Kurdish Nationalism: An Analysis

Great Essays
Now, how did non-Sunni Kurds approach and feel about Kurdish nationalism during its nascent stages of development? For many non-Sunni Kurds, Kurdish nationalism was just another attempt at reinforcing religious dominance over other religious communities in the area, not much different from its ethnically diverse neighbors. These minorities mostly rejected Kurdish nationalism during this period. By the 1800s many sectarian differences had come to a head after subsequent battles between the great empires in the Middle East and Islamic movements in response to European colonial exposure. The Naqshbandi Order’s popularity in Kurdistan is a testament to these factors. For instance, Shaykh Khalid, the 19th century Kurdish Naqshbandi shaykh responsible …show more content…
Yezidi Kurds in northern Iraq never transcended their religious beliefs or identity in order to partake in Kurdish nationalist movements. Nelida Fuccaro, professor at University of Exeter, in her essay “Ethnicity, State Formation, and Conscription in Postcolonial Iraq” examines the complexities of state attempts to conscript Yezidi Kurds into the Iraqi army in the 1930s. While discussing the tribal identities of Jabal Sinjar, she notes how the relationship between the Yezidi Kurds and Sunni Kurds was “scarce...and somewhat strained” (566). For this particular community of Yezidis in Northern Iraq, not only did physical boundaries separate them but the religious divisions were very poignant at times. Often during the mid-1800s, Sunni Kurdish tribal chiefs raided Yezidi villages and attempted to convert the Yezidi tribes of Jabal Sinjar. For instance, Austin Layard, a British Archeologist, during his adventures across Kurdistan in the 1848 recounts in his book Discoveries among the Ruins of Nineveh and Babylon visiting a Kurdish village run by Shaykh Kassim, who was infamous for his “hatred of Yezidis...murdering those who came within his reach” (39). In addition, the Sunni Ottoman Empire often appointed Sunni Kurds to enforce Ottoman hegemony and dominance among Yezidis. Yezidi Kurds were not interested in being swept up into what they viewed as another proselytization effort by Sunnis in the region. Ultimately, in her final remarks, Fuccaro contends that this strong religious foundation of the Yezidis prevented them from joining the Kurdish Nationalist movements in that particular era due to their Sunni dimensions and overtones (575). Clearly in this example, Kurdish nationalism is synonymous with Sunni Islam. The idea of a Kurdish nation became more and more reinforced that the

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Kurdish Nationalism

    • 1390 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Islam was the focal point of ethnic identification, a structure for launching nationalist revolts against enemies and disseminating nationalist ideas, and the reason why other Kurds of different religious persuasions refused to be involved. Moreover, Kurdish nationalism should be considered an Islamic movement. The rise of nationalism transformed the way in which Kurds understood themselves and Islam, ultimately nurturing new interpretations based on their surrounding regional circumstances. While recent manifestations of Kurdish nationalism have been associated with the Marxist and atheistic inclined Kurdistan Worker’s Party (PKK), an organization hostile to religion, it would be interesting to see how the PKK has reconciled Islam’s power in stirring up Kurdish nationalist sentiments (King 23). David McDowell actually notes that the Turkish government in 1980s exploited Islam in order to discredit the PKK and disenfranchise Muslim orthodox Kurds from it.…

    • 1390 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The paper describes Paul Bremer and the CPA’s struggle to draft a new Iraqi Constitution in the aftermath of the US invasion of Iraq in 2003. It goes into great detail how the failure in the part of the CPA actors regarding influence of religion and nationalism changed and delayed the implementation of the Iraqi constitution. Even though religion is related to the culture of the group by way of personal and collective identity, it also has a social function within the society it works. Therefore, in Post Saddam Iraq, the Grand Ayatollah Sistani was able to mobilize such functions for nationalist causes as well. Bremer and his staff were extremely uneducated about the religious and nationalistic tendencies of Post Saddam Iraq.…

    • 753 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Palestinian Nationalism

    • 1763 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Palestinian nationalism solidified as a result of British policies of divide and rule. Even though some historians date back the beginning of a Palestinian identity to the formation of the Palestinian sanjaq in 1874 (Khalidi, pp. 149-151), due to the religious attachment to Palestine as a holy land, it was far from a unified nationalist movement at that stage. The British reaction to the 1936 Great Revolt, which consisted of a brutal counterinsurgency campaign led by over 25,000 troops and dynamiting of homes, left a permanent scar on Palestinians and created an anti-colonialist sentiment which shaped the goals of the movement until 1947 when the British gave up on the Palestinian issue and handed the file to the United Nations – during the campaign, 10% of the Palestinian adult population were perished or wounded and in Jaffa alone, the British blew up 240 buildings (Bsheer, 2 Nov). The intentions of the British were clear as they exploited the situation that Palestine was a country without a political community, especially when the government appointed the well-known Zionist Herbert Samuel as the first High Commissioner.…

    • 1763 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Whether by exposure to particular Islamic nations or attempting to establish their own nation, Islam is intricately tied to the ethnic identity of the Kurds. In fact, Martin van Bruinessen notes from his field research in Kurdistan during the 1970s that many pious Muslim Kurds do not acknowledge their fellow Yezidi and Alevi Kurds as truly Kurdish (Mullas 53). Islam to them was essential to the Kurdish identity. Likewise, he notes that the Yezidis and Alevis have often seen themselves as ethnically different from their fellow Sunni Kurds, constituting a whole different type of ethnic nationalism (Mullas 53). I will go into more detail about these other Kurdish religions’ relationship to nationalism, however, what is ultimately important is that with these divisions among Kurdish groups, again the modern questions of what is a Kurd becomes intricately tied to ones’ religious inclination, particularly Islamic.…

    • 1803 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As religions grow, many interpretations come up, particularly during a time of crisis. However, many contend that organizations that have a theology which is founded on hate do not represent any of the traditions in Islam. Many devotees of Islam argue that Islam is a religion of peace. The truth of this assertion may not be entirely accurate; this is because many militant groups carry out their activities through based on a puritanical strain of Islam that is known as Jihadi Salafism. It can be described as a medieval interpretation of Islam that developed when the Arabs were not in good terms with the Europeans as well as the East Asians.…

    • 830 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Daesh: Terrorist Group

    • 1225 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Khilafa,Established in 1345 is built on prophetic methodology, unlike secular states who supposedly fight for the wrong things. Daesh does not like the USA at all, and they do not believe there is a God on their side. A most commonly heard set of words by muslims which are “Allahu Akbar” meaning“God is Greatest” is heard normally by ISIS in shaky cam footages of their attacks, as if to justify their attacks with a praise to God. What unfortunately creates more individuals to join ISIS is when there is an western intervention. Whenever the west intervenes in these situations, it causes more dispersion in the Arabian world, The Saudi Kingdom has strong belief and convictions, and we ultimately end up losing wars even if we are victorious in battles.…

    • 1225 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Indeed, it can be explained that Kurdish feudalism played a major role in promoting the notion and taking over the leadership in Kurdistan. Even though the Kurds did group themselves in various political societies during the later parts of the 19th century and in early 20th century, it was in December 1918 that the groupings of the Kurds turned political and started demanding independence through the Socialist Party of Kurdistan (SPK). Nevertheless, the feudalist aspirations of the leadership resulted to a split in SPK as some leaders supported secession while other supported autonomous. The opposing views on what was best for the Kurds meant that the Kurds found it hard to make progress with their demands. Indeed, it can be explained that Kurds found it a challenge to match the efficiently organized and operated nationalist objectives of their Turkish neighbors.…

    • 2071 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    KHILAFAT MOVEMENT: This is also one of the period of Hindu and Muslims unity as they both fight against the British. Gandhi started Non cooperative Movement against British Black laws and Muslims started their Khilafat movement because of their sentiments towards Turkish Muslims. They Both put their movement by their own way against british. Reasons Of Khilafat Movement: Khilafat Movement was a religio-political Movement launched by the Muslims from the British India to the retention from the Ottoman Caliphate or even khilafat-e-Usmania and for not letting to the Muslim holy locations go beneath control from the Non-Muslims. During the 1st World War Turkey sided against Germany and since Germany began…

    • 1061 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hussein was a Sunni Muslim, which at the time was a religious minority. Since Christians were also a minority in Iraq, they were “much more protected under the Hussein Regime than they are currently,” says Brian Katulis of the Center for American Progress. (Tobia 1). Christians were not favored under Hussein, yet they were not harmed. According to Adeed Dawisha, Professor of Political Science at Miami University, “[Under Hussein’s rule] It was understood that if you don’t interfere in politics, then you are provided with a good life.” After Hussein was captured by American forces, his regime fell and a religious civil war broke out, against all religious minorities, including Christians, that spread across the Middle East.…

    • 1184 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There is a lot of debate surrounding whether the Crusades were started by evil, unprovoked Christians that sought to defeat the advanced Muslim civilization or were the Crusaders, who were being oppressed by the Muslims, left with no choice but to protect the Holy Lands. Professor Stark seeks to prove, using actual historical data, that the later argument is the case. That in fact, the Crusaders were forced to fight in a response to the Muslim aggression. Far from being un-provoked, the crusades began after more than 300 years of Muslim…

    • 760 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays