Essay On Patriarchal Rule In Romeo And Juliet

Improved Essays
Coppelia Kahn 's article on Romeo And Juliet, Coming of Age in Verona, seeks to show the role of patriarchal rule in the play, as well as attempts to show how Shakespeare flipped it on its head. Without a doubt the patriarchal rule by both the Montagues and the Capulets is blatant. Both families are ran by the father figures, with the young men in the families acting as their father figure 's weapons. Kahn expresses how Shakespeare uses the patriarchal rule to allow for Romeo to temporarily escape the grasp of the patriarchal rule so that his love with Juliet can shine. Kahn argues that Romeo forgoed his role in his family for the chance at “true love”, where as Juliet effectively ran away from her more subordinate role so that she can be with …show more content…
Whereas the Capulets are just as patriarchal as the Montagues, Juliet throughout the play, other than a few points, is fiercely disloyal to her family. Her father 's explosive rage at most scared her into an immediate submission, but it of course is secretly subverted. Kahn explains how Juliet 's nurse plays Juliet 's surrogate-mother of sorts in the play. Juliet 's nurse offers advice, aids Juliet 's needs and trys to guide her onto the path of sub-servitude, so that the families honour can maintain itself. Kahn believes that the Nurse could not possibly understand that Juliet 's commitment to Romeo would be able to cause her disobedience to her family. Juliet 's disobedience the the typical female role in her family is shown by Kahn to be shown even before her love with Romeo. As Juliet 's nurse notes that most girls her age have already have had children and are ruled by their men. Kahn shows the importance of Juliet having control in her and Romeo 's romance, as it represents the theme in the play of the deconstruction of the romantic love story and the forbidden love due to a destruction of typical patriarchal relationships. Juliet is not taken by Romeo, she shares herself with Romeo by her own love 's …show more content…
The little hints of Juliet 's disobedience and Romeo being the more weak-willed character that is madly in love with Juliet. Their reliance on alternate mother and father figures, the nurse and the friar respectively, is an important aspect of the play as well, as Kahn notes it gave both characters the avenue needed to escape their patriarchal rule long enough to marry and elope. Unfortunately, as Kahn states, the death of the two was wholly inevitable, their love for each other ensured they would not let even death separate them, while their families would not let them truly love each other. Even in the end, as Kahn notes, Romeo dies alongside Juliet in the Capulet 's tomb, reversing the traditional passage of the female over to the male house, abandoning standard patriarchal ways. Their love, entombed and forbidden, a display of disobedience and a want for less hatred in their

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    So, with these three examples all including how Juliet was forced with marriage or love, coming from Paris her try to be lover, The Nurse her mother figure, and Lord and Lady Capulet her own parents, attempting to make Juliet love a person she doesn’t want to love, because Juliet loves Romeo. But, Juliet already knows that her parents will not accept the fact that Juliet loves a Montague, since the big feud between the two families was still present. Juliet’s parents still would’ve believed that Romeo was a villian just because of his name. When it is told throughout the book, he did all of his rebellious acts in order to protect Juliet, of course her parents didn’t know that, as well as Juliet not telling them that Romeo and her were seeing each other in the first place for n extended period of time. Which are reasons on why the Capulet’s wouldn’t approve, since he did so many rebellious acts that it turned off the Capulet family.…

    • 1609 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    V. 230-232) Juliet expects her nurse to take her side, however she sides with her father, to her dismay. Juliet is hurt greatly by this betrayal. Love bound by secrecy is costly; no one knows it better than Juliet Capulet. Juliet exclaims her last words, “Yea, noise? Then I’ll be brief.…

    • 366 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A key detail is that Juliet is continuously disobeying her parents without thinking of the consequences to her actions. The third detail important to the play is Friar Laurence gives Juliet a remedy which sets off a chain of terrible events which ultimately causes Romeo and Juliet to die. All of these details are significant because both Juliet and Friar…

    • 1070 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    If she is inferior to both of them, it becomes difficult to distinguish which one she should listen to. While she never expresses a problem with the internal conflict, one can assume that she struggles to become the ideal, obedient woman that society has taught her to become. In the play, she attempts to argue the suppression when her father insists that she should ignore Hamlet, but Polonious quickly corrects her by stating, “Marry, I’ll teach you. Think yourself a baby” (1.3.18). This statement by Polonious and other belittling statements throughout the play highlight just how much pressure Ophelia’s family and society place on her.…

    • 1548 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Emilia is unaware of her husband 's plans, but it is her role to do as he says; therefore, she follows orders. Emilia feels that she has no other choice but to be submissive to her husband, because society says that submission is what wives must follow. Emilia finds the time at the end of the play to break her chains and rebel against her husband. She is the one that inevitably tells of her husband 's wrongdoing and puts all the pieces together. Emilia did an act that Desdemona was not able to do, she saw through the illusion of her husband and turned against him as he did wrong.…

    • 998 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    My life is my foe 's debt"(1.5.118). Fate is now setting Romeo and Juliet up for a death trap. Since Romeo and Juliet are from households that have had ancient grudges, their parents forbid them to see each other. Fate, knowing this love shall be forbidden, brings the two closer, and Juliet has no other choice but to fall in love with Romeo. When Juliet is informed by her nurse that Romeo is a Montague, she says, "My only love, sprung from my only hate!…

    • 1033 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Instead, she manipulates both men for her own pleasure (Shakespeare 43-44). This scene with Bianca and the two men is the first sign of Bianca’s imperfection. Other than manipulation, Bianca’s true personality does not begin to show until after she is already married to Lucentio. At the end of the play when the husbands are calling their women back into the room, it is assumed that Bianca would respond because she is supposed to be obedient; however, Bianca does not listen (Shakespeare 83). The fact that Bianca refuses to listen to her husband’s orders foreshadows the issues in the future for this married couple.…

    • 1223 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ultimately, Lord Capulet and his wife should be held responsible for the untimely and tragic demise of Romeo and their daughter Juliet as they were very oppressive, caused violent tendencies with their stubborn nature, and they did not generally care about Juliet’s emotions or opinions. In the inevitably tragic play “Romeo and Juliet” by William Shakespeare, we are introduced to two young, star crossed lovers who are incredibly naive and unlucky. The two were extremely determined to make their relationship work despite the longtime feud between their respective families. However, while their love was true and intense, it wasn’t entirely at fault when it comes to their deaths. While the relationship may not have worked as Romeo is dramatic…

    • 1190 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Many believe that Romeo and Juliet’s immaturity causes them to make impetuous and rash decisions like their marriage, and that they are ultimately responsible for their deaths. Despite popular belief, In Romeo and Juliet, written by William Shakespeare, societal norms surrounding marriage and the role of parents in their childrens’ lives are at fault for the acceleration of Romeo and Juliet’s relationship, which leads to their ultimate deaths. Both the norms of only having sex once married and parents imposing marriage upon their daughters were prevalent in Romeo and Juliet’s society, which motivated the acceleration of their relationship and their seemingly impulsive marriage. It was taboo at the time to have sex before marriage, and that is shown in the following passage. When the Nurse and Lady Capulet are discussing Juliet’s potential marriage with Paris, the Nurse tells an anecdote about Juliet falling on her face when she was young.…

    • 1650 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    That night, Romeo will take you away to Mantua.” This proves that Juliet must be so in love with Romeo that if she wants to trick her families into a fake depression of being dead, that could really make her family realize how special Juliet was to them. In Act 2, scene 2, Juliet says, “O Romeo, Romeo! Wherefore art thou Romeo? Deny thy father and refuse thy name. Or, if thou wilt not, be but sworn my love, And I’ll no longer be a Capulet.” This proves that Juliet must want to be a Montague or part of a different family so that Romeo can live with her, or she can live with Romeo.…

    • 1256 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics