England Was More Successful Than The Spanish Colonization Of The New World

Improved Essays
The success in the colonization of the New World depended of many factors. The English were more successful than the Spanish in colonizing the new world because England had more stability than Spain, they had a powerful army and firm government, a better economy system and a goal in mind. The Spanish focused on the “now,” on gold and exploiting the new lands. While the english had a clear plan to create a lasting future for generations to come. Although Spain made a lasting impression during the initial colonization of the New World, England was the most successful country when it came to settling in North America. Spain had many disadvantages in comparison with England. Its initial success was attributed to being the the first …show more content…
The first two successes were Jamestown and Plymouth Plantation. There were many differences between the two, such as the type of local government established, the kind of relationships maintained with the local natives and the way they became self-sufficient. The Spanish believed that the native americans were too untamed and tried to change their beliefs and religion to what they saw fit. The Spanish would force conversion upon the tribes and kill anyone who resisted their rule. Queen Isabella, like many others,believed that if these people were unaware of God they were unfit to own the land. This was a common theme through other European powers at the time. However, the English did not pursue conversion like Spain. Instead, they let the tribes continue to have religious freedom while they laid claim to the lands. Like Spain, the british also believed that the Native Americans were barbarous and unfit for ownership of land. However, they approached things with an open mind and semi discreet manner. The English would not make any kind of …show more content…
Roanoke Island founded by Sir Walter Raleigh disappeared into the wilderness and left the British as disappointed failures at colonizing the new lands. Finally on May 24, 1607 Jamestown was discovered and became the first successful settlement. It Jamestown strong military rule for much of the first decade as a colony that. They soon moved to an assembly that was "elected" by the people. Before the inhabitants of Plymouth Plantation set foot on the New World in the leaders of the expedition drew up the Mayflower Compact, by doing so they formed a civil government. This gave them claim to the land and to rule it in the name of the King. These early forms of democracy seem to have been the best way to rule, due to the many ideas and different backgrounds of many of the inhabitants. Jamestown was on shaky ground from the beginning with the natives leading to two wars with the Pawhatan Indians. They alienated any Indian allies they might have had by forcing them to bow before the King of England. Plymouth started off on the right foot by procuring the help of two English-speaking Indians. These two Natives taught colonists how cultivate corn and acted as envoys with the local natives. This allowed for extensive trade with the Indians of that

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    They received a cultural favor from Squanto and Wampanoag. Squanto was a man that assisted the pilgrims he was also a member of the Wampanoag confederacy. There were many settlers that had arrived and was moved inland. When they…

    • 771 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Also the settlers had a problem with Indians. According to Jim, “The first attempt in 1585 and 1586 failed after its members, led by Ralph Lane, warred with local Indians and were unable to establish the means to sustain themselves” (Morrison, 2006-2007). The Indians didn’t like the settlers in the New…

    • 476 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The key difference between the colonies of New Spain and New France and those of Virginia and New England was the way their settlers interacted with the surrounding Native Americans. Whether it be through exploiting the Indians for labor, as was done by the Spanish, or forging alliances with them, like the French, both New Spain and New France became frontiers of inclusion, where natives were incorporated into colonial society. On the contrary, England began massive immigration to Virginia and New England in order to provide workers for tobacco cultivation. Because its colonies were populated with families, there was no need for Indians to be incorporated into society, neither as workers nor as marriage partners. Therefore, the English set…

    • 131 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Spanish, French, and Dutch colonies in North America all interacted with the Native Americans during the 16th century. Spain’s extreme subjugating approach and views on freedom and religion differed from the accepting and collaborative views of the French and the Dutch. Although the French and Dutch had apparent positive approaches compared to Spain, oppression of the Native Americans occurred under the control of all three colonies. The Spanish were the first to colonize North America and their approach lacked moral compass.…

    • 708 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This helped to solidify the good relations that the Puritans and the Native Americans had with each other. Britain established the Jamestown and Plymouth colonies in the 1600s. Although they were both English colonies, they had differences in cooperation within their respective government assemblies. They also had different focuses on industries due to their geographic regions.…

    • 1039 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The English and Spanish differences during the Age of Exploration within their government, religion, and economy led to many advantages and disadvantages that changed the New World’s fate. The Spanish were the first to arrive to North America, and mainly wanted to explore. They were motivated by gold, glory, and god. Their government was tight, watched strictly, and rich.…

    • 629 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Whether or not a settlement succeeded depended on how the settlers relationship with three things: their people, their neighbors, and their land. The Spanish, French, Dutch and the English all had different experiences with these three things and their reaction to them decided whether or not the settlement would succeed. Looking at the English colonies: New England, Chesapeake, the Middle Colonies, South Carolina and the Indies, we can see the same three things apply.…

    • 1177 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Spanish, French, and British colonies were the three major European powers to settle in the New World. They “took lead in conquering and colonizing North America during the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries” (Tindall & Shi, 102). These three European powers so all the opportunities to advance in North America and they all succeed and failed in one way or another. When looking at reasons why they came to America, economic values (fur trading), setbacks of the region, and who was the major part of the colonies, we can really start to see the differences between each group.…

    • 587 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In Plymouth the Native Americans gave them assistance, because of the way they got along so well (Nancy Fisher, Jamestown and Plymouth: Compare and…

    • 1670 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Spanish came to the New World with the goals to prosper in wealth and to serve for God, and this newly founded New World gave the Spanish Colonies the chance to regain it's religious followers after the followers were lost to the colonies Protestant “heresy” that it once had; the Spanish colony became ‘fully catholic’ by 1492 by expelling the Muslims and Jews after 1492. The Spanish firmly believed that colony had rights to conquer and colonize the New World to spread Christianity to the Natives inhabiting the land. In the minds of the Spanish Colonists, they were saving the souls of the Native peoples even if it meant destroying their bodies. The colonists used this to justify for practically every one of the actions that they did in the New World along with the act of forced conversion on the Natives, sending out priests to aid in the conversion. The Spanish, in order to aid conversion, created the Mission System; a religious mission to convert Native peoples throughout the American Southwest and into California.…

    • 1798 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Since a major reason for the English coming to the U.S. was for trade, John Smith and the other colonists had a deceitful strategy for trading with the Indians. “Smith said, in effect, that he did not care if they did not want to trade: if they would not give him corn in exchange for the trinkets he chose to give them, he would just take it and call it his revenge for their having allowed him to be captured in their territory the previous year.” The colonists devised the perfect plan. Give the indians useless trinkets, in exchange for all the corn they could eat. The greedy colonists just wanted to take all of what the indians had, and give anything back, knowing that corn was the Indians major source of food.…

    • 705 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Spanish and English colonies were also different in terms of economic goals. As for Spain, the main reason for travelling to the New World was to create wealth. The Spanish did not plan or hope to establish permanent colonies in the Americas, but rather to find the coveted wealth and return to the Old World. Meanwhile, the English focused more on expanding into the New World with successful permanent settlements than finding wealth. The Spanish and New England colonies were slightly similar and substantially different in terms of their economic bases.…

    • 1632 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Jamestown and Massachusetts Bay Colony both had great impacts for the thirteen colonies. Jamestown was the first surviving settlement for the English in the Americas. Jamestown’s survival caused more settlers to come to the Americas in the belief that they too could survive. The Puritans of Massachusetts Bay colony believed only Puritans should have a “voice” over the colony. Non-puritans left Massachusetts to start a new colony because they didn’t want to be pressured to follow the beliefs of the Puritans.…

    • 722 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The English used these marriages as a way to get the natives to change their ways voluntarily by marrying into a Puritan community. Like the colonies’ views on intermarrying with the native tribes, the Spanish and English were also largely similar in terms of enslaving the native people. The Spanish were nearly completely reliant on slavery. In Spanish colonies, the encomienda system, forcing the Indians to work for and pay tribute to the Spanish in return for protection and entrance into heaven through conversion to Catholicism, were placed upon the natives.…

    • 2387 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Eventually, some of the local tribe helped the settlers. Capahowasic and Nantaquond were among others who guided the settlers to safety. William Bradford viewed the Native Americans as a positive thing, and they viewed the Pilgrims as good people. Since they missed the planting season, there only hope was from the local Indian tribe. Squanto was a local Native American who the Pilgrims established a healthy relationship with.…

    • 903 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays