Case Study: Draingo

Improved Essays
DrainGo is facing significant issues with employee morale and customer satisfaction, which directly impacts the company’s bottom line. The low morale is a result of a poorly designed business model, where the tasks required of employees are not properly aligned with the skillset of these individuals. The most evident misalignment, is that of the order processing clerks, who are not properly trained to assess the complexity of each job, resulting in the improper allocation of resources to jobs. These order processing clerks might be competent individuals, but they are forced to adhere to a faulty process in which they ask customers detailed questions they are unable to explain in detail. This lack of knowledge is frustrating to customers, …show more content…
Given that analysis, how could you make the proposed reward system work better?
One of the major issues present in Cooper’s solution is employees must feel that the level of effort they put into their job will result in reaching their performance goals. While the monetary reward is enticing, without proper training, the order processing clerks will find difficulty attaining their goals, and will not be motivated if they feel they lack sufficient knowledge to drive performance based on their efforts. The primary issue the plumbers and plumbers assistants face is related to the misallocation of resources to jobs. Since this is not an activity they even contribute to, their customer service performance cannot directly be attributed to their efforts. Furthermore, the billing representatives are completely ignored in this compensation scheme. This will create a substantial decrease in motivation for these employees once they witness their co-workers being compensated for their efforts and they are
…show more content…
Describe how you could help employees feel more satisfied with their work by redesigning their jobs. Be specific as to your suggested redesign(s) and be sure to explain your rationale behind each redesigned job.
One of the major issues present in the job design at DrainGo is extremely low employee autonomy, where no one is responsible, or even aware of their contributions to the other processes; each individual is a cog in the machine with very little understanding of what the other cogs do. The order processors are assigned the task of assigning workers to customer, and they have limited depth of knowledge of the questions they are told to ask the customers and are unfamiliar with the terms. The plumbers and plumber’s assistants are forced to handle customers that are angry over rescheduling or high fees resulting from improperly dispatched jobs. If the order processer assigns a job to a plumber’s assistant that requires greater technical expertise, they must reschedule a plumber to do the work, or if a plumber is assigned to a menial job that a plumber’s assistant could handle. The billing representatives are then forced to deal with these angry customers, who were not involved in any of the prior processes, and lack even a basic understanding of the work

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The four culture beliefs of Sam’s are respect for the individual, service to our customers, strive for excellence, and act with integrity these help the company stay strong with people. Having respect for employees and its customer is a great way to show that a company not only cares about the money being made but the people contributing. This culture belief started when the company was small as a way to show its employees and customers they are valued. Ways to show respect is by listing to its employees and then being able to communicate back to them the results. Sam’s has a Sundown policy this is when an employee voices their issues to members of management the manager has until the end of the day to give that employee an answer.…

    • 1086 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Analysis of Lincoln Electric Company’s Culture The Lincoln Electric Company can attribute much of its long lasting success to the organizational structure and culture. The company continues to realize economic and productivity growth, year over year due to their unique company culture. In Arthur Sharplin’s “The Lincoln Electric Company” case study, we are able to analyze how the organic company structure and founder values produced a unique a combination of an outcome-oriented and people-oriented culture. Lincoln Electric Company was founded in 1885 by John C. Lincoln.…

    • 883 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Project Description Richard Lee, President of Elgin Technology Products is considering to stablish a new customer services system. Mr. Lee wants to implement a way to rewards his customers based on their relationship to the company. Basically the problem is about setting the right expectations for the clients in regards of timing and also treat them fairly. Resolving customer’s problems in a short period of time definitely helps to customer satisfaction however Mr. Lee must be 100% commit to be able to do it. Even if its four hours or next day resolutions for customer issues, all alternatives should be consider.…

    • 719 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In our personal experiences, we have seen that employees who are underpaid according to their efforts or who are not provided appropriate opportunities for growth end up leaving the company. Employees who are rewarded in relation to their efforts remain committed and encouraged to work well and may even take on additional responsibilities. Leaders are responsible for ensuring that people are rewarded according to their efforts. In some cases, employees are even willing to accept lower wages as long as they are appreciated for their efforts and given a chance for personal…

    • 1046 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Harrah Case Study

    • 1322 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Winn should assist Loveman and other’s to develop a communication campaign around how the gain sharing is calculated and paid, why it is important to the organizations goals and objectives, as well as how it can impact long-term financial gains. In its current state, the gain sharing program is not tied to financial performance. Going forward, communications around how customer service correlates to the business bottom line may prove to be insightful for employees to connect their direct impact with the businesses overall success. In agreement with Ed Rylant, employees require communication, feedback, and a voice in order to be successful (Delong & Vijayaraghavan, 2003). I also feel it would be advantageous to reward those (outside of the gain sharing reward) that suggest ideas and live the Harrah’s model of providing the best customer experience through spot bonuses.…

    • 1322 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Costco Training Method

    • 136 Words
    • 1 Pages

    For the job training, employees in an organization can learn and practice from the real situation because the situation can help employees see the whole picture of their work areas and they can understand and can apply to solve the situation when something have happen. This training method suits to Costco because it has many positions that work day to day in stores such as a cashier person, an inventory person, a checking stock person and a staff in a store. Georgellis & Lange found that “the need for further research to explicitly include on-the-job training as an important facet of job satisfaction [and] the importance of both on-the-job training and job satisfaction to influence labour productivity” (2007, n.p.). On the job training and…

    • 136 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Wells Fargo’s Ethical Scandal It was a bank heist greater than the Brink's job in 1950, however, the brigands used no ordinary firearms or getaway vehicles. As opposed to being quick on the draw, they had quick fingers on computer keyboard and mouse. Over the course of four years, The Wells Fargo Bank of San Francisco, had at least 5,000 employees opened more than a million fake bank and credit card account on behalf of innocent customers. This monumental scandal that broke the basic principle of ‘doing ethical business,’ has also brought many other issues to light. Some of these include the lack of integrity from the people who lead this organization who lied and denied the fraud, the deficiency to properly run a mega-organization, the indignation from the people affected by this fraud, the lack of ownership when a mistake is made.…

    • 913 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In conjunction with monetary rewards and use of intrinsic motivation can enhance the effects of the pay for performance plans by raising the personal attachment to the project matching employees to tasks based on skills and interest. 5) There are few exceptions to be followed in respect to the pay for performance…

    • 885 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Pomeroy Case

    • 201 Words
    • 1 Pages

    Pomeroy was hired by a Fortune 20 supermarket client. With annual revenue of over one billion dollars, the retailer operates nearly 2,800 retail, food, drug, jewelry, and chain stores. (Pomeroy, n.d.). The company asked the execution to occur in parallel with another system-wide deployment to resolve other critical issues. The clients’ Network Data Security included their stores operating on single, open network where store-wide devices capable of transmitting, receiving and storing confidential customer data of one department.…

    • 201 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Motivation comes from job content factors like responsibility and growth/advancement. The technicians need and expect compensation and incentives in order to support themselves and their families. Even Sonny Gassiott, the District Operations Manager in New Orleans, recognized that money is not the only motivators. He admitted that “it’s just not as simple as thinking ‘if I pay him [a technician] a dollar more, he’ll work that much harder’” (Hall,…

    • 1271 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Winn’s customer service achievement plan included a bonus payout program in which management paid employees a bonus of up to $200 if the employees fulfilled the quarterly customer satisfaction goal, regardless of operating income results. Harrah’s measured customer satisfaction through monthly customer surveys, in which patrons graded by a letter system, A through F. Winn discussed the strategy behind the program “If a department could convert 4% of non-A’s to A’s, it would qualify for a bonus,” this plan results in “more than $16 million in bonuses to non-management employees.” To provide the best solution to Loveman, Winn had to weigh the costs and benefits of either keeping, revising, or replacing the current bonus payout program. If Winn were to decide to replace the program, she would face more costs than benefits. Although the program’s emphasis on reaching goals and competition could be exhausting to some employees, any plan of this nature would have the same effect.…

    • 1107 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the case given, the problem in Perfect Pizzeria, a large pizza franchise in Illinois, is a disparate treatment between unqualified managers and employees that cause the lack of motivation and poor job satisfaction. Motivation and job satisfaction is very important fundamental notions to keep the business in prospering and increase the profit to be succeed. Motivation allows any employees to help them perform optimally and increase their productive and job satisfaction makes them to work in the same place for a long time. Most workers are motivated to work harder depends on how much do they fulfill the expectancy in the workplace. To motivate employees, managers must have the ability of perceiving and providing individual incentives.…

    • 842 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Today humans are considered as one of every company’s most important assets, so they efforts need to be efficiently and effectively rewarded. Compensation is a main factor for organization to attract, retain and motivate its workforce. Individuals look for jobs that not only suit their abilities and talents, but compensate them accordingly in terms of salaries and other benefits. "The term employee benefits refer to compensation other than an hourly wage or salary. Examples of specific employee benefits include paid vacation, medical insurance coverage, and tuition reimbursement, but the number of employee benefits can be staggering” (Martocchio, 2014).…

    • 1182 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This is why motivation and rewards can be one of the keys to a successful organisation. The use of rewards and motives in a work place can lead to higher productivity as workers have something to strive for. This can also have a knock on effect to the overall profits and brand reputation made as employees are more dedicated to the brand, as they want to earn the rewards and be recognised for their efforts. Mckenzie and Tullock (2012), with reference to Maslow’s hierarchy of needs, suggest that employees need to be appreciated to gain self-fulfilment, which can be gained by reward and peer/ colleague recognition. As reported by Forbes (2012) research showed that 83% of the organisations they studied lacked in staff recognition.…

    • 721 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Cathay Pacific Airline was founded in 1946, standing with their vision: To become the world’s best airline wouldn’t be achievable without the commitment of our people (Cathaypacific.com, 2015). Cathay Pacific Airline then named as Cathay Pacific Airways, and becomes one of the world’s leading airlines (Worldairlineawards.com, 2015). To maintain this position, the commitment of employees becomes to be the origin issue, where job satisfaction helps to determine the degree of commitment of employees (Luthans, 1998). 3.…

    • 1228 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays