Equality Of Opportunity In Gerald Cohen's Why Not Socialism

Brilliant Essays
Question 3: In Gerald Cohen’s Why Not Socialism, he discusses three types of equality of opportunity: bourgeois equality of opportunity, left-liberal equality of opportunity, and socialist equality of opportunity. Bourgeois equality of opportunity advocates for removal of, “socially constructed status restrictions, both formal and informal, on life chances” (Cohen, 15). Cohen explains formal and informal restrictions using the examples of serfdom in feudal times and the impact of race on life chances today. Left-liberal equality of opportunity builds off of bourgeois equality of opportunity, promoting the removal of social disadvantages such as socioeconomic status (Cohen, 16). Welfare programs are a result of the left-liberal equality of …show more content…
Children of professional families hear about eleven million words per year, while children of working-class parents hear six million and children whose families are on welfare hear three million words per year. By the time children attend kindergarten, children of professional families have heard, on average, thirty-two million more words than children from families receiving welfare benefits (Boyce, 2). Additionally, in kindergarten classrooms, a social order is established quickly and is highly correlated to socioeconomic class. Students who are considered to be of lower social standing have increased risks of depression, more classroom inattention, poorer peer relationships, and lower academic competence (Boyce, 2). As school progresses, minority students sometimes react negatively to what they perceive to be outcomes unlikely for them to achieve. For example, in some schools, poor black students develop “oppositional culture” to deprecate students who work hard in school by accusing them of “acting white” (Small et al., 10). The consequences of social standing in kindergarten has been tied to socioeconomic status and has lasting effects, as friendships grow and remain steady through grade school and learning and study habits …show more content…
Lareau discusses the influence of family background on children’s educational experiences and attainment, as her research found that socioeconomic status largely influences the quality and quantity of parent interaction with their children’s schooling. Lower socioeconomic status parents are generally uncomfortable interacting with teachers and administrators (Lareau, 75). As a result of this timidity and lack of educational success themselves, parents of lower socioeconomic status often take a passive role in their children’s education. To contrast, parents of higher socioeconomic status are comfortable communicating with teachers and administrators, especially to advocate for their children’s success. These parents are also more familiar with the class room dynamics; they have more flexible work hours, allowing them to hear about their children’s days after school or even to volunteer in the classroom (Lareau, 76). Additionally, these parents have more disposable income thus allowing them to hire help to bridge knowledge gaps their children may

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    American Dream In Crisis

    • 1902 Words
    • 8 Pages

    AP Government Book Assignment By Tristan P. Myers “Our Kids, The American Dream In Crisis” By Robert D. Putnam “Our Kids, The American Dream in Crisis,” is an interesting piece of text that compares past and present day life stories of multiple teenage children along with their families’ outlooks of the American Dream. Using both quantitative and qualitative data, author Robert D. Putnam provides an analysis that we could all relate to. Robert D. Putnam immediately informs the reader the prime reason for writing this book. Putnam writes, “...in modern America one barrier would loom much larger than it did back then: class origins.…

    • 1902 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Parental involvement and social class has a high correlation for the same reasons children in the dominant class have higher cultural capitals; economic freedom allows parents to participate more in their children’s life. Middle class parents give their children some form of cultural capital by “ reading to children, taking children to the library, attending school events, enrolling children in summer school…” (Lareau 3). Another reason as to why parents in the dominant class are more involved in their child’s education than their subordinate counterparts is because of the different views on the relationship between parents and teachers. Parents in the subordinate class view teachers one of the sole sources of their child’s education, this means that they think teachers should be the one teaching their child and not them; or, if they do get involved, it is limited.…

    • 650 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Even though school tends to encourage parents to raise their children by concerted cultivation, a philosophy of parenting in which parents tend to foster their child’s expertise by introducing multiple organized activities throughout their schedules, not everyone has access to this style of child rearing and prefers to use the accomplishment of natural growth instead, where children are free to do whatever they want during youth because adulthood is challenging. The middle-class, which seems to exercise the first one, therefore enables their children to succeed not only academically but also socially and financially. This phenomenon is emphasized by researchers and it appeared that just a few of the lowest class children whose parents followed…

    • 835 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Parental engagement is often viewed as desirable and is associated with positive school experiences and schooling outcomes. However, according to Lewis-McCoy, parental engagement is multidimensional, and beyond the positive image that is promoted there are negative dimensions as well, which affect the access if all families to a high-quality education. Some types of parental engagement made the educational terrain between white and black and between rich and poor even more uneven (66). Many parents learned about a school’s practices and opportunities via networks of parents. Lewis-McCoy observed three types of networks: formal, semi-formal and informal.…

    • 983 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In an ideal society, access to education would be portrayed as a top priority. All individuals with the desire to further pursue their education would have the necessary resources to do so. Unfortunately, this is not how societies ideals have been structured. Instead, the younger generation associates education as an unnecessary expense. This ideal fluctuates the vision set by sociologists like Marx/Engels, and Durkheim to achieve a good society, and limits upward mobility.…

    • 1682 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She points out the ideas that middle and lower class families have of language, activities, and interactions with institutions. These values that families hold correlates with the two parenting philosophies that Lareau identifies different social class families choose to utilize. Throughout her study, Lareau discusses concerted cultivation in middle class families, where parents play an active role in their children’s development. Lareau points out that in poor families, natural growth is the philosophy that parents use, where children have more freedoms and spend most of their time free of adult…

    • 1445 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sarah Garland's Article

    • 546 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Article Summary In her article “When Class Became More Important to a Child’s Education Than Race,” Sarah Garland (2013) explains how, “In 1963, kids in the 10th percentile of income fell behind children in the upper echelon of wealth by about a year or so. Today, that gap is closer to four years” (1). She does a phenomenal job at going into depth on this main idea by including factual information like dates, percentages, and resources to get her point across to the readers.…

    • 546 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Lareau's Analysis

    • 391 Words
    • 2 Pages

    When reflecting on children’s educational outcomes, including my own, it is interesting to notice that socioeconomic status plays a detrimental role in predicting educational success. Likewise, Lareau’s three explanations of social class between parents and schools enhance our understating of the connections. Lareau challenges the assumption that working class families do not value school or that they believe school is not that important. She argues that, indeed, working class families do value school and consider schools as an important aspect of their children’s lives. Similarly, Lareau disagrees with the notion that schools discriminate against working class students.…

    • 391 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Social Identity Theory

    • 1473 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Not only is this a way to maintain a sense of unity, but this is also a form of group identification that strengthens their willingness to assist their families (Telzer & Tsai et al. 76). Group identification which follows the Social Identity Theory by Tajifal state this. Due to this way of thinking, children are more concerned with family unity, rather than completing independent goals. When students have a selfless mindset of putting others before oneself, they place themselves in a complicated situation that can either result in performing poorly on a personal task such as a school assignment or risking to strain the relationship between a tight-knit family. Dennis interviewed the parents of students and obtained their views on collectivistic…

    • 1473 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Divorce In School

    • 1424 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Have you ever stopped to imagine how the different effects of student’s home lives effect their performance in school? Some of us were fortunate enough to never have to worry about the strenuous effects our home life had on our school life. The American family and culture has changed so drastically over the past twenty to thirty years, many teachers today cannot even relate to the everyday problems that the children of today are facing. This being the case, it is difficult for some teachers to help our struggling youth with the many different problems they bring to the classroom from home. Sadker, Sadker, and Zittleman (2008) suggest that the changing dynamics of families in the 21st century play an important factor in children struggling…

    • 1424 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Achievement Gap Archetypes

    • 1016 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Evan proves that high income students are more engage in school because one’s parents support one with school supplies while lower income students doesn’t have access to books and extra tutors. According to Evans “Low-income homes contained fewer books, toys, and other developmentally appropriate learning opportunities relative to middle- and upper-income homes. Half of low-income, American children between three and five years of age have 10 or more children's books in their home” (Evans). Achievement Gap can’t be close because there are many issues such as economic issues.…

    • 1016 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Welfare Reform Viewpoints

    • 256 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The welfare reform has become a controversial topic for both conservatives and liberals. Both of these groups have different ideologies and intake of welfare recipients. Conservatives claim that poverty originates in individual choices and argue that welfare programs promote laziness and single parenting, a trend that can be seen today as a consequence of the many restrictive regulations embedded in the TANF after the 1996 reform. Liberals, on the other hand, agree with the increase of government involvement in the welfare system, which has been happening more often since the recession of…

    • 256 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Who you are, what you know, and who you know can significantly can impact your education experience and how you interact with larger society. In Unequal Childhoods, Lareau explains how families social class and race lead to them having different parenting styles, which lead to the families having different interactions with other adults, siblings, educators, and medical officials. I agree with Lareau 's case about the parenting styles have an impact on how families and children interact with larger society. Lareau 's argument on how parenting and childhood vary by social class is strong because she explores many different families from different social classes and races. Lareau observed from two elementary schools and interviewed with 88…

    • 832 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The breakdown of the American family plays an important role in educational inequality; If parents are married and have a healthy relationship, it is more likely for their children to prosper, but if parents are divorced, it creates a very tense and stressful environment for the children and does not allow them to reach their true potential. “And why has the proportion of American youth who drop out of high school, especially African American and Hispanic males, remained fairly constant?” (Becker and Murphy 587). This question in Becker and Murphy’s piece, The Upside of Income Inequality, is then followed up with, “The answer to these and related questions lie partly in the breakdown of the American family, and the resulting low skill levels acquired by many children in elementary and secondary school – particularly individuals from broken households” (Becker and Murphy 587). These two quotes are the very explanation America needs to hear in order to truly understand the effect of a broken home on American students.…

    • 1533 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Lareau (2011) also says, “Working-class and poor parents sometimes were not as aware of their children’s school situation (as when their children were not doing homework),” (p.347). Children from the working-class poor typically could not get rules to work for them as middle-class children mostly could (Lareau, 2011). Lareau (2011) states about middle-class children, “Family schedules are disrupted,” (p.351). Children from this child rearing method did not spend as much time with their family members (Lareau,…

    • 1595 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays