Occupational Health Nursing Ethics Case Study

Great Essays
Introduction Occupational health nurses face a plethora of ethical issues throughout their everyday practice. An obstacle persists when the occupational health nurse faces an ethical issue, in which they are unable to act on their ethical obligations due to a variety of constraints (Canadian Nurses Association, 2003). This phenomenon is also known as ethical distress. Ethical distress is of utmost importance as this can be an expression of a nurses’ sensitivity to the moral aspects of practice, including an acknowledgement towards the patients’ vulnerability (Canadian Nurses Association, 2003). An experience with ethical distress can lead the nurse to reflect on their personal moral code and may lead to a positive integration into one’s practice. …show more content…
Unfortunately, occupational health nurses must recognize that personal and corporate values can compete (Rogers, 2012). This may present an ethical issue in confidentiality, as nurses have a professional duty to safeguard client records. However, health records may be requested from company, resulting in conflicting interests. In this situation, the nurse must reflect upon the ethical dilemma and utilize nursing ethical principles to justify the their appropriate course of action. The ethical dilemma of patient confidentiality can be examined through the lens of various ethical principles including: autonomy, non-maleficence, beneficence and justice. Additionally, moral theories can also be applied to this ethical dilemma in order to provide insight on the issue at …show more content…
It certainly of the best interest for the employee to keep their health records safeguarded and consented upon any disclosure. However, the ethical dilemma of patient confidentiality may be challenged when disclosing certain information to the employer may actually promote the well-being of the worker. For instance, a worker may have been exposed to a workplace hazard such as constant noise pollution. Inversely, the worker may have permanent impairment in their hearing ability. If this information were to be exposed to the employer, the employer can ensure that the adequate safeguards are in place, introduce hazard surveillance systems as well as modify the workplace, in order to minimize constant

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The importance of keeping information safe and what to do to protect people information was clearly explained. A unique feature of this article is the fact that the author mentions the legal aspect of confidentiality and elaborates the components that need to be broken in other for the law to consider a breach of secrecy. The article also talks about the Human Right Act 1998 which covers all aspect of privacy and reinforces the fact that peoples’ private information should be respected. However, the author fails to mention the consequences if one fail to follow protocol and breach patient confidentiality. More research needs to be done in this particular area if more information is…

    • 2001 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Participants The participants were randomly selected and derived from licensing lists from four states. Total of 1000 nurses, 250 nurses selected from each of the four different states, and census regions in the United State of America (Maryland, Massachusetts, California and Ohio), basically to describe and assess the type, frequency, occurring rate of stress of ethical dilemmas encountered by nurses in their everyday practice, (Ulrich, 2010). The second article, a group was selected from teaching hospital in Tabriz in Iran, 345 were nurses, and in-patients were 500, selected to assess knowledge and performance about nursing ethic codes, professional ethical care from nurses' to patients' perspective.…

    • 353 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Code of Ethics (2010) was created by the NCNZ which acts to guide nurses in ethical nursing practice. InItheICodeIofIEthics (2010), the four different types of relationships that nurses have, have been acknowledged these are nurse to client, colleague, organisation and society. With use of the underlying values of ethics in nursing- Autonomy (self-determination), Beneficence (doing good), Non Maleficence (doing no harm), Justice (fairness), Confidentiality (privacy), Veracity (truthfulness), Fidelity (faithfulness), Guardianship of the environment and its resources and being professional-in relation to each of the relationships, a RN would demonstrate both a professional and ethical nursing…

    • 97 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    A professional is an expert in their field. While observing the nurse student for her three week evaluation, their appeared to be some complaints and concerns regarding her professionalism on the job. She arrives late, scrubs are wrinkled and have odor of tobacco smoke, and staff says she's not a team player. These issues are very concerning when working with the health field. Being late to work shows lack of commitment to the job, and laziness.…

    • 272 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ethics is a topic that every nurse comes in contact with on a daily basis. It determines how nurses carry out the duties of the job and how the public perceives the profession as a whole. The College of Nurses of Ontario (further referred to as CNO) has outlined the ethical standard of nursing and has created a document that all nurses can rely on to build the foundation of their ethics in the workplace. Ethics in nursing has developed and changed over the course of the existence of nursing. This evolution is important to note as it highlights how the ethics in nursing developed from physician oriented to patient oriented and how different views may be held by the patients for the role of a nurse in their healthcare.…

    • 1324 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Nurse leaders work under very stressful situations and these stressful situations can lead to ethical dilemmas which can create the potential for moral distress. Inadequate nurse leaders often fail to address ethical dilemmas which can put patients and their staff members in danger. True nurse leaders will have the courage to challenge people when they see healthcare violations. They are the ones that are able to see in ways that are out of the norm and then find solutions to help resolve these challenges. They must not be afraid to take the first steps in being a role model or help develop and practice moral courage in the nursing profession.…

    • 130 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    In my view, nursing entails giving quality care to patients while concurrently adhering with codes of conducts that are affiliated with the profession. The core values of nursing define the driving force that dictates my values and behaviors. These core values include honesty, responsibility, equality of all patients, the pursuit of new knowledge, the desire to prevent and alleviate suffering and the belief in human dignity. Nurses discharge their responsibilities and make their ethical decisions based on the framework of the ANA 2014 code of ethics. The main principles surrounding the ANA code of ethics can be categorized into, • Confidentiality, this is the protection of clients’ privileged information • Fidelity, exercising the protection…

    • 1072 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    To Detect and Mend The American Nurses Association’s [ANA] Code of Ethics are standards meant to protect not only the public but the nurses as well. Without these standards, clinicians can rationalize practices, according to their own convictions, but may not necessarily benefit the client and uphold the integrity of the profession. For instance, a nurse with substance abuse disorder can justify his action as a reasonable coping mechanism to perform his job.…

    • 572 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Moral distress is defined as an inability to act according to one’s ethical principles by the moral agent due to various influencing external constraints such as time pressures, organizational, legal, and/or authoritative barriers (as cited by Ulrich & Hamric, 2008). According to de Veer, Francke, Struijs, and Willems (2013), nurses often experience moral distress due to the inadequate staffing, job pressure, higher societal demands, and conflicts between institutional rules and one’s moral values. Moral distress can lead to disturbing consequences, such as burnout, turnover, fatigue, frustration, physical illness, anger, powerlessness, and a host of other worrisome and painful outcomes. The moral distress I had experienced is when my patient walk against the medical advice (AMA). I took care of a middle-aged Native American woman, who was admitted to the adult surgical floor after an angiogram.…

    • 1199 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In regard to these responses, one could argue that these nurses did not get a lot of support or help within the organisation and as a result it is an ongoing situation. This put forward that moral distress strongly activates the emotions of nurses compare with the Professional stress issues. In their answers, 22 nurses expressed moral distress factors as not telling the truth about patients’ health condition to patient or their family, ignoring patient 's wishes, not enough help for the patient when needed and taking unnecessary actions for patients. It can be argued that these dilemmas can generate emotional response and increase ethical issues within the institution and the…

    • 3232 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The American Nurses Association code of Ethics was created as a guide to help nurses provide quality care while ensuring that all patients are protected and treated equally. Provision four of the ANA has four key points that emphasize the nurse’s responsibility and obligation to his or her patient. The first statement touches on the nurse’s authority, accountability and responsibility for the decisions being made. The second statement emphasizes the nurse’s responsibility to make decisions and take necessary actions to promote health (ANA, 2015, p4). The decisions made by the nurse have to be justifiable and must be patient care centered.…

    • 872 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Trobec et al. (2009) concluded that nurses working in the community and psychiatric nurses recognizes the utmost importance of the code of ethics as well (Trobec et al., 2009). MacDonald (2006) also supports this finding as it was stated, “professional codes of ethics describe the ought or fundamental obligations for nurses’ moral conduct in practice.” Moreover, CLPNBC’s professional standards outlines the importance of the nurse respecting their client’s vulnerability and always acting in a professional manner insuring the maintenance of the client’s dignity. This is particularly important for those who have mental health needs and are subject to forced treatment as they are particularly vulnerable.…

    • 1563 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Information that should be kept in closed when being processed by only the authorized staff include all patient medical records ,report of communicable disease and the records that contain names and other identifying information of the patient. There are many examples about ethics that Surround confidentiality e.g wean the doctor use patient information in research without any approval from the hospital or the patient or wean doctor tall the patient conditions to someone know the patient e.g cowmen friend between doctor and patient abut patient conditions. The confidentiality concept is enshrined in law that says that: all patient have right to expect that the health care information that given to physician or healthcare professional is used only for the reason that should used for and also that it will not be used without patient permission. patient have the right to control and access to their own personal health information. Issues surround the confidentiality may be bring to a clinical ethics group in the form of considering hospital policies and ethics committee .…

    • 794 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Nurses encounter a serious amount of ethical problems when providing patient care that can lead to ethics–related stress. Ethical-related stress is an occupational stress that is emotional, physical, and psychological consequences of moral distress (Ulrich, et al., 2007). It is a general assumption that nurse leaders should provide ethical training to other staff in need by demonstrating the ethical practice and providing ethical support as well. Even when frontline nurses assume the role of leaders to enhance ethical practices, their actions to build a moral community amongst nurses cannot be sustained if they are unsupported by their formal nurse managers (Storch, Makaroff, Pauly, & Newton, 2013).…

    • 1266 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Chapter four is a very complex chapter about ethical issues and focuses on the applied ethical decision making as a critical leadership role for mangers (Marquis, 2014, p. 71). Nurses are often places in situations where they are expected to be agents for patients, physicians, and the organization simultaneously, all of which may have conflicting needs, wants and goals (Marquis, 2014, p. 71). From previous nursing classes I learned about different ethical framework including teleological, deontological, rights based reasoning, and intuitional theories, as well as different ethical principles such as autonomy, beneficence, nonmaleficence and more. This helped me analyze how nurses handle situations in a way that would uphold the American Nurses Association Code of Ethics for Nurses. However, with the world being so diverse, as a nurse you never know what type of situation your going to have to address.…

    • 1360 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays