral truths. The observation that the moral truth is explanatory irrelevant is not novel, it was made first by Gilbert Harman (see also (Gibbard 1990, ch6) ). Street notes that there is, in fact, an explanation that refers to moral truths (she calls in the ‘tracking account’), but there exists a better explanation that does not do so. (Street 2006, sec. 6).…

    • 1082 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Faber’s attitude toward him proves that he and Montag were not friends and Montag had never confided in him. However, Faber and Montag became close soon after this conversation because Faber realized the Montag has become obsessed with books and rebellion. Keller’s literary analysis was more against the main idea of the novel. Montag, being a dynamic character in the novel, changed his way of perceiving books into accepting them, and Keller’s discussion focuses on Montag’s community, his life, and his relationship with his…

    • 893 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Correct punctuation is not something you have to worry about in speech and Yunior clearly doesn’t care about it when writing this book. So this non-traditional writing style creates the sense that you are, again, having an informal conversation with Yunior. He is, after all, trying to create a comfortable atmosphere that doesn’t have to be formal in the slightest. Therefore, it may not be necessary to include quotation marks at all in the mind of Yunior. The initial shock the reader has about the unfamiliarity of incorrect punctuation will make the reader ask themselves why the author decided to go without the quotes.…

    • 1694 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She confines in her evidence, conceals her values, and the interest with the topic. In other words, she does not relate to anything in her writing, its transparent, and it executes her entire plea. To conclude this analysis “Reforming Immigration for Good” abandons the right of publication. Ngai’s academic approach is unappealing to the youth of Shorthorn readers, and she rarely grants the article a breath from overused factual evidence. Her weak central claim was backed up by minimal support, and she made no attempt to have common ground amongst other arguments.…

    • 988 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mr. Fowler and Sasha Part A: Self - Awareness Mr. Fowler is not promoting self-awareness in Sasha. Although he has discussed Sasha’s behavior with her parents, he has offered no help to her personally. Sasha needs to be motivated extrinsically and Mr. Holt needs to try and build on her intrinsic motivation. Mr. Fowler seems to ignore Sasha’s actions. Mr. Fowler asks Sasha to stay on task but is not making Sasha aware of what she is doing wrong, while she is actively doing it.…

    • 936 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays