Essay Comparing Chaucer And Marie De France

Improved Essays
Geoffrey Chaucer and Marie de France have strikingly similar themes within the Breton Lai’s they have produced within their works. A Breton Lai is a narrative form of English and French Medieval literature that usually consist of tales of Courtly love, Chivalry, and often using supernatural elements within the story as well. Both Chaucer’s work of The Wife of Bath’s tale and Breton Lais produced by Marie de France such as Bisclavret and Lanval incorporate all of these elements and they will be examined and compared in this response. The Earliest Breton Lai’s were written by Marie de France and although we have no way of knowing whether or not Chaucer read Marie de France’s works, we can clearly see a connection between the two authors as shown in The Wife Of Bath’s Tale. There is the theme of Chivalry already presented in the beginning of the tale when the Knight must prove his self-worth and innocence to the accusations of rape by finding the answer the queen so desires to …show more content…
Lanval is extremely loyal and courteous to the mysterious woman that saves his life in King Arthur’s court only revealing that he had met her to save his life and never mentioning her once as asked. The same goes for the Knight in Chaucer’s tale proving his loyalty to the agreement him and the loathly lady he came upon that also saved his life. Theseare all aspects that both Marie De France’s and Chaucer’s Lai’s share in their pieces of work. One difference I can recognize between the two is the theme of love. Love isn’t a very major theme in the Wife of Bath’s tale as it is in Lanval. Although both show devotion to the women they come across, Lanval seems to be more in love than the Knight in Chaucer’s tale. Bisclavret also shows a theme of love and how upset the aspect of love has made him due to his transformations. This seems to be a major difference between the

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In the twelfth century, a variety of different genres in poetry and storytelling started to form to celebrate the allied cultures of chivalry and courtliness. Entertainment that focused on courtliness had a very different style, subject matter, and authorship. Many of them of them were composed by women. An example would be Marie de France, author of the collection of lais and The Life of Saint Audrey. Marie de France wrote during the time that Henry II and Eleanor of Aquitaine were ruling.…

    • 1286 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Literature throughout history often has the unfortunate quality of being misogynistic, especially by modern standards. While it is certainly a stretch to say that female writers are always kinder to characters of their own sex than any male author, it may be fair to say they are at least more familiar with the difficulties their female characters face. This is why, while it would also be a stretch to call Marie de France a feminist, especially by modern standards, it may be fair to say that she recognized a woman’s position in relation to world around her. It was this understanding of her status as a woman which influenced her work, as seen in both her treatment of the Lady in her lai, Yonec, and her adulterous relationship with the fairy knight Muldumarec.…

    • 841 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Marie De France’s Lanval is one of the two Arthurian stories in her collection of Lais. Lanval is a work of a courtly romance and deals with issues of both sexuality and colonialism. More specifically, the text illustrates how women’s sexualities are treated differently in direct relation to their status within colonialism. I will argue that because Guenevere is English, her defiance is not addressed in this text because of the underlying proto-nationalist themes present in Marie’s imagining of Arthur and England as inherently deserving of ruling over Scotland. Lanval encounters both the Mysterious Woman of the borderland between Carlisle and Scotland, as well as Arthur’s wife Queen Guenevere, and throughout Lanval’s interactions with the two women, both women are assertive in their power and apparent agency in terms of their sexuality.…

    • 1687 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Lai Of Lanval Analysis

    • 555 Words
    • 3 Pages

    He desires to be loyal to his love and not disclose her existence as requested, yet he also must remain loyal to his king and not lay with his wife. Lanval chooses to announce his love to the Queen because he is angry but also to repel her advances. In maintaining loyalty to his king, he betrayed his love. The path Lanval chose was between two loyalties, and the one of greater sacrifice. This action reinforces his character by showing that given a difficult choice, he took that which caused greatest damage to himself, thus offsetting the magnitude of the betrayal via a moral…

    • 555 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Through her inclusion of “evil women” Marie challenges gender roles, critique of chivalric values, and expresses the importance of moderation. Challenging Gender Roles “Equitan” and “Bisclavret,” breaks the gender stereotypes though the use of gender reversals to present women as characters who are also capable of strength. Marie’s writing allows for women to be seen as more powerful than the image of feebleness construed in other courtly myths of her time. Both Lais contain the notion of gender reversals as the women attempt to assert dominance over their male counterpart. In “Bisclavret,” the woman adopts a courtly lover demeanor and attempts to control her lover by getting him to reveal his secret.…

    • 1490 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Merchant’s Tale follows a genre of the narrative common to the medieval French literature known as a “fabliau.” According to Christina von Nolcken “these types of stories are often short, comic, and involve a person stealing another person’s wife.” The key plot of The Merchant’s Tale fits this, especially with the stock features of the lustful old man cuckolded by a young woman. Von Nolcken continues, “part of the comedy of a fabliau of this kind is the folly of the old man who thinks he can sexually please his young, good-looking wife, and have her truthful to him”. The tale focuses on January as he appears the victim of the unfaithful wife, but his inappropriate lust and foolishness would have caused no sympathy from Chaucer's medieval audience.…

    • 997 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Anne Malory's Courtly Love

    • 1508 Words
    • 7 Pages

    A deep self-conflict appears in her presentation as both mysterious and involved in the courtly love tradition. Malory’s work showed an English preference to steep the queen’s sexuality in mystery when he removed Guinevere’s explicit scenes from Le Morte D’Arthur and Vives’ aimed to erase women from society after the loss of virginity. Mystery implied innocence through ignorance, while the courtly love tradition acknowledged sex as the end goal of a Courtly flirtation. Capellanus’ argument that the key to courtship lies in the lovers’ knowledge of the woman’s eventual submission, in Chrétien’s quick reconciliation between Lancelot and Guinevere. In 1527, this conflict shows best in her gift to Henry of a jewel that depicted a storm tossed maiden.…

    • 1508 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Love has forced Lancelot to humiliate himself: He is so lost in daydreaming about Guinevere that he ignores the multiple warnings given to him by the other knight. When he falls into the stream, ‘[his] lance fell into the stream and his shield flew from round his neck,” (833-4) leaving Lancelot disarmed once again because of foolish reasons and unable to fulfill his duties as a knight. He struggles in his battle. “[Lancelot] was…angry to be so weak today that his blows were feeble and his day wasted.” Christien is showing Lancelot to be somewhat ridiculous in his role of a knight as he attempts to excel in his role as a…

    • 934 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Women are viewed in a variety of ways, depending on culture and opinion. Chaucer’s Canterbury Tales walks us through various tales of men and their interactions with women. Chaucer also includes the tales of the Prioress, the two nuns and the Wife of Baths. From a close reading of the text, it could be assumed that women were associated with little to no value. They were used primarily for sexual reasons and weren’t considered sacred.…

    • 903 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Chaucer the Comedian (An Analysis of Chaucer’s use of Satire to Obtain His Intended Audience) From generation to generation there have always been people who want to drastically change the way the human system has been set up. Martin Luther King Jr. in the 50’s and 60’s with civil rights; or Christ himself about 2000 years ago, they wanted to change the way we a human's looked at the world. Geoffrey Chaucer, commonly referred to as the “Father of English Literature” because he was the first poet to write in vernacular English instead of Anglo-Saxton or Latin. He is also referred to as iconoclastic for the ways he attacks, most of 1300 Europe and the way it has operated for hundreds of years.…

    • 930 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Lanval’s traditional gender role has been reversed by showing his lack of power, money and actions compared to those of his lovers, whose are the complete opposite of his. She shows a power that a woman of her time could not imagine having and are normally seen in high ranking men. Whereas Lanval is showing traditional attributes that would be considered feminine if being described to…

    • 428 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In comparison to Sir Gawain and the which is a celebration of medieval chivalry knight, Lanval by Marie de France is a critique of the medieval chivalry. Even though at timed Lanval shows acts that should be praised by the chivalry system, most of the story relies on mocking this system. In Lanval we see more of a mockery towards the chivalry system. One of the biggest factors that led me to conclude this was that this poem was written by a woman.…

    • 781 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When Lanval meets his Lover’s attendants he follows them,”giving no thought to his horse.” () Him leaving his horse behind acts as him symbolically leaving behind his knighthood to join his other worldly lover. Lanval devotes himself to his new love by proclaiming,”I shall obey your command;/for you, I shall abandon everyone”() Lanval’s lover gives him anything he desires providing for him the way…

    • 1058 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Helen Rocha Per.2 SAHC:HR By looking at the Knight's and Miller's Tale in Geoffrey Chaucer's work of fiction Canterbury Tales 1476, one can see the distinctions between love and lust, and the tragic and comic endings desire, temptation, and ones emotional necessities may lead the human mind to. The Knight who portrays humorous aristocracy among pilgrims, introduces a courtly love tale that represents his social class. The Miller on the contrary represents the middle class in Medieval England, and coveys a fabliau tale, completely distinct from the Knight's tale. Both tales introduce the conventions of romance, and upshot of desire. While one tale engages on a spiritual meaningful convention of love, the other engages in sexual drive and the humiliation lechery may bring to ones table for the rest of their living.…

    • 1073 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    But as the story continues the knight faces a hard challenge, if he fails he is to be killed. In most fairy tales, there is either a problem at hand or there is a very strong point made in the short tale. In the "Wife of Bath's Tale", Chaucer makes a very good point which just about every woman could agree…

    • 630 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays