Essay Comparing The Alamo And The Patriot

Improved Essays
The Alamo and The Patriot’s script grasp two important historical events in American history. While The Alamo focuses on the battle Texans fought against Santa Anna in 1836, The Patriot takes place in the eighteenth century during the American Revolution. The filmmakers of both films are artist who interpret meaning and not state facts like reporters. As a result, these films fail to make good history because their filmmakers manipulate the plot to where it is centered only around the American perspective. This is evident in both films through the impartial screen time each side is given and the biased development of characters.
If the filmmakers from both movies had decided to interpret the history differently and had only shown the Mexican and British perspective, the roles would have been swapped,
…show more content…
This is evident in the screen time each side is given in both films. By giving unequal screen time to both sides during a film, the filmmakers conceal the truth from the audience and do not allow the opposing side to justify their actions. In The Alamo, Santa Ana is presented in scenes only where he uses his power to remove the vulnerable Texans out of the Alamo. Further, in The Patriot, Col. Tavington is shown burning down buildings and killing innocent people. These are all expected actions of a villain in a story which follow the model that causes viewers to root for a main character against that character's enemies. Benjamin Martin, the American patriot in The Patriot, is given more screen time to justify his actions and show the audience he is only acting to defend his family’s wellbeing. Santa Ana and Col. Tavington, are the only strong leading characters from the opposing side in each film which creates a biased development of characters. Their upper hand figures and cruel characteristics create a fixed viewpoint that keeps the audience from the truth of both

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Sleuthing the Alamo: Davy Crockett’s Last Stand and Other Mysteries of the Texas Revolution draws on James E. Crisp's rich data of the Texas Revolution and his own inclusion with predisposition and fanaticism. Diving more significant into the myths incorporating the Alamo, for instance, Davy Crockett's courageous passing and the authenticity of the de la Peña diary, Crisp uncovers as of now covered truths, tunes in point-by-point counter with diverse curators (both learner and master), and searches for not to uncover the myths of the Alamo, yet rather to understand them. Crisp finally parcels his book in every chapter a major point, the extremism clear in particular variants of Sam Houston's commended talk; the perfect and frail portions of…

    • 1344 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Battle of the Alamo was a battle between Texas and Mexico. The battle of Alamo was the most famous battle out of all the other wars. There was a battle because Mexico was raiding Texas and Mexico said if the United States made Texas a state that they were going to go to war. The United States ignored Mexico, thus Mexico went to war against Texas.…

    • 320 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Mexican War began after Mexico and America reached a breaking point with each other. Tensions rose when America and Mexico could not decide on a border for Texas. Mexico believed the border was the Nueces River, but America believed the border was the Rio Grande River, this event, along with others, caused the war. The U.S. was not justified in going to war with Mexico. One reason is the people of Mexico did nothing, and America only wants to go to war so they can add another slave state to the union, and because they are hungry for more land.…

    • 194 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Gwen Barney 4-27-2015 English-5th hour Social Studies-4th hour Mexican War It wasn’t easy. This event put up a fight between America and Mexico. While many fought, others died.…

    • 658 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sleuthing the Alamo In the historical narrative, Sleuthing the Alamo, James Crisp tells his own experiences while uncovering and deciphering long lost history. He shows a great deal of determination and drive when searching to tell history as it happened, and not the way other view it. Other historians interpret, view, and translate history in all kinds of different ways and that shows through in their writings and paintings of history. This could possibly skew the past making it hard to determine between what actually happened and what people claim happened. Davy Crockett and the Alamo are a very important parts of Texas history, but their cultural meaning is not as similar to what Crisp discovers.…

    • 881 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Lucy Horn 4-27-15 English~3rd hour Social Studies~6th hour Total War In 1846 war broke out between two neighboring countries. “US historians refer to this event as ‘The Mexican War’, in Mexico its called ‘The US Invasion’ (Doc. C, paragraph 1).” The Mexican War had lasted two years, 1846 to 1848. Ten years before the war, Texas had declared its independence from Mexico in 1836. Not long before that, in 1821, Mexico had declared independence from Spain.…

    • 707 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Alamo Battle Analysis

    • 2598 Words
    • 11 Pages

    The Battle of the Alamo was a significant turning point in the war for Texas Independence. This battlefield analysis will briefly explore the reasons behind why the battle took place, the strategic significance of the Alamo, who the participants were on both sides, what actions took place, and the failures that occurred both strategic and tactically. We will present an alternate outcome of this battle and explore what may have happened if the Texan defenders would have won the battle. The failure of the Texans to defend the Alamo concentrated around their lack of accurate and timely intelligence collection, the non-reporting of actionable intelligence as it pertained to the enemy’s composition and courses of action, and failure of higher command to supply the outpost with proper logistic support.…

    • 2598 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Since the beginning, movies have always been extremely influential on society. They can be captivating, emotional, or even historical. The Patriot is just one of the many examples of a historical film. Mel Gibson plays Benjamin Martin, a simple man of South Carolina, who joins the American Revolution when the British attempt to take his farm away from him. Benjamin and his son Gabriel rally together in a militia to protect their land from the British.…

    • 1055 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In tandem with the Sleuthing the Alamo analysis, the causes, consequences, and events of the Texas Revolution have changed over time. These changes have brought new explanations and interpretations about the process of writing history. There are a dozen of materials that have been written using different perspectives over the last century. According to generations of Americans and immigrants, the genesis of Texas revolution is recounted as the simple tale of outnumbered defendants that were overwhelmed by an invading army. The defendants sacrificed their lives in order to bring into existence the Republic of Texas.…

    • 1157 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Oscar Micheaux, an independent film director would go on to become one of the most prolific black American directors of the period would enter the dialog of the mulatto with his film Within Our Gates. The issue Micheaux took on, that Griffith’s mulatto character lacked, was the idea of social constraints and dangers a mulatto character must endure. Where Griffith created a mulatto as a villain to be defeated, Micheaux exhibited a mulatto, not as a villain, but as a victim of society’s restraints due to racism. This would allow audiences a chance to view another portrayal of the mulatto character beyond that of Griffith and Hollywood, but unfortunately, unlike Hollywood’s darling film The Birth of a Nation, Micheaux’s film would not be given the viewership to help correct Griffith’s racist 1915 film. Consequently, there was not nearly enough influence given to independent directs like Micheaux to counteract the messages in Griffith’s film about mulattos, and beyond that, African Americans…

    • 1410 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In his book, Sleuthing The Alamo, James E. Crisp goes beyond the mere description of the historical events that took place during the Texas Revolution. Crisp’s passion to uncover why certain events of the Texas Revolution were remembered in a specific way, propelled him to closely examine and critically analyze the motive behind a number of writers and historians. It was this determination that forced Crisp to take no for an answer and to “attempt to separate Texas myth from Texas history”. What makes Crisp’s book Sleuthing The Alamo so unique, in contrast with most historical books, is that Crisp involves himself in his text in such a way that it becomes very personal to him. Additionally, Crisp doesn’t conceal his own personal biases as…

    • 929 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Jacob Ashcraft 24 October 2016 Texas Revolution Was Inevitable In one of the first major scholarly works on the Texas Revolution, historian Eugene C. Barker in 1928 described the conflict as a “clash of cultures.” Barker maintained that Anglo-Texans and Mexicans had little in common and, as a result, concluded that the rebellion could not have been avoided. Barker is correct in his statement about war being inevitable. Some believe it was because the Anglo colonists wanted overrun Texas and break away to become a part of the United States in the venture westward.…

    • 930 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sleuthing The Alamo In the Rhetorical analysis, Sleuthing The Alamo, James E. Crisp dives head long into an extensive evaluation of the events, people, and historical stories of the Alamo. As he began his research he stumbled across a speech written and given by Sam Houston. Houston is a well acknowled man in both Texas and U. S. history with a reputation for fairness, and being and all around good wholesome man with a polished set or morals. Upon reading a statement Houston made to his men Crisp felt as if something were wrong.…

    • 826 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Patriot’s & People’s American Revolution Comparative Essay Howard Zinn and Larry Schweikart with Michael Allen interpret American history in their respective books A People’s History of the United States and A Patriot’s History of the United States. Both books, while going in-depth in the progression of America, differ sometimes greatly in their views and opinions of events in history. Zinn differs with Schweikart and Allen in his interpretation of the American Revolution in that Zinn saw the revolution as the logical response to the oppression of Great Britain and Schweikart and Allen viewed the revolution as the glorious triumph over a great evil.…

    • 1642 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In Sexual Violence in the politics and policies of conquest: Amerindian Women and the Spanish Conquest of Alta California by Antonia I. Castaneda she talks about how Amerindian women were treated by the Spanish soldier and the terrible thing they were put through. In The Collapse of the Missions by David J. Weber he talks about the horrible way Spanish soldier treated the Indians and how they tried to “civilize” the “savage Indians” and the struggle the Indians faced trying to stop this horrible act. In Gringos, Greasers and the Southwest: Evolving Chicano Identity on the Border Region, 1850-1930 by Michael R. Ornelas. He speaks about what affected the way Chicano saw themselves as what impacted their outlook of themselves and how that form the generation to come and their identity.…

    • 1316 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays