Errol Morris Will The Real Hooded Man Please Stand Up?

Superior Essays
Media, in the forms of photography, film, and writing are similar in that they often reveal a particular message, or comment on a societal aspect. For some, these messages may be underlying, while in others, they are evident and transparent. This idea helps distinguishes differences in media. Photography is widely open for interpretation. In the case of Errol Morris’ “Will the Real Hooded Man Please Stand Up?” the lack of context and textual clues make it hard to discern what was true or what the photograph claimed to show. This idea of truth is a notion Morris continues to comment on throughout his piece. He does not merely talk about truth in the context of the photographs he’s discussing, but instead truth as a universal topic, a topic we …show more content…
Photographs, in particular, are limiting in nature in that the there is more behind them then what we can see. Morris notes that often times photographs can provoke “uncritical thinking” (Morris 26) when trying to learn the truth or purpose of something, in this case, the Hooded Man images. These photographs are nonfictional, as they portray events that actually took place. These images were found on news websites and television programs, which were validated by reputable sources such as the New York Times. The medium of how these images were portrayed, the news, caused people to uncritically and undoubtedly accept their existence and truth. When an audience thinks “uncritically” engagement is absent. People tend to resist ideas that challenge their own and shy away from curiosity and questioning. As an audience, we must think critically to get any truth from photographs. In order to think critically, context is required. Context can include who the photographer is, where or when the picture was taken, or what it is portraying Context could also even be questioning the credibility of the picture’s source. Without context, we are more likely to make errors in identification when making inferences. P Morris takes readers through the story of “Hooded Man” and how he was misidentified, to show how this form of media and the medium of how something is presented, can distort our …show more content…
Similarly to Morris’s notion of”uncritical truth”, an audience may just assume that many of the events Anzaldúa described are real and did in fact happen. However, the medium of memoirs don’t simply just recall and repeat the history of one’s life, instead they enhance it. Authors often embellish certain areas of their life to seem more dramatic when trying to make a point or comment. This can make the truth hard to distinguish. There is no real way to validate the actions, events, feelings, and emotions found within the writing of a memoir. Memoirs differ from fiction in that the importance of facts are different. We don’t tend to look at the actions and events Anzaldúa describes and try to refute them, we accept them. This creates a different definition of

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    However, it fails to represent or misrepresents those ideas and values as it can pose an ideological threat to dominant groups. Furthermore, people need to understand the ways in which journalists manage the processes through which information is gathered and transformed into news. As these pressures are encouraging journalists worldwide to follow familiar patterns of news making. There are particular strengths and weaknesses in news coverage as most framing is for effect rather than ulterior motives. Few journalists nowadays do consider audience effects when they are writing, other than prohibitions.…

    • 1107 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sometimes things happen to us so quickly, that when we tell the story, it isn't exactly right when it does come down to the cold hard facts, but it as true as anything that we will ever know. Stories are not totally fact, but with interpretation they can lead us to factual events that do occur. O'Brien may have adjusted some details from his actual experience in Vietnam and deemed it a ‘fictional' book, but to him the stories he tells in The Things They Carried are very real to him. And through the use of metafiction he is able to convey this to his…

    • 860 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Photojournalists are viewers to the world around them, they see people in danger and in pain by just showing up to work. Getting involved isn’t only good for just journalists and their focuses. It can also be good for journalism as a whole and for the public (Jacobitz). Although, there will at times be some situations that can’t be controlled, there are always ways in which help can be given, it’s just what you take advantage of as an opening. Since photojournalists are in the position of being where others need assistance, they should put aside the camera when there’s a very high chance that their actions will help others or prevent harm.…

    • 1024 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He quotes from Cecil Day- Lewis from his poetic composition, “If it were clear in my mind, I should have no incentive or need to write about it . . .We do not write in order to be understood; we write in order to understand” (Thomson 51). This evidence that Thompson gave us didn’t function to make his argument stronger, therefore this evidence was unsuccessful. This evidence supports old- fashion handwriting rather than using the internet to publish and help clarify the writer’s ideas.…

    • 928 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Neutrality refers to refraining from adopting a position on the subject matter. In writing an account of the past a historian may form an opinion. This opinion should not enter the historians work as it can sway the reader into formulating an opinion based on the historians'. When a historian adds his or her personal position on the subject matter this can be seen as a move from a historian to a journalist. Ideological considerations such as theological, philosophical, materialistic or any other intellectual bias might distort his vision that is, he is not free from his own…

    • 1798 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    When people are sad, happy, angry and in this case, afraid. When people are afraid they are less likely to think and instead, react. This is known as fight or flight. Less than ethical news companies utilize this in their broadcasting to prey upon our baser instincts. They show news in a specific means that will only highlight negative aspects of a situation without covering all perspectives or details of a story to lead to a well-informed conclusion, then put the stories on repeat.…

    • 1436 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The masses frequently implement generalizations as it is simply human nature to do so, however one should be mindful to not to apply stereotypes to individuals. Above all one should take into consideration whether or not stereotypes perpetuated in the media are a true reflection of ethnic groups and individuals within these groups. Further research must be conducted before any audacious decisions are made, however if the media is ultimately found at fault for being biased one might also ponder how to adjust the media’s content in attempt to produce a more impartial…

    • 1384 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    McGinniss extrapolates events to benefit his viewpoint, and Malcolm’s interview process is biased towards those who are more willing to be interviewed. While McGinniss’s actions can be attributed to malice against his subject and Malcolm’s can be attributed to opportunism, the real reason for both of their actions is due to the bipartite nature of the story preventing an…

    • 1559 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    The majority of people believe that the media is biased but believe that the mainstream media is reporting all the information. Nonetheless, once people see something they don’t like, they notice things that reinforce the belief that there’s bias (Media Bias, 2015). According to Farhi (2012), the media themselves, do believe that there is some bias in reporting but not to the extent of one-sided favoritism. On the other hand, according to Jones (2016) the bias within certain networks is very evident. Jones (2016) claims that networks such as CNN and MSNBC are very pro-Hilary Rodham Clinton and have openly endorsed the Clinton campaign.…

    • 1272 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Further, Erikson himself did not endorse research efforts and operationalizing of his descriptions of the life stages. Consequently, there is theoretical precision it lacks rigor and…

    • 800 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays